Policing the police

Extra-judicial killings by army, CRPF not covered by recent Supreme Court guidelines

Activists welcome Tuesday's Supreme Court guidelines but wish they'd gone further.

The Supreme Court’s guidelines on Tuesday making it mandatory for a magistrate to investigate so-called encounter deaths ‒ the euphemism for extra-judicial killings ‒ are a big step towards addressing the high number of extra-judicial deaths in India, say human rights activists. But many believe that the judgement may have missed out key issues.

On Tuesday, in response to a case filed by the People’s Union for Civil Liberties, the apex court issued a set of 16 guidelines to ensure that investigations into police encounters are carried out effectively and independently.

The guidelines include mandatory registration of first information reports in cases of encounter deaths, a magisterial inquiry into the case, investigations either by the Crime Investigation Department or another independent agency and holding back out-of-turn promotions or gallantry awards for police officers until the genuineness of the encounter is determined.

Since many encounters are conducted after alleged tip-offs about criminal activity from intelligence agencies, the Court now mandates that such tip-offs have to be recorded in writing before an operation is carried out.

News of encounter deaths are not surprising in India any more. Some high-profile cases such as the Ishrat Jahan and Sohrabuddin Sheikh cases in Gujarat have made encounters almost synonymous with fake encounters.

But the National Crime Records Bureau, which provides official data on crime statistics in the country, lists only a negligible number of fake encounters in its records. Between 2000 and 2013, for instance, the NCRB records only 19 registered cases of fake encounter killings, but no convictions.

It is other agencies, such as the National Human Rights Commission  and the Human Rights Watch, that provide alternative statistics on encounter killings.

According to activists, most encounters are passed off in police records as firing of other kinds. According to 2013 NCRB data, for instance, there were 684 instances of "police firing" across the country, which killed 103 people. These occasions are classified under riot control, anti-dacoity operations, action against terrorists and extremists and "others".

While taking note of this official data, the Supreme Court judgement mentions that the same NCRB report lists only two encounter deaths in India in 2013, both in Assam. “The figure raises doubts about its correctness,” the judgement says.

What the judgement is missing

While welcoming the Court’s judgement, some human rights activists believe its scope could have been widened to include other security forces too.

“As of now the judgement is confined to the police, but I wish it also covered security forces covered under the Armed Forces Special Powers Act,” said Babloo Loitongbam, the director of Human Rights Alert, a non-profit organisation in Manipur, a state where activists have consistently been protesting the atrocities committed by the armed forces.“Before 2012, 80% of Manipur’s encounter deaths were carried out by such forces, not the police, and the number of deaths sometimes went up to 500 a year.”

In September 2012, an organisation called Extra-judicial Execution Victims Families Association, Manipur filed a case in the Supreme Court demanding proper investigation into more than 1,500 encounter deaths over the years. The Court appointed a commission under Justice Santosh Hegde to randomly investigate a few cases, which were all found to be fake encounters, said Loitongbam. “Since then, the number of encounters has dropped sharply in Manipur,” he said.

Stringent monitoring

In addition to having a judgement that applies all security forces, activists point out the need for police reforms and more stringent monitoring of cases by the courts themselves.

“One of the reasons for fake encounters is that the police personnel often find it difficult to prove cases against criminals, and they decide to act as their own judges through encounters,” said Meenakshi Ganguly, the South Asia director at international non-profit Human Rights Watch. “This can change if the police is given better support and training in collecting evidence and ensuring the safety of witnesses.”

Human rights lawyer Vijay Hiremath points out the glitches in the Sohrabuddin Sheikh encounter trial to emphasise the need to have more pro-active courts. “[BJP president] Amit Shah has not been attending court hearings even though he is a murder accused in the case, and the prosecution is not even opposing his requests for exemption from the hearings,” said Hiremath. “So even if investigations into encounters are carried out by independent agencies, it would not be enough until courts are also more stringent.”

Support our journalism by subscribing to Scroll+ here. We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BY 

Get ready for an 80-hour shopping marathon

Here are some tips that’ll help you take the lead.

Starting 16th July at 4:00pm, Flipkart will be hosting its Big Shopping Days sale over 3 days (till 19th July). This mega online shopping event is just what a sale should be, promising not just the best discounts but also buying options such as no cost EMIs, buyback guarantee and product exchanges. A shopping festival this big, packed with deals that you can’t get yourself to refuse, can get overwhelming. So don’t worry, we’re here to tell you why Big Shopping Days is the only sale you need, with these helpful hints and highlights.

Samsung Galaxy On Nxt (64 GB)

A host of entertainment options, latest security features and a 13 MP rear camera that has mastered light come packed in sleek metal unibody. The sale offers an almost 40% discount on the price. Moreover, there is a buyback guarantee which is part of the deal.

Original price: Rs. 17,900

Big Shopping Days price: Rs. 10,900

Samsung 32 inches HD Ready LED TV

Another blockbuster deal in the sale catalogue is this audio and visual delight. Apart from a discount of 41%, the deal promises no-cost EMIs up to 12 months.

Original price: Rs. 28,890

Big Shopping Days price: Rs. 10,900

Intel Core I3 equipped laptops

These laptops will make a thoughtful college send-off gift or any gift for that matter. Since the festive season is around the corner, you might want to make use of this sale to bring your A-game to family festivities.

Original price: Rs. 25,590

Big Shopping Days price: Rs. 21,900


If you’ve been planning a mid-year wardrobe refresh, Flipkart’s got you covered. The Big Shopping Days offer 50% to 80% discount on men’s clothing. You can pick from a host of top brands including Adidas and Wrangler.

With more sale hours, Flipkart’s Big Shopping Days sale ensures we can spend more time perusing and purchasing these deals. Apart from the above-mentioned products, you can expect up to 80% discount across categories including mobiles, appliances, electronics, fashion, beauty, home and furniture.

Features like blockbuster deals that are refreshed every 8 hours along with a price crash, rush hour deals from 4-6 PM on the starting day and first-time product discounts makes this a shopping experience that will have you exclaiming “Sale ho to aisi! (warna na ho)”

Set your reminders and mark your calendar, Flipkart’s Big Shopping Days starts 16th July, 4 PM and end on 19th July. To participate in 80 hours of shopping madness, click here.


This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of Flipkart and not by the Scroll editorial team.