× Close
caste relations

Son marries outside caste, father files copyright case protecting use of family name

Case demonstrates innovative tactics families are employing to stop inter-caste marriages, say activists.

A Bihari lawyer, Sidh Nath Sharma, has filed a case against his son demanding that he stop using their family name after he married a lower caste woman. If his son, Sushant Jasu, continues to use his name, he should pay him Rs 10,000 in copyright fees every time he uses it, Sharma demanded.

Sharma, a Bhumihar Brahmin, claims that by marrying outside their caste, his son has not only hurt him, but damaged his social reputation. He is seeking Rs 1 lakh as compensation for all the time and money he spent bringing up his son.

Jasu is a tax official working in Gujarat. Jasu's wife, who is unnamed in an AFP report about the story, is a bank officer from Danapur. Sharma's wife and the rest of his family, who all attended Jasu’s wedding, support the son's decision.

“This just points to how caste reproduces itself,” said Suryakant Waghmore, a professor at the Tata Institute of Social Sciences. “Even the most irrelevant law can be used very innovatively to perpetrate caste matters. Constitutionally speaking, this case should not even have been registered.”

According to a 2013 study by Princeton, only 6.14 per cent of marriages in Bihar are between people of different castes, compared to a national average of 11 per cent. Of these, 3.62 per cent of inter-caste marriages involved women marrying men of upper castes. Bihar also grants Rs 50,000 to all Bihari Hindu women who marry outside their caste.

Activists working in Bihar say this is a wholly unprecedented case. “The fact that he has sued his son is very bizarre,” said Father Philip Manthra, president of the People’s Union for Civil Liberties in Bihar. "This case is definitely an anomaly." Cases of inter-caste marriages are usually dealt with by khaps and other traditional caste associations, he said.

These associations employ a range of tactics to pressure people not to marry across caste lines. Violence is not uncommon, though there are no official figures for such crimes.

When he heard about the story, copyright lawyer Avesh Kayser said, “This is utter stupidity. Where is the question of copyright in this? It is a person’s personal name. I can understand if the name was a trademark, but even so, if I were named Ratan Tata or Anil Ambani and I started a proprietorial business, there is nothing either of them could do to stop me.”

However, now that it is in court, Sharma’s case will have to be weighed on the merits of the law. The case will be heard on January 25.

“For the sake of argument, a surname could possibly belong to a family, but once a personal name is added to it, it assumes an entirely different identity,” said Kayser.

“Even if the copyright over the surname does belong to the family, it was not created by the father,” he added. “By Indian laws, copyrights cease to exist 60 years after the death of the creator. Therefore the surname cannot be considered to be the family’s copyright.”

For now, Sharma has agreed to withdraw his case if his son divorces his wife -- with her consent -- and marries a woman of his own caste.

Waghmore rubbished this idea. “If the son has any sense, he’ll drop his surname now that he has already crossed caste boundaries,” he said.
We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BULLETIN BY 

Athleisure is the new black

This new fashion trend sweeping across the country demands your attention.

A portmanteau of 'Athletic' and 'Leisure', the rising trend of 2015 – athleisure is a huge nod to two great trends that have taken hold of the fashion world: fitness and casualness. While Jane Fonda might have had the jump on this trend 30 years ago, it has only become a phenomenon after 2010 as the wellness industry started booming.

Not like we were not working out before. The Juicy Couture sweatpants of the 90s, the ubiquity of the sweatshirt from classrooms to boardrooms (we're looking at you Zuckerberg) were a precursor to this movement.

High fashion has lapped up athleisure because it brings with it the promise of functionality. High performance fabrics do most of the heavy lifting, from odour control to sweat proofing, using breathable fabrics, lending support and shaping, and helping in getting the maximum out of your ensemble. The focus on style ensures that the clothes travel easily from gym to work to bar (probably juice bar). The tectonic shift has been in not keeping high performance workout gear restricted to the gym alone.

This is the only fashion trend, other than jeans, to trickle up rather than trickle down; and the designers have responded accordingly. Taking it a notch higher into the Sports Luxe category, there is a Karl Lagerfeld sweatshirt and couture sneakers from Chanel; there is Alexander Wang teaming up with Adidas and giving us sweats that are so sleek they can and have been worn on the red carpet. Victoria’s Secret has a new active wear line and even Beyonce has debuted Ivy Park, her active wear line with TopShop, signalling peak athleisure. This is a trend that shows off the body rather than hides it, and with Fit being the new Rich, style and fitness coalesce to make it the break out trend of the season.

While it is an inducement for fitness, it is not for the fit people exclusively. It allows you to live out the fitness fantasy without actually doing a lot of the work. Fatigue from the skinny jeans has made the market welcome comfortable yoga pants; a trend that refuses to go away! Started as a largely female focused trend, companies like Lululemon and SweatBetty bet big on the athleisure lifestyle and are now multimillion dollar companies that make the best yoga leggings in the business. Athleisure became more male friendly with compression pants and puffer jackets that kept you cool in the summer and warm in the winter all the while being a snug fit. Even sneakers have never seen such an all-time high in the market as they do now, with Yeezy’s, Air Jordan’s, to the Adidas superstar fetching top dollar and we have athleisure to thank for that.


It is one of the few moments when fashion is not being merely whimsical; it is actually listening to what people want to wear and what makes sense according to their evolving lifestyles. Paying heed to this gap in the market of a population that runs on Fitbit and counts its calories has paid out and proven to be a win-win for both the brands and the buyers.

Ajio brings athleisure to Indian shores with its Active Capsule collections. The handpicked Too Fit to Quit capsule provides a range of sweatshirts, t-shirts, running shorts and track pants to work out or lounge around in. The casual style is carried over to accessories as well as a great range of bags and sneakers. Along with a versatile portfolio of Puma, Vans, Wrangler, Lee, Skechers etc it also has an in-house line in fitness apparel that mixes Indian tastes with urban contemporary. Head over to Ajio.com, the aisle of style to shop this trend.

This article was produced on behalf of Ajio.com by the Scroll.in marketing team and not by the Scroll.in editorial staff.

× Close