× Close

At the Karachi Literature Festival, the real stories were of India and Pakistan

A number of sessions focussed on the relations between the two countries.

On a column in the lobby of the Beach Luxury Hotel in Karachi, an image of my dead friend Sabeen Mahmud looked out at the crowds pouring in for the Karachi Literature Festival 2016. Sabeen had been selected by popular vote as Herald magazine’s Person of the Year. It was the cover of this magazine that was taped up on the pillar in the lobby.

The year before, too, Herald’s Person of the Year was a young person who had become a casualty of religiously motivated terrorism. The list of unwitting heroes and shaheeds in Pakistan’s face-off with indigenous terror outfits grows longer, and the dead ever younger. Appropriately, this year’s literature festival in Karachi saw themes of communal and religious violence run concurrently in a number of sessions.

Of intolerance here there and everywhere

Among the people who would have recognised Sabeen on the magazine cover when walking by were the festival delegates from India. Sabeen was always a champion of better relations between India and Pakistan, and had arranged or collaborated on several amazing initiatives to promote civil-society dialogue and understanding between the two countries. And because it can never be far from the issue of communal and religious divisions, another major theme at this year’s KLF was relations between Pakistan and India.

In fact, Sanjay Rajoura, a stand-up comic from Delhi who performed on Friday evening at the KLF, had first performed in Pakistan in 2012 at a Pakistan-India Social Media Mela arranged by Sabeen’s organisation, PeaceNiche; and Barkha Dutt, consulting editor at NDTV, who launched a book at this year’s KLF, had been denied a visa for that same Social Media Mela.

It is events like the KLF and the SMM that provide small, precious opportunities for citizens from the two countries to interface and to examine each other from what can sometimes be an uncomfortable proximity, an example of which festival goers saw on Friday.

Rajoura intentionally came out on stage at the KLF with satirical guns blazing, referring to the Partition, Hindu-Muslim relations and Jinnah sahib’s political motivations pretty much within the first five minutes of his performance. When a lady in the audience just couldn’t take it anymore and hotly shouted, “Don’t you say anything against Jinnah!” the rest of the crowd shushed her, and when Rajoura appealed for a more questioning approach to political authority, the crowd cheered him on.

This became one of the many moments in this year’s KLF that were cause for hope on the mottled spectrum of Indo-Pak relations. What initially started as a depressing scenario, with the controversy over visa applications and cancelled sessions with celebrity actors, eventually turned into something far more positive. Dutt and transgender rights activist Laxmi Tripathi easily emerged as the stars of KLF 2016, both speaking to jampacked halls and bringing the focus back onto important issues while maintaining their status as celebrities in their own right.

At a session titled “Words and Images of the Day”, Dutt overshadowed fellow panelists Olivier Truc and Farhan Bokhari in terms of popularity, so much so that when it was time for the Q&A, every single question from the audience was directed at her.

It was obvious from the audience interaction that people were watching Indian news channels, and were concerned about developments in India that pointed towards a growing culture of religious intolerance, especially towards minorities. But Dutt refused to be defeatist, and suggested that the stronger culture that prevailed in India was one of criticising the State and speaking out against oppression and intolerance. “I don’t know why the idea persists that one cannot be patriotic and support the armed forces of one’s country (as I do mine), and still criticise the government and be anti-war,” she said.

When questioned on the role of media in propagating misunderstanding and hatred between India and Pakistan, she acknowledged that media on both sides of the border did play this card for ratings, but reminded the audience that privately owned media was still very young in South Asia, and that it would take some time yet to find an equilibrium. She also maintained that it was not the medium that was the problem – it was the people behind it. Anchorpersons and producers had it in their power to propagate a pro-peace message, using the same medium, and there were those within the industry who did use it for that purpose.

And how will we have peace?

Similar areas of focus emerged at other sessions in the festival. At a book launch marking the 60th anniversary of Khushwant Singh’s Train to Pakistan, which was printed by the Oxford University Press for the first time in this country (prompting one of the session’s eminent panelists to quip, “Looks like the train has finally reached Pakistan,”), the discussion turned towards communal violence.

Artist and film producer Naz Ikramullah vividly recalled how quickly the mood had turned ugly on the streets in Calcutta at the time of the Partition. She was a child then, living in a Muslim neighbourhood, and she remembered talk of dressing the children up in Western clothes and sending them out into the crowds so as not to give away which community they were from. She also remembered a Sikh neighbour who had come to warn them when a large cross was painted outside their house to mark their family as a target.

This was not the case always, of course, as there were innumerable cases of neighbours having attacked each other rather than extending their protection to families who were at risk. Historian Barbara Metcalf, also on the panel, commented on this particular aspect of communal relations in the subcontinent and the horrifying ease with which people who had lived in the same street for years could suddenly turn on each other.

There was reason to believe in a better outcome, though. The one thing that had emerged with certainty over years of research, she said, was that communal violence could be virtually eradicated if there was political will to eradicate it.

These questions of political will and the role of government and policy in preventing violence and discrimination against minority communities were also raised in “The White Stripe on the National Flag”, a session on the status of minorities in Pakistan. The infamous blasphemy law was mentioned prominently for having provided legal cover for action against members of minority communities, as well as mainstream Muslims.

Author and Christian missionary Father John O’ Brien stated with conviction that every single case brought against Christians under Pakistan’s blasphemy law, when investigated, had turned out to be motivated by matters of property, caste, personal jealousy, or money. The Christian community was unable to depend on the government for any real remedial action on this front or in the matter of communal violence, he noted sternly. “After every incident, there is a noble apology and the promise that this will not happen again – until, six months later, it does.”

Never one to be cowed down by political correctness, social worker and politician Shaheen Attiq-ur-Rahman gave a blistering critique of city elites, stressing that if minorities were in a poor shape in Pakistan today, it was because not enough of the elites took notice or spoke up when they should have. “We must take responsibility,” she asserted, to ringing applause from the audience.

Adding an interesting perspective to this, Sono Khangarani, Director at Thardeep Rural Development Programme, brought up the valid point that minorities’ representatives in the political arena were also to blame. There seemed to be the same faces appearing over and over again, favoured by political parties, and forming an elite of their own – bringing their ability to represent minority communities into question.

Come together

Many of these underlying themes (division, community, identity, representation, violence, the role of elites, and the connection of all of these to the State) came full circle in one of the final sessions of the festival, titled “What keeps us apart? – India-Pakistan relations”.

Wonderfully moderated by FS Aijazuddin, the final question put to the panelists was: who were the two parties on either side of the border whom we could feasibly put our faith in to finally usher in peace between the two countries?

Congress politician Salman Khurshid, said that in his view hope lay with the people of both countries. If the citizens were to demand better relations, governments had to comply. Former Pakistani Foreign Minister Hina Rabbani Khar responded that she would take a more pragmatic view. In her opinion, it would take two leaders who were willing to stop being politicians and to start acting like statesmen. If that were to happen, Khar said, it would be a matter of months for peace to be a reality.

Khurshid Mahmud Kasuri, who served as Foreign Minister in the Musharraf Administration, said the answer was simple: India and Pakistan. Only genuine efforts across the board by both stakeholders to achieve peace could actually bring it about. Intentions were everything.

At this point, the moderator decided to abandon the customary Q&A segment in favour of a small exercise. He posed a few rudimentary questions about Hindu and Sikh religious beliefs and rituals to the audience, to test its general knowledge of two of the largest faiths of the region, represented by millions of South Asians. Out of a crowd of many hundreds in the main garden of the Beach Luxury Hotel, perhaps two people raised their hands to show that they knew the answers.

There could not have been a more compelling demonstration of the desperate need for communal and cross-border interaction.

One of Sabeen Mahmud’s favourite mottos (subverted from a popular message on the back of Pakistani trucks) came to mind, more poignantly than ever before:

Fasla na rakhain. Pyaar honay dain.

We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BULLETIN BY 

What to look for when buying your first car in India

Hint: It doesn’t have to be a small car.

When it comes to buying their first car, more Indians are making unconventional choices. Indian car buyers in 2016 are looking for an automobile that is a symbol of their aspirations and sets them apart from the herd. Here are a few things you should consider when buying your first car:

Look beyond small cars

According to the JD Power India Escaped Study (2015), the percentage of new-vehicle shoppers who considered a small car reduced by 20% over three years—from 65% to 45%. Buyers are now looking at bigger, affordable cars and luckily for them, there are more choices available. Known as compact sedans, these cars offer the features of a sedan, are larger than hatchbacks and contain a boot. These sedans offer the comfort and features that once only belonged to expensive luxury cars but at a price that’s within the reach of a first-time car buyer.

Design and styling is important but don’t forget utility.

It’s a good idea to have a car that has been designed over the past three years and doesn’t look outdated. Features like alloy wheels and dual beam headlamps add to the style quotient of your vehicle so consider those. Additionally, look for a car with a sturdy build quality since Indian urban conditions may not always be kind to your car and may furnish it with scrapes and dents along the way.

Image Credit: Volkswagen
Image Credit: Volkswagen

Does it test-drive well?

In 2014, 35% of new-vehicle buyers researched vehicles when they were buying but by 2015, this number had risen to nearly 41% according to the JD Power study. While the internet is the primary source of research in India, the best source of information about a car is always a test drive. Listen to the sales person and read all online reviews, but test every feature to your satisfaction.

Where do you plan to drive?

Look for a car that’s spacious and comfortable while being easy to drive or park on our crowded city roads. Compact sedans are perfectly suited for Indian driving conditions. Some of them come with parking assistance and rear view cameras, rain sensors and front fog lights with static cornering that are excellent driving aids. If you plan to use the car for long drives, compact sedans that provide cruise control, a tilt and telescopic adjustable steering wheel and a front centre armrest would be perfect. On road trips with family members who usually pack more than necessary, extra elbow room inside and good boot-space is a blessing.

Is the model about to be discontinued?

Never buy a model that is going to be discontinued because it could result in difficulty finding spare parts. Buying an old model will also affect your resale value later. In 2015, according to the same report, 10% of shoppers considered newly launched car models as against 7% in 2013—a strong indication that newer models are being preferred to old ones.

Diesel or petrol?

Diesel and petrol cars have different advantages, and it’s best to take a decision based on the distance you plan to drive on a regular basis. While petrol cars are usually priced lower and are more cost effective when it comes to service and maintenance, diesel cars typically have better mileage due to higher efficiency and provide a smoother drive due to higher torque. Additionally, diesel is the cheaper fuel. So it makes more economic sense to buy a diesel car if you are driving long distances every day.

Most importantly, safety always comes first.

Look for a car that is built sturdy and pays extra attention to safety features like Anti-lock Braking Systems (ABS), side impact bars and dual front airbags. Safety is also a function of the design and features such as a galvanized steel body add to the strength of the build. It’s important to remember not to make trade-offs on safety for less important features when choosing variants.

Buying your first car is an important milestone in life. And the new Volkswagen Ameo has been designed with several first-in-segment features to cater to all the needs of a first-time car buyer in India. Its bold design and elegant styling along with state-of-the-art features like cruise control, reverse parking camera and sensors, and intelligent rain sensors set it apart from other cars in its class. Its safety features are also a notch above, with dual front airbags that are standard in every variant and side impact bars. A sturdy galvanized steel body and laser welded roof cocoon its passengers from harm, and its modern ABS, that is also standard in all variants, prevents the wheels from locking when you brake hard. A six-year perforation warranty and a three-year paint warranty ensure that the car body is protected from scratches and dents. The Ameo comes in both petrol and diesel variants. Check out all the features of the Ameo here. Also hear the experience of two first time car buyers in the video below.


This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of Volkswagen and not by the Scroll editorial team.

× Close