animal kingdom

Dog trouble: Is our best friend a foe for wildlife?

A survey has found that domestic dogs have attacked 80 wildlife species, some of them endangered.

Our best friend could mean a matter of life and death to wildlife. A pan-India survey has sniffed out data on domestic dogs attacking as many as 80 species, including those dwindling in numbers such as the golden langur, the great Indian bustard and green turtles. Nearly half of these attacks have taken place in or around protected areas.

In a bid to understand the impact of free-ranging dogs on native wildlife in India, which many experts claim is an “under-reported” fact, Chandrima Home of the Ashoka Trust for Research in Ecology and the Environment or ATREE and colleagues zoomed in on dog-wildlife interactions in India through an online survey and by scrutinising reports from national print media.

“We found it is largely a problem across India, despite the limitations of an online survey,”Home told Mongabay-India. “Dogs were reported to attack nearly 80 species of wildlife and most of the attacks were on mammals – largely ungulates, like cattle, and small carnivores. In some places, respondents reported multiple attacks. Majority of these attacks were by free-ranging dogs unaccompanied by humans and in packs. Nearly half of the attacks led to the death of the animal.”

Dogs surround cow carcass at Jorbeer, Bikaner, Rajasthan. Photo credit: Anoop Kumar/Desert National Park, Rajasthan
Dogs surround cow carcass at Jorbeer, Bikaner, Rajasthan. Photo credit: Anoop Kumar/Desert National Park, Rajasthan

Wildlife going to the dogs

Out of the 80 species documented, 31 were ‘threatened’ as per the IUCN Red List, including four critically endangered species. Vultures, great Indian bustard, Bengal florican, Chinese pangolin, green turtles, Himalayan goral, Asiatic wild ass, red panda and the golden langur are among the species on the edge of survival, which were reportedly attacked between 2000 and 2016.

Data from the study shows that of the 249 responses, 73% reported sightings of domestic dog attacks on wildlife. Nearly 78% of the respondents from the online survey perceived the presence of dogs in and around wilderness areas to be harmful to wildlife.

Globally, cats, dogs and even rodents and pigs are known to disrupt wildlife, endangering about 600 species that are classed as vulnerable to critically endangered in the IUCN Red List. Studies show dogs have contributed to 11 vertebrate extinctions and imperiled 188 threatened species worldwide.

Out of an estimated one billion domestic dogs globally, India is home to about 60 million, the fourth highest in the world.

Dogs chasing the Indian wild ass in the Little Ran of Kutch, Gujarat. Photo credit: Kalyan Varma.
Dogs chasing the Indian wild ass in the Little Ran of Kutch, Gujarat. Photo credit: Kalyan Varma.

High dog density in India is attributed to poor dog ownership rules and lack of sustained efforts in population control and due to increased availability of food waste. Home believes a combination of all these factors influences the negative impact of dogs on wildlife.

“Since domestic dogs occur at densities higher than natural predators, the frequency of attacks on prey species is also likely to be high, especially in and around protected areas which are generally small in size in India. Large mammals find it difficult to fight back when dogs charge in packs,” she said.

Home said in India, much of the free-ranging dogs are loosely associated with humans and even if they are pets, they are generally off the leash and therefore have a propensity to interact with wildlife in several cases, due to their proximity to buffer zones and protected areas.

Dogs can venture out in these areas even if they may be fed at homes. It is important to recognise the fact that a large proportion of these attacks occur without being accompanied by humans, indicating whether they are owned or not, their free-ranging nature can have significant impacts on wildlife, she stressed.

“The effects of these attacks on populations that are actually in decline could be disastrous. It’s almost like the final nail in the coffin. When a species such as the great Indian bustard has shown already serious decline due to numerous reasons, predation by domestic dogs can push the species to extinction,” Home said.

The researchers cautioned against an “observation bias” in the data accumulated since larger sized species tend to get reported more.

A pack of dogs predating on a hog deer across the highway adjoining Kaziranga NP. Photo credit: Arif Hussain and Dipen Nath of Aaranyak.
A pack of dogs predating on a hog deer across the highway adjoining Kaziranga NP. Photo credit: Arif Hussain and Dipen Nath of Aaranyak.

Dogs exacerbate edge effects

The assessment also spotlights the role of dogs in driving changes at the boundaries of habitats (edge effects). These edge effects, which are basically ecological effects that stem from the creation of habitat edges, either naturally or by human activities, have important implications for forest fragmentation and conservation.

About 48% of the attacks were also reported within protected areas and buffer areas around them, pointing to, as Home said, a “pervasive threat” to biodiversity. This data also suggests “dogs are an important part of the edge effect around protected areas in India.”

“When habitats are fragmented, there are several edge impacts,” Home elaboraed. “For example when a road passes through a protected area, there are impacts on the species that are at the boundaries. Similarly the movement of dogs within such areas and longer forays can extend the impact of the edge.”

As an example, primatologist Parimal Bhattacharjee cited a recorded aggression in a small forest fragment near Assam University campus located in Silchar, Assam, in which a troop of six endangered Phayre’s leaf monkeys (prominent for their ‘spectacles’) were forced to abandon their regular areas following intense barking by domestic dogs.

“Coupled with the fact that there is large scale destruction of habitat for the procurement of agricultural land and setting up new human settlements, high dependency of locals on fuel wood, the aggression between the Phayre’s leaf monkeys and dogs may result in expulsion of the monkeys from their native area,” Bhattacharjee, who was not associated with the study, told Mongabay-India.

Similarly, there are reports of golden langurs forced to clamber down from trees to cross roads and move across to the other side of the forest due to habitat fragmentation, and coming under attack from domestic dogs.

“These [golden langurs] are non-urban species and when they enter villages at the edge of forests, they are subjected to aggression by dogs owned by villagers to protect livestock from predators. In certain areas, canopy construction was carried out to protect them-from a combination of road kills and dog attacks,” Bhattacharjee said.

Conservation biologist Sanjay Gubbi said domestic dogs have both direct and indirect impacts on wildlife, competing for prey with wild carnivores.

“They hunt wild animals from smaller wildlife such as hare, monitor lizards to large mammals such as chital and sambar,” Gubbi of Nature Conservation Foundation, who was not associated with the study, told Mongabay-India. “We see this regularly in our camera traps where domestic dogs are carrying or chasing wild prey. Hence they compete for prey with wild carnivores. Lowered wild prey density affects species such as leopards and can cause leopards to shift to domestic prey leading to increased human-wildlife conflict.”

 Dogs feasting on cattle carcass at Jorbeer dumpyard, Rajasthan. Photo by Anoop Kumar/Desert National Park, Rajasthan
Dogs feasting on cattle carcass at Jorbeer dumpyard, Rajasthan. Photo by Anoop Kumar/Desert National Park, Rajasthan

The experts also underscored domestic dogs as reservoirs of diseases that are transmitted to dhole, wolf, jackal, fox and other canids and felids.

Whose dog is it anyway?

Approximately 87% of the respondents felt the need to control dog populations around wilderness areas, an observation that underscores the need to rethink population management and address the threat of dogs as a conservation problem for wildlife, feel experts.

“When it comes to dog population management nobody actually wants to look at one of the most important problem in India, ie dog ownership policies,” Home said. “People like to feed dogs (easy way to show compassion) but do not want to be responsible pet owners. Also sterilisation is considered the only way to curb population.”

Though trap-neuter-release (16%) followed by euthanasia (14%) were chosen as methods for dog population control by respondents in the survey, a majority (61%) opted for multiple methods of population control such as the ones above in combinations with reducing food availability and translocation to dog shelters.

“Restricting free-ranging behaviour is very important and that can only come with strong laws,” Home said. “In certain cases, hard decisions also have to be taken but in a humane way. One cannot have dogs around sensitive conservation areas. Disowned and feral ones should be removed. Animal welfare should not just be about dogs but also the gamut of wildlife being affected by the dogs themselves.”

Dogs predating on a hog deer across the highway adjoining Kaziranga National Park. Photo credit: Arif Hussain and Dipen Nath of Aaranyak.
Dogs predating on a hog deer across the highway adjoining Kaziranga National Park. Photo credit: Arif Hussain and Dipen Nath of Aaranyak.

However, behavioural biologist Anindita Bhadra flagged a concern regarding perception of dogs not being a part of the local biological diversity. “This is a very western view of dogs – dogs being considered only as pets. This is a very myopic view. Would researchers say the same about dholes or dingoes?” Bhadra from IISER-Kolkata questioned.

According to Andrew Rowan, chief scientific officer for The Humane Society of the US and former president and CEO of Humane Society International, the issue of stray dogs worrying/killing wildlife in India is very similar to the complaints in the US by conservation biologists that cats are responsible for a huge amount of bird mortality.

“The core problem is the encroachment of human communities into protected areas and the humans are then accompanied by dogs who may, or may not, remain close to their human commensals as they explore their environment,” Rowan added.

This article first appeared on Mongabay.

Support our journalism by subscribing to Scroll+ here. We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BY 

People who fall through the gaps in road safety campaigns

Helmet and road safety campaigns might have been neglecting a sizeable chunk of the public at risk.

City police, across the country, have been running a long-drawn campaign on helmet safety. In a recent initiative by the Bengaluru Police, a cop dressed-up as ‘Lord Ganesha’ offered helmets and roses to two-wheeler riders. Earlier this year, a 12ft high and 9ft wide helmet was installed in Kota as a memorial to the victims of road accidents. As for the social media leg of the campaign, the Mumbai Police made a pop-culture reference to drive the message of road safety through their Twitter handle.

But, just for the sake of conversation, how much safety do helmets provide anyway?

Lack of physical protections put two-wheeler riders at high risk on the road. According to a recent report by the World Health Organisation (WHO), more than 1.25 million people die each year as a result of road traffic crashes. Nearly half of those dying on the world’s roads are ‘vulnerable road users’ – pedestrians, cyclists and motorcyclists. According to the Indian transport ministry, about 28 two-wheeler riders died daily on Indian roads in 2016 for not wearing helmets.

The WHO states that wearing a motorcycle helmet correctly can reduce the risk of death by almost 40% and the risk of severe injury by over 70%. The components of a helmet are designed to reduce impact of a force collision to the head. A rigid outer shell distributes the impact over a large surface area, while the soft lining absorbs the impact.

However, getting two-wheeler riders to wear protective headgear has always been an uphill battle, one that has intensified through the years owing to the lives lost due on the road. Communication tactics are generating awareness about the consequences of riding without a helmet and changing behaviour that the law couldn’t on its own. But amidst all the tag-lines, slogans and get-ups that reach out to the rider, the safety of the one on the passenger seat is being ignored.

Pillion rider safety has always been second in priority. While several state governments are making helmets for pillion riders mandatory, the lack of awareness about its importance runs deep. In Mumbai itself, only 1% of the 20 lakh pillion riders wear helmets. There seems to be this perception that while two-wheeler riders are safer wearing a helmet, their passengers don’t necessarily need one. Statistics prove otherwise. For instance, in Hyderabad, the Cyberabad traffic police reported that 1 of every 3 two-wheeler deaths was that of a pillion rider. DGP Chander, Goa, stressed that 71% of fatalities in road accidents in 2017 were of two-wheeler rider and pillion riders of which 66% deaths were due to head injury.

Despite the alarming statistics, pillion riders, who are as vulnerable as front riders to head-injuries, have never been the focus of helmet awareness and safety drives. To fill-up that communication gap, Reliance General Insurance has engineered a campaign, titled #FaceThePace, that focusses solely on pillion rider safety. The campaign film tells a relatable story of a father taking his son for cricket practice on a motorbike. It then uses cricket to bring our attention to a simple flaw in the way we think about pillion rider safety – using a helmet to play a sport makes sense, but somehow, protecting your head while riding on a two-wheeler isn’t considered.

This road safety initiative by Reliance General Insurance has taken the lead in addressing the helmet issue as a whole — pillion or front, helmets are crucial for two-wheeler riders. The film ensures that we realise how selective our worry about head injury is by comparing the statistics of children deaths due to road accidents to fatal accidents on a cricket ground. Message delivered. Watch the video to see how the story pans out.

Play

To know more about Reliance general insurance policies, click here.

This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of Reliance General Insurance and not by the Scroll editorial team.