Legal reform

Why many states are using the 1923 Goondas Act to curb digital piracy

The music industry has discovered that amending the age-old statute makes it easier to get the police to take action against people who violate copyright laws.

In mid-July, the Karnataka legislature amended its Prevention of Dangerous Activities Act, popularly called the Goondas Act, to bring digital pirates under its purview. Two weeks later, the law returned to the news. The Bengaluru police announced that it would charge two men accused of raping a schoolgirl under the same statute.

So what is this act that seems to be able to tackle both illegal music downloaders and sexual offenders?

The Goondas Act, first enacted in 1923 in Bengal, lives on in nine states in India, one in Pakistan and across Bangladesh. The law was initially intended to prevent habitual defenders from repeating their crimes through preventive detention. Typical versions of the law today allow the police to keep people in jail for up to a year, with reviews every three months.

It might seem excessive for people guilty of downloading ebooks.

Tamil Nadu takes the lead 

Tamil Nadu was the first state in 2004 to bring digital pirates under the ambit of its version of the Goondas Act. Maharashtra followed suit in 2009. Andhra Pradesh in 2010 suggested that it would also like to amend its Goondas Act to include video piracy.

These are just states that already have Goondas Acts.

Since last year, the Bengali music industry has been lobbying for the West Bengal government to introduce their own version of the Goondas Act and make music piracy a primary offence. Punjab’s music industry has been demanding this since 2006.

“Stricter laws on software piracy only help the big fish in the software, publications and music markets, which typically lobby with governments to increase their profits,” said Prashant Mali, a cyber-law advocate. “But clubbing technology-related laws and the Goonda Act is a bad idea with disproportionate punishment.”

Despite the overlap with the centre’s Copyright Act and the Information Technology Act, states have been the ones pushing for stricter controls on digital piracy. There is a simple explanation for this.

“When the companies whose digital assets are being infringed upon want to take criminal action, they have to rely on police,” said Pavan Duggal, a Supreme Court lawyer. “Since the management of police is a state subject, it makes sense for them to push for more powers to the police to cover acts relating to digital piracy.”

Hold-all act

The Goondas Act is just the sort of hold-all statute that can cover such offences without requiring too much legislative mobilisation. In a typical iteration of the act, a person can be charged if the state suspects that he or she is planning to conduct an illegal activity. This hypothetically means that anyone who possesses a pirated digital copy of any film, book, image or song – or ever used any social media – is liable to see the inside of a jail cell for a year.

“The Goondas Act was essentially invoked against people who were history-sheeters and suspects when the police couldn't find evidence to put them away for a crime they had already committed,” said Sanjay Hegde, a Supreme Court lawyer and former standing counsel of Karnataka for over a decade. “As long as the act applied to bootleggers and rowdies, the public applauded. Now that its reach is being expanded to people like us, people are pointing out its propensity to being misused.”

In 2010, Tamil Nadu admitted that it had imprisoned 675 people under the Goondas Act, its highest number since 2002.

Expanding footprint

The southern state had reignited interest in the act with its controversial 2004 amendment. The law had dipped out of use almost entirely after Independence. In 1960, the Supreme Court struck down Madhya Pradesh’s Central Provinces and Berar Goondas Act of 1946 for having an unreasonable definition of the term “goonda”.

After that, there was a decade-long lull before a host of states, starting with Uttar Pradesh in 1970, began to enact their own versions of the Goondas Act. By the end of the '80s, Gujarat, Maharashtra, Rajasthan and all south Indian states except Kerala had their versions of these acts.

“Those took off after the Emergency, where you had MISA [Maintenance of Internal Security Act] and the PDA [Preventive Detention Act],” said Hegde. “These laws were replicated at the state level. You might have safeguards put into the law, but they are actually not complied with and judicial redress is also not available.”

“The problem is that we are going towards a nanny state,” said Hegde. “Every government department wants to control everything a citizen does. They want teeth, but they can’t think of anything beyond detention.”

We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content  BY 

Understanding the engineering behind race cars

Every little element in these machines is designed to achieve power and speed.

All racing cars including stock, rally or Formula 1 cars are specially built to push the limits of achievable speed. F1 cars can accelerate to 90 km/h in less than two seconds and touch top speeds of over 320 km/h. Stock cars also typically achieve over 300 km/h. So what makes these cars go so fast? A powerful engine is combined with several other components that are relentlessly optimized to contribute to the vehicle’s speed. All these components can be grouped under four crucial elements:

Aerodynamics 

The fastest cars are the most aerodynamic. A sleek, streamlined design is a head-turner, but its primary function is to limit wind resistance against the vehicle. If a car is built to cut through the wind rather than push against it, it will travel faster and also use less fuel in the process. To further improve the aerodynamic quality of the car, everything from the wheel arcs and lights to the door handles and side mirrors are integrated into the overall structure to reduce the drag - the friction and resistance of the wind. For some varieties of race cars, automobile designers also reduce the shape and size of the car rear by designing the back of the car so that it tapers. This design innovation is called a lift-back or Kammback. Since aerodynamics is crucial to the speed of cars, many sports cars are even tested in wind tunnels

Power

All race car engines are designed to provide more horsepower to the car and propel it further, faster. The engines are designed with carburetors to allow more air and fuel to flow into them. Many sports and racing cars also have a dual-shift gear system that allows drivers to change gears faster. The shift time—or the brief time interval between gear changes when power delivery is momentarily interrupted—can be as little as 8 milliseconds with this gear system. Faster gear shifts enable the car to travel at their fastest possible speeds in shorter times.

Control

The ability to turn corners at higher speeds is crucial while racing and racing cars are often designed so that their floors are flat to maximize the downforce. Downforce is a downwards thrust that is created in a vehicle when it is in motion. This force exerts more pressure on the tyres increasing their grip on the road, and thereby enabling the car to travel faster through corners. The downforce can be so strong that at around 175 km/h, even if the road surface were turned upside down, the car would stick to the surface. Many racing cars like the Volkswagen Polo R WRC are even equipped with a large rear wing that helps generate extra downforce.

Weight

The total weight of the car and its distribution is a critical part of race car design. All race cars are made of durable but extremely light material that reduces the weight of the vehicle. Every part of the vehicle is evaluated and components that are not strictly required in the race car—such as trunks or back seats—are eliminated. The weight distribution in these cars is carefully calibrated since at high speeds it proves crucial to car control. As a result, almost all racing cars have an RMR configuration or a Rear Mid-engine, Rear-wheel-drive layout where the engine is situated at around the middle of the car (but closer to the rear than the front), just behind the passenger compartment. This layout where the car is a little heavier towards the rear than the front allows for better control of the car at high speeds.

Only the most cutting edge technology is used to develop modern race cars and as a result, they are normally far more expensive to buy and more difficult to maintain than regular ones. But your dream of owning a race car does not need to remain a dream. The Volkswagen GTI, part of the award-winning VW GTI family, is now coming to India. Since 1979, these sporty and powerful cars have been dominating roads and rally race tracks.

With a sleek aerodynamic build, a great power-to-weight ratio and 7-speed dual-shift gears, the Volkswagen GTI is the most accessible race car experience available in India. Packed with 189 bhp/ 192 PS, the car is capable of doing 0-100 km/h in just 7.2 seconds and boasts a top speed of 233 km/h. And though the car is built to be quick and powerful, it is also strong on fuel economy with an outstanding mileage of 16.34 km/l. To experience what it is like to drive a race car, book a test drive now.

This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of Volkswagen and not by the Scroll editorial team.