Title

× Close
caste relations

Son marries outside caste, father files copyright case protecting use of family name

Case demonstrates innovative tactics families are employing to stop inter-caste marriages, say activists.

A Bihari lawyer, Sidh Nath Sharma, has filed a case against his son demanding that he stop using their family name after he married a lower caste woman. If his son, Sushant Jasu, continues to use his name, he should pay him Rs 10,000 in copyright fees every time he uses it, Sharma demanded.

Sharma, a Bhumihar Brahmin, claims that by marrying outside their caste, his son has not only hurt him, but damaged his social reputation. He is seeking Rs 1 lakh as compensation for all the time and money he spent bringing up his son.

Jasu is a tax official working in Gujarat. Jasu's wife, who is unnamed in an AFP report about the story, is a bank officer from Danapur. Sharma's wife and the rest of his family, who all attended Jasu’s wedding, support the son's decision.

“This just points to how caste reproduces itself,” said Suryakant Waghmore, a professor at the Tata Institute of Social Sciences. “Even the most irrelevant law can be used very innovatively to perpetrate caste matters. Constitutionally speaking, this case should not even have been registered.”

According to a 2013 study by Princeton, only 6.14 per cent of marriages in Bihar are between people of different castes, compared to a national average of 11 per cent. Of these, 3.62 per cent of inter-caste marriages involved women marrying men of upper castes. Bihar also grants Rs 50,000 to all Bihari Hindu women who marry outside their caste.

Activists working in Bihar say this is a wholly unprecedented case. “The fact that he has sued his son is very bizarre,” said Father Philip Manthra, president of the People’s Union for Civil Liberties in Bihar. "This case is definitely an anomaly." Cases of inter-caste marriages are usually dealt with by khaps and other traditional caste associations, he said.

These associations employ a range of tactics to pressure people not to marry across caste lines. Violence is not uncommon, though there are no official figures for such crimes.

When he heard about the story, copyright lawyer Avesh Kayser said, “This is utter stupidity. Where is the question of copyright in this? It is a person’s personal name. I can understand if the name was a trademark, but even so, if I were named Ratan Tata or Anil Ambani and I started a proprietorial business, there is nothing either of them could do to stop me.”

However, now that it is in court, Sharma’s case will have to be weighed on the merits of the law. The case will be heard on January 25.

“For the sake of argument, a surname could possibly belong to a family, but once a personal name is added to it, it assumes an entirely different identity,” said Kayser.

“Even if the copyright over the surname does belong to the family, it was not created by the father,” he added. “By Indian laws, copyrights cease to exist 60 years after the death of the creator. Therefore the surname cannot be considered to be the family’s copyright.”

For now, Sharma has agreed to withdraw his case if his son divorces his wife -- with her consent -- and marries a woman of his own caste.

Waghmore rubbished this idea. “If the son has any sense, he’ll drop his surname now that he has already crossed caste boundaries,” he said.
We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BULLETIN BY 

Five foods that could be included in your balanced breakfast today

It has become a cliché to say that ‘breakfast is the most important meal of the day’, but like all clichés there is a ring of truth to it.

Starting the day with breakfast is a simple way to make a difference to the overall well-being of an individual. In spite of the several benefits of breakfast consumption, the phenomenon of skipping breakfast is widely prevalent, especially in an urban set-up where mornings are really rushed.

The ‘India Breakfast Habits Study’ has revealed that one in four urban Indians claim to skip breakfast and about 72% skimp by having a nutritionally inadequate breakfast. Isn’t it alarming? Over the years, numerous studies have demonstrated that eating breakfast has several health benefits and can impact future health of an individual. But given today’s fast-paced life, Indians are increasingly undermining the importance of a well-balanced breakfast.

So what makes for a balanced breakfast? A balanced breakfast should consist of foods from at least three essential food groups, e.g one serve of whole grains, one serve of dairy (milk or curd) or lean proteins and one serve of fruit or vegetables. It should provide essential nutrients like protein, fibre, vitamins and minerals besides energy.

Here are some nutrient-rich foods you could incorporate as part of your balanced breakfast:

1. Oats. Oats are cereal grains that are high in protein and are a great source of fibre, especially soluble fibre. Oats contain beta glucan, a soluble fibre which has cholesterol lowering effects and therefore considered heart healthy. It also provides some minerals like iron, magnesium and zinc.

2. Barley. Barley is one of the first cultivated grains in the world, dating back nearly 13,000 years. It has the distinction of having the highest amount of dietary fibre among the cereals. Barley is chewy with a distinct nutty flavor, and is a good source of B-complex vitamins like vitamin B1, B3, B6 and biotin as well as minerals like phosphorus and manganese. Barley is also low in fat, and scientific research has shown that consumption of barley can help in lowering blood cholesterol levels.

3. Wheat. Like barley, wheat too is among the world’s oldest cultivated grains, and a source of vegetable protein. Its easy availability makes it a vital ingredient in many dishes. Whole wheat is a good source of protein and is stocked with vitamin B1, B3 and B6 making it a healthy addition to one’s diet.

4. Dried fruits. Dried fruit is fruit that has had almost all of the water content removed through drying methods. The fruit shrinks during this process, leaving a small, energy-dense dried fruit. Dried fruits are a good source of micronutrients and antioxidants (phenols) in general. Raisins, for example, contain iron and magnesium that are essential for normal functioning of the body.

5. Nuts. Nuts provide healthy fats, protein and fibre. They also provide vitamins and minerals and are a versatile food that can be incorporated in various recipes. Different nuts are rich in different nutrients. Almonds, for example, provide fibre, calcium and vitamin E.

Kellogg’s Muesli with nutritious grains including wheat, barley and oats and delicious inclusions such as almonds and dried fruits (grains and inclusions differ for different variants) along with milk or curd can be a tasty, nourishing breakfast and a great way to start your day. To explore delicious variants, click here.

This article was produced on behalf of Kellogg’s Muesli by the Scroll.in marketing team and not by the Scroll.in editorial staff.

× Close
PrevNext