The novel The Hermit Doctor of Gaya: A Love Story of Modern India was published a hundred years ago, in 1916, by IAR Wylie (1885-1959), a writer who in her lifetime and in her writing flouted many accepted conventions of her day. Ida Alexa Ross Wylie – her name was derived from both her parents – used her initials as a writer. Women writers of her time either did this or used pseudonyms.
In choosing to set five of her novels in India, all among her early work, Wylie also turned on its head one of the cardinal rules of writing – about knowing a place well in a true literary sense, before writing about it. She had never been to India, and as she mentioned later in her memoirs, she imagined her stories from the ones recounted by an old roommate.
It’s a long-running debate. The Swedish novelist, Katarina Bivald’s recent novel, The Readers of Broken Wheel Recommend, published in the US to some acclaim, is set in a town in east central Iowa, a place Bivald herself has never visited. Book-loving Sara comes from Sweden to meet Amy, her pen pal with whom she has corresponded over two years, a friendship forged by their mutual love for books and reading, only to learn of Amy’s recent death. Yet Sara stays on, opens a bookstore, and becomes a friend and confidante to all those who come by.
Adventure, love and intrigue in colonial India
India, envisioned as a land of adventure, strange mysticism and esoteric spirituality, was already a popular subject for writers in Wylie’s time –in the novels of Rudyard Kipling and Flora Annie Steel, for instance. But Wylie, it is evident, wasn’t merely a good listener and reader; her novels reveal her political sense and understanding of contemporary issues and debates.
The novel begins with a tale made popular by the British colonial official and folk-tale collector Colonel James Tod in his Annals and Antiquities of Rajasthan. It’s a story about the letter written by the queen of Mewar, Rani Karnavati, to Humayun, seeking his support against Bahadur Shah of Gujarat. It enclosed a rakhi making the Mughal emperor, in Wylie’s words, the queen’s “bracelet brother”. And this is what, despite their unassuaged, dimly acknowledged passion for each other, the dancer Sigrid Fersen, in Wylie’s novel, calls Tristram, the eponymous hermit doctor of Gaya.
That Wylie had great hopes from this novel is evident from the fact that the two novels published a year apart – Tristram Sahib in 1915 and this one in 1916 – are actually the same work. But Wylie moved publishers, choosing to move from Mills and Boon (yes!) to the more respectable GP Putnam’s Sons.
Entwined in this novel of complicated love between Sigrid and Tristram are myriad other subplots. It is Tristram’s trusted valet, Ayeshi, whom he had once saved from a snake bite, who narrates the popular folk tale. Yet Ayeshi reneges, becomes a turncoat for reasons hard to fathom – possibly to save his master Tristram from accusations that the latter was responsible for injuries sustained by Colonel Boucicault, the reviled head of the regiment stationed at Gaya.
The closed and complex world of the "sahib"
High Society life in Gaya is comfortable, yet constricted and rigidly conventional: life for the British, with the native Rajah (Rasuldu) as a necessary adjunct, is centred around tea parties and polo games. There are necessary friendships hinged around secrets never aired. This equilibrium is upset when Sigrid Fersen, the dancer of some disrepute, arrives.
Sigrid’s reasons for coming to Gaya are, just like much else in this novel, hard to fathom. She is a guest of the raja who thinks this ought to make her literally dance to his tune. There’s the merchant Mr Barclay, not accepted by the English because he is “half-caste”, whose desire to be accepted make him pursue Sigrid and propose to her.
Into these very humane complications Wylie also brings in the divisive issues of economy and religion, and the supposedly unbridgeable differences between East and West, symbolized by the bridge that, as the army regiment says, can never be built over “Mother Ganges”. It’s the river that separates Gaya from Heerut, where a cholera epidemic has broken out.
Heerut’s weavers and farmers are hapless and desperate, and Mr Barclay wants them beholden to him, promising them returns, though his real intentions are to constrict the flow of goods from Manchester – an argument against deindustrialization, except that in Barclay’s case it seems entirely self-serving.
Reason vs unreason
Strangely, the two people who are obviously in love with each other choose to marry different people. And this – it happens midway through the novel and so isn’t a spoiler – is one of the fascinating things in the novel about how Wylie tries to unravel the many ways reasonable people make unreasonable decisions. Happiness, as Sigrid and Tristram argue with each other, could mean a life well-lived, or rightly lived.
Wylie’s characters have their own complexities. Heroism isn’t glorified, and while Major Tristram takes immense risks when serving the cholera-stricken villages, he is also, in his very sick state, being reckless and silly. Colonel Boucicault is a hated bully, but lost in his own demons of loneliness. His wife, on the other hand, rejoices in her own mad freedom as her husband lies paralysed.
An unconventional writer
Wylie, in her personal life, had unconventional views on a great many things. As she narrates in her memoirs, My Life with George, she became Independent very early on, travelling by ship to Norway when barely a teenager. In London of the early twentieth century, she described herself as a “militant suffragist”. She was drawn to the struggle for voting rights for she understood the desire for independence and self-reliance that women felt. She shared their sufferings and humiliation as they were beaten back by the police and jeered at by crowds: all this made her fiercely dedicated to the suffragist cause. In 1920, she moved to the US and with a fellow suffragette and companion, Rachel Barrett, driving all the way from New York to Hollywood to begin a new career.
The film version
Stronger Than Death (1920), the film made in the silent era based on The Hermit Doctor, was one of the first films made on Wylie’s books. There would be thirty more from this time onward till 1953. Stronger Than Death was the dream production of the temperamental, brilliant Russian émigré dancer actor Alla Nazimova. The film had Bhogwan Singh, one of the early Indian actors in Hollywood, playing Ayeshi.
Another of Wylie’s novels was adapted into the Spencer Tracy-Katherine Hepburn starrer Keeper of the Flame (1942). The death of a noted leader, Robert Forrest, is mourned by many Americans, but as a journalist seeks to unearth details of Forrest’s life in the hope of writing his biography, some unsavoury details emerge: of Forrest and his backers seeking divisive electoral tactics to win power. Its theme seems to eerie reflect present day political concerns in the US.
Wylie lived on in the US till her death in 1959. Her long-time companion was the pioneering American doctor and writer, Sarah Josephine Baker. Though Wylie was a prolific writer, in an interview dated 1921, she was pessimistic about the future of the novel. She expected that the novel would no longer be in existence in “about ten and fifteen years” – a fear she articulated long before the digital invasion and the end of bookshops. The reason for the decline, according to Wylie was that too many writers “were affected by the virus of psycho-analysis and morbid introspection”.
The novel as form has survived, though Wylie is little read today. A few of her novels, including The Hermit Doctor, in recent years have been digitised.