The Daily Fix

The Daily Fix: Removing Haj subsidy is welcome. But secular principle must apply to all pilgrimages

Everything you need to know for the day (and a little more).

The Big Story: Pilgrim’s progress

The Centre has withdrawn the Haj subsidy for Muslim pilgrims, adding that the funds will be used for the education of women from the minority community. Such a move, said Minority Affairs Minister Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi, was in line with the government’s aim to empower minorities “with dignity and without appeasement”. It is also in line with the Supreme Court order of 2012, which said the subsidy should be phased out in 10 years, with the money used for the “uplift of the community in education and other indices of social development”.

On the whole, it is a sensible move, which seems to aim at replacing tokenism with more meaningful investment in the welfare of minorities and at putting the distance required between a secular government and religious practices. But it is open to question whether Bharatiya Janata Party-led governments apply the second principle with sufficient rigour.

The subsidy, which mainly entailed lower fares for Air India flights, had long been criticised for being badly thought-out. It was claimed that funds routed through the Haj Committee were distributed as political largesse to community leaders, that the inflated airfares meant the money was actually a subsidy for the failing national carrier rather than Muslim pilgrims. For these reasons and more, the subsidy became a symbol of the Congress’s “minority appeasement”. It became ammunition for the BJP’s attack on “pseudo-secularism” and gave hardline Hindutva organisations an opportunity to vilify Muslims.

In the past, members of the community had called it an “albatross around our neck”. Few Muslim leaders now contest the removal of the subsidy, though some have expressed unhappiness that it should be so “sudden” and “targeted” at one community. All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen chief Asaduddin Owaisi, who had earlier urged that the money be spent on educating Muslim girls, has challenged the Narendra Modi-led government to stop “Hindu appeasement” too.

This is a charge that the BJP must take seriously. The Centre might justify expenditure on massive religious events like the Kumbh Mela on the grounds that it is the government’s duty to ensure the necessary facilities as well as law and order for large gatherings in any part of the country. It is less apparent why the Centre should set aside funds for the boarding and accommodation of pilgrims going to Tibet on the Kailash Manasarovar yatra. Besides, several state governments provide money for residents making the pilgrimage.

While states like Karnataka and Delhi, currently ruled by other parties, also provide such grants, the expenditure is most conspicuous and rising with BJP-led governments. Madhya Pradesh subsidises a range of pilgrimages for senior citizens and their attendants, including visits to Ayodhya, Mathura, the birthplace of Sant Kabir, St Thomas’s Church in Kerala as well as Hindu religious destinations in Pakistan, China, Cambodia and Sri Lanka. The Yogi Adityanath government in Uttar Pradesh not only doubled the grant for the Manasarovar Yatra, but it also proposed to build a Manasarovar Bhavan. Recently, it also faced charges of diverting government funds to the “Gorakhpur Mahotsav”, a star-studded extravaganza in the chief minister’s former Lok Sabha constituency.

The BJP seems quite willing to be seen spending on Hindu pilgrimages and religious practices, and not just on the security arrangements. It is curiously at odds with the secular standards the party sets for itself when it comes to the Haj. To repeat a truism in secular politics, if the state is to retreat from religion, it must retreat from all religions equally.

The Big Scroll

Shoaib Daniyal argues that the Congress’s Muslim tokenism has hurt both the party and the community.

Here is an explainer on why the Haj subsidy so controversial.

Punditry

  1. In the Indian Express, Haris Wankhede on how the Bhima-Koregaon protests suggest a return to a radical past for Dalit consciousness.
  2. In the Hindu, Jean Dreze finds that many states have instituted so-called reforms in the public distribution system that are hurting millions of people.
  3. In Mint, Shekhar Chandra asks a grim question: can we still avoid the climate tipping point?

Giggles

Don’t miss...

Joydeep Gupta on how rising sea levels threaten to displace millions in the Sunderbans:

 “I had first visited Baliara in 2009, two months before the cyclone hit. Badruddin Sarkar, retired headmaster of the village school, had then stood on top of the 18-foot embankment and pointed out the homes he used to have – the first was overtaken by a rising sea in 1991 and the second in 2004. All that could be seen of the second was the trunk of a coconut palm – it used to be part of the foundation. Two months after I met him, a storm surge from Cyclone Aila topped the embankment, ruined Sarkar’s paddy fields and freshwater fish farms with salt water, killed his livestock, and forced him to migrate to Kolkata, the capital of the Indian state of West Bengal, over 100 kilometres away.”  

Support our journalism by subscribing to Scroll+ here. We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BY 

Decoding the symbolic threads and badges of one of India’s oldest cavalry units

The untold story of The President’s Bodyguard.

The national emblem of India; an open parachute and crossed lances – this triad of symbols representing the nation, excellence in training and valor respectively are held together by an elite title in the Indian army – The President’s Bodyguard (PBG).

The PBG badge is worn by one of the oldest cavalry units in the India army. In 1773, Governor Warren Hastings, former Governor General of India, handpicked 50 troopers. Before independence, this unit was referred to by many titles including Troops of Horse Guards and Governor General’s Body Guards (GGBG). In 1950, the unit was named The President’s Bodyguard and can be seen embroidered in the curved maroon shoulder titles on their current uniforms.

The President’s Bodyguard’s uniform adorns itself with proud colours and symbols of its 245 year-old-legacy. Dating back to 1980, the ceremonial uniform consists of a bright red long coat with gold girdles and white breeches, a blue and gold ceremonial turban with a distinctive fan and Napoleon Boots with spurs. Each member of the mounted unit carries a special 3-meter-long bamboo cavalry lance, decorated by a red and white pennant. A sheathed cavalry sabre is carried in in the side of the saddle of each trooper.

While common perception is that the PBG mainly have ceremonial duties such as that of being the President’s escort during Republic Day parade, the fact is that the members of the PBG are highly trained. Handpicked by the President’s Secretariat from mainstream armored regiments, the unit assigns a task force regularly for Siachen and UN peace keeping operations. Moreover, the cavalry members are trained combat parachutists – thus decorating the PBG uniform with a scarlet Para Wings badge that signifies that these troopers are a part of the airborne battalion of the India Army.

Since their foundation, the President’s Guard has won many battle honors. In 1811, they won their first battle honor ‘Java’. In 1824, they sailed over Kalla Pani for the first Burmese War and earned the second battle honour ‘Ava’. The battle of Maharajapore in 1843 won them their third battle honor. Consequently, the PBG fought in the main battles of the First Sikh War and earned four battle honours. Post-independence, the PBG served the country in the 1962 Indo-China war and the 1965 Indo-Pak war.

The PBG, one of the senior most regiments of the Indian Army, is a unique unit. While the uniform is befitting of its traditional and ceremonial role, the badges that augment those threads, tell the story of its impressive history and victories.

How have they managed to maintain their customs for more than 2 centuries? A National Geographic exclusive captures the PBG’s untold story. The documentary series showcases the discipline that goes into making the ceremonial protectors of the supreme commander of the Indian Armed Forces.

Play

The National Geographic exclusive is a landmark in television and is being celebrated by the #untoldstory contest. The contest will give 5 lucky winners an exclusive pass to the pre-screening of the documentary with the Hon’ble President of India at the Rashtrapati Bhavan. You can also nominate someone you think deserves to be a part of the screening. Follow #UntoldStory on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram to participate.

This article was produced by Scroll marketing team on behalf of National Geographic and not by the Scroll editorial team.