Independence Day

Fact check: What Modi said about demonetisation in his I-Day speech and what the data shows

The prime minister made some very confusing claims about the note ban exercise in his Independence Day speech.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi used his Independence Day speech on Tuesday to once again extol the virtues of demonetisation, which he insisted was proof that he had waged “a big war against corruption and black money”. Modi made a few grand claims about the move, which resulted in all currency notes of Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 in value being withdrawn on November 8 , 2016, and replaced with new ones.

The massive effort, which saw 86% of India’s currency sucked out of the system, caused huge disruptions across the country. It led to a number of deaths and affected the economy in ways we are still struggling to understand. All of this was accompanied by a relatively opacity from the government, which has still refused to divulge details about much of the currency withdrawal scheme.

In Tuesday’s speech, Modi made a number of claims about demonetisation that managed to be as vague as everything else the government has put out on the subject. A fact check of Modi’s claims follows. Read the entire speech here.

Demonetisation

  • Claim: “After forming the government, our first task was to constitute an SIT [Special Investigation Team]. Today, after three years, I want to tell the countrymen proudly that we have confiscated black money worth Rs. 1.25 lakh crores, the culprits will be brought to book and forced to surrender.” 
  • Check: The government unearthed more than that amount over the last three years but it does not mean all that money is surrendered to the state. Instead, most of it is likely to be penalised and taxed. According to a reply to a Lok Sabha question, across Income Tax department searches, surveys, a compliance window and an Income Declaration scheme until 2016, the government had calculated Rs 1.35 lakh crore of undisclosed income.
  • Claim: “According to the research conducted by outside experts, about Rs 3 lakh crores that had never come into the banking system before, has been brought into the system after the demonetisation. More than Rs. 1.75 lakh crores deposited in the banks is under the scanner. Black money worth Rs. 2 lakh crore had to be deposited in the banks and this system has forced them to be accountable.” 
  • Check: This set of statements is thoroughly confusing, and mostly unattributed. Modi says Rs 3 lakh crore of money has entered the system that was never in formal banking before, that black money Rs 2 lakh crore had to be deposited in the system, and that Rs 1.75 lakh crore is under the scanner. He does not explain why only Rs 1.75 lakh crore is under the scanner if the government has identified Rs 2 lakh crore of black money. It is also unclear which “outside experts” Modi is referring to. A story by PTI, attributed to an anonymous senior official earlier this year said that the government estimated Rs 3 lakh crore-Rs 4 lakh crore of previous undeclared income had been put into the banking system. A Reserve Bank of India report estimates “excess deposits”, not unaccounted income, as being between Rs 2.7 lakh crore and Rs 4.3 lakh crore.   
  • Claim: “This year, see the results, from 1st April to 5th August more than 56 lakh people filed personal income tax returns. Last year in the same period it was just 22 lakh. That’s more than double. These are the results of our fight against corruption.” 
  • Check: It is true that 56 lakh more individuals filed returns in that specific period – from April 1 to August 5, 2017. But the comparison is cherry picked and therefore does not tell us much. As Boom points out here, by changing the time periods in which it has looked at income tax returns, the government is claiming a big jump where there may be none. The only apples-to-apples comparison will come when full returns figures are released after the financial year.
  • Claim: “Over 18 lakh people have been identified, whose income is much higher than what their declared income and therefore they have to clarify this. Around 4.5 lakh people have now come forward and are trying to trade the right path after accepting their mistakes. One lakh people, who had neither heard of Income Tax nor paid Income Tax, have now been forced to do so.”
  • Check: Revenue secretary Hasmukh Adia said notices would be sent to 18 lakh taxpayers for transactions that seemed out of line. In Parliament, the government said it had sent communications, not notices, to 18 lakh taxpayers and had heard back from 9.27 lakh. There is no official information about the other two figures Modi used, whereby 4.5 lakh have accepted their mistakes and 1 lakh count as those who have never paid taxes before.
  • Claim: “After demonetisation we did data-mining. Then we found three lakh companies, which were only shell companies. They were involved in havala dealings. Three lakh, can you imagine. And we have canceled the registration of 1.75 lakh of them. Shut five companies in India and it’s like a storm. We shut 1.75 lakh. Those who steal the country’s riches will have to answer for their deeds, this is what we have done. There were some shell companies which on just one address they had four hundred companies registered.”
  • Check: Modi has mentioned identifying three lakh shell companies before. On record, however, this is what was told to the Lok Sabha: “As on 12.07.2017, Ministry of Corporate Affairs has removed 1,62,618 Companies from the Register of Companies by following the due process under Section 248 of the Companies Act, 2013.” This answer however, does not attribute the deleted companies data mining after demonetisation. The Lok Sabha reply also mentions that I-T department investigations over the last three years have led to detection of just 1,155 shell companies.
We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BY 

Children's Day is not for children alone

It’s also a time for adults to revisit their childhood.

Most adults look at childhood wistfully, as a time when the biggest worry was a scraped knee, every adult was a source of chocolate and every fight lasted only till the next playtime. Since time immemorial, children seem to have nailed the art of being joyful, and adults can learn a thing or two about stress-free living from them. Now it’s that time of the year again when children are celebrated for...simply being children, and let it serve as a timely reminder for adults to board that imaginary time machine and revisit their childhood. If you’re unable to unbuckle yourself from your adult seat, here is some inspiration.

Start small, by doodling at the back page of your to-do diary as a throwback to that ancient school tradition. If you’re more confident, you could even start your own comic strip featuring people in your lives. You can caricaturise them or attribute them animal personalities for the sake of humour. Stuck in a boring meeting? Draw your boss with mouse ears or your coffee with radioactive powers. Just make sure you give your colleagues aliases.

Pull a prank, those not resulting in revenue losses of course. Prank calls, creeping up behind someone…pull them out from your memory and watch as everyone has a good laugh. Dress up a little quirky for work. It’s time you tried those colourful ties, or tastefully mismatched socks. Dress as your favourite cartoon characters someday – it’s as easy as choosing a ponytail-style, drawing a scar on your forehead or converting a bath towel into a cape. Even dinner can be full of childish fun. No, you don’t have to eat spinach if you don’t like it. Use the available cutlery and bust out your favourite tunes. Spoons and forks are good enough for any beat and for the rest, count on your voice to belt out any pitch. Better yet, stream the classic cartoons of your childhood instead of binge watching drama or news; they seem even funnier as an adult. If you prefer reading before bedtime, do a reread of your favourite childhood book(s). You’ll be surprised by their timeless wisdom.

A regular day has scope for childhood indulgences in every nook and cranny. While walking down a lane, challenge your friend to a non-stop game of hopscotch till the end of the tiled footpath. If you’re of a petite frame, insist on a ride in the trolley as you about picking items in the supermarket. Challenge your fellow gym goers and trainers to a hula hoop routine, and beat ‘em to it!

Children have an incredible ability to be completely immersed in the moment during play, and acting like one benefits adults too. Just count the moments of precious laughter you will have added to your day in the process. So, take time to indulge yourself and celebrate life with child-like abandon, as the video below shows.

Play

This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of SBI Life and not by the Scroll editorial team.