Opinion

The stark difference in the Godhra and Gulberg sentences shows why the death penalty should go

From Mumbai 1992-’93 to Gujarat 2002, it is clear that the death penalty is used to disproportionately target disempowered minorities.

On a day when a court sentenced 24 people to prison – with no death penalties – for the 2002 Gulberg Society massacre in Ahmedabad, it might be illuminating to discuss how exactly the death penalty works in India.

India’s judiciary has a rule of thumb for awarding the death penalty: only rarest of the rare murders qualify. What qualifies for this standard, though, depends on the interpretation of the individual judge.

Take the massacre at Gulberg Society on February 28, 2002. A Hindu mob attacked the Muslim apartment complex, killing up to 69 people. Is killing scores of Indians in broad daylight a “rarest of the rare” case? How about the brutality of the crime? Here’s an excerpt from a Times of India report on how Ehsan Jaafri, a resident of Gulberg and former member of Parliament, was killed.

"According to eyewitnesses, Ehsan Jaafri was pulled out of his house around 3.30 pm, stripped, paraded naked and asked to say Jai Shri Ram and Vande Mataram. He refused. His fingers were then chopped off and he was then parade around the locality badly injured. His hands and feet were then cut off, and he was dragged down the road with a fork-like instrument at his throat before being thrown into a fire."

If he wanted, Jaafri could have run away before the mob descended. But he stuck on, turning his home into a refuge for the Muslims of the area – only to meet this gory death.

Unfair system

Although India’s legal system did not hold up Jaafri’s slow torture and death to be a “rarest of the rare” case fit for the death penalty, it did sentence 11 Muslims to death in the Godhra train burning case. That tragedy occurred the day before the Gulberg massacre, and left 59 Hindus dead. The sentence was passed even as the man alleged by the prosecution to be the mastermind of the train burning was actually acquitted by the courts for want of any evidence – sowing deep doubts about the prosecution’s entire case.

These sentences make it clear that when it comes to navigating the Indian legal system, the dice is heavily loaded against disempowered minorities. This isn't the case only in Gujarat. Take, for example, the violence that convulsed Mumbai in 1992-’93 in the wake of the demolition of the Babri Masjid.

The bomb blasts of March 1993, which left 257 people dead, resulted in 100 Muslims being convicted. Ten people were sentenced to death, though the Supreme Court later commuted the sentences of all but one of them to life.

However, the blasts had been triggered by large-scale riots in the preceding months that left 900 people dead, most of them Muslim. For this violence, only three people have been convicted, that to only for the minor offense of carrying arms.

Another example: the 2006 Khairlanji massacre in Maharashtra where a mob of the dominant Kunbi caste killed four members of a Mahar family. This is what the Frontline reported:

"Before sunset on September 29, a mob of about 40 Kunbis from Khairlanji entered Bhotmange’s hut and dragged out his wife, daughter and two sons. Forty-year-old Surekha, 17-year-old Priyanka, 19-year-old Roshan and 21-year-old Sudhir were stripped naked and paraded to the village square where the women were probably raped. All of them were beaten with bicycle chains and other implements and their leg bones were broken, presumably to prevent their escape. Finally, they were killed by axe blows. According to the forensic report, they died from 'intracranial haemorrhage and neurogenic shock'. The bodies were loaded on to a bullock cart and dumped in a canal about two kilometres away."

In spite of this terrible brutality, the anti-Dalit violence of Khairlanj did not qualify as a “rarest of the rare” case. In 2010, the Bombay High Court commuted a trial court’s death-penalty to life imprisonment.

Endemic bias

The bias against minorities in India’s legal system is pervasive and endemic: an astonishing 94% of Indians on death row for terror offences are either Muslim or Dalit.

These examples and statistics point to just how broken the idea of the death penalty is. In the US, the country which legally executes the largest number of people every year, research has found glaring biases in how racial minorities are treated. A 2007 study of death sentences by Yale University School of Law concluded that Black defendants receive the death penalty at three times the rate of white defendants in cases where the victims are white. A 2013 study by the University of Maryland revealed that Black defendants facing trial are more than three times as likely to face a possible death sentence than White criminals.

There are many reasons to abolish the death penalty. As the United Nations General Assembly stated in 2010, “There is no conclusive evidence of the deterrent value of the death penalty."

The everyday bias in which the death penalty is disproportionately applied to minorities – violating every tenet of natural justice – means that this method of punishment has no place in any modern society. At a more fundamental level, this method of punishment is against human rights. No crime can justify the abrogation of the right to life of another human.

We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BY 

Children's Day is not for children alone

It’s also a time for adults to revisit their childhood.

Most adults look at childhood wistfully, as a time when the biggest worry was a scraped knee, every adult was a source of chocolate and every fight lasted only till the next playtime. Since time immemorial, children seem to have nailed the art of being joyful, and adults can learn a thing or two about stress-free living from them. Now it’s that time of the year again when children are celebrated for...simply being children, and let it serve as a timely reminder for adults to board that imaginary time machine and revisit their childhood. If you’re unable to unbuckle yourself from your adult seat, here is some inspiration.

Start small, by doodling at the back page of your to-do diary as a throwback to that ancient school tradition. If you’re more confident, you could even start your own comic strip featuring people in your lives. You can caricaturise them or attribute them animal personalities for the sake of humour. Stuck in a boring meeting? Draw your boss with mouse ears or your coffee with radioactive powers. Just make sure you give your colleagues aliases.

Pull a prank, those not resulting in revenue losses of course. Prank calls, creeping up behind someone…pull them out from your memory and watch as everyone has a good laugh. Dress up a little quirky for work. It’s time you tried those colourful ties, or tastefully mismatched socks. Dress as your favourite cartoon characters someday – it’s as easy as choosing a ponytail-style, drawing a scar on your forehead or converting a bath towel into a cape. Even dinner can be full of childish fun. No, you don’t have to eat spinach if you don’t like it. Use the available cutlery and bust out your favourite tunes. Spoons and forks are good enough for any beat and for the rest, count on your voice to belt out any pitch. Better yet, stream the classic cartoons of your childhood instead of binge watching drama or news; they seem even funnier as an adult. If you prefer reading before bedtime, do a reread of your favourite childhood book(s). You’ll be surprised by their timeless wisdom.

A regular day has scope for childhood indulgences in every nook and cranny. While walking down a lane, challenge your friend to a non-stop game of hopscotch till the end of the tiled footpath. If you’re of a petite frame, insist on a ride in the trolley as you about picking items in the supermarket. Challenge your fellow gym goers and trainers to a hula hoop routine, and beat ‘em to it!

Children have an incredible ability to be completely immersed in the moment during play, and acting like one benefits adults too. Just count the moments of precious laughter you will have added to your day in the process. So, take time to indulge yourself and celebrate life with child-like abandon, as the video below shows.

Play

This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of SBI Life and not by the Scroll editorial team.