Before the debate over a Uniform Civil Code for Muslims, there was a similar row over the enactment of a law to codify Hindu personal law in India. The Hindu Code Bills, established chiefly by BR Ambedkar and Jawaharlal Nehru, pioneered reforms that are taken for granted today: among them the right to divorce, equal rights for women to inherit property and the abolition of polygamy.
Before the Bills were finally passed in the 1950s, there was more than a decade of revisions, leading up to dramatic scenes in the Constituent Assembly. As is the case with the codification of Muslim personal law today, the Hindu Code Bills were met with stubborn resistance from various sections over their perceived interference with religious matters.
The seed for the codification of Hindu religious laws was sown during British rule. A four-member committee set up in 1941 and headed by BN Rau proposed a draft code, which was later amended and etched out by Law Minister Ambedkar, with a thrust towards breaking down the caste system and giving more rights to women. However, the Hindu Code Bill met with vehement opposition in Parliament and its passage was deferred multiple times. Among its staunch opponents were religious leaders, members of the Hindu right and even sections within the Congress. The bills were forced to be amended and watered down, but after they repeatedly failed to pass through Parliament, Ambedkar resigned from the Cabinet in September 1951. In his
resignation speech, Ambedkar indicated that he had not felt adequately supported by Nehru in his quest to get the Bill passed. Nehru, according to historical accounts, had been advised to defer the bills till the 1951 elections, the first in Independent India, were concluded.
After the Congress stormed to power in that election, Nehru set about getting the Bills passed. He split them up into four parts, ostensibly to make it easier to win Parliaments approval. Consequently, Hindu Marriage Act, Hindu Succession Act, Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, and Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act were passed between 1952 and 1956.
This period of turmoil and Ambedkar’s tireless efforts to push through reform despite overwhelming opposition were captured by political cartoonists at the time. On Tuesday, Twitter user Advaid dug up these works of art from the reams of history and shared them on the social media platform. At a time when the Hindu Right leads the country, and the BJP has consistently invoked Ambedkar’s legacy and has positioned itself as a champion for Muslim women’s rights as an advocate of the Uniform Civil Code, the cartoons are a satire-infused reminder of a time when the tables were turned. Advaid said multiple reports of vandalism of Ambedkar statues in the country prompted him to dig up memories of the leader’s struggles in getting the Hindu Code Bills passed, just one of the reformer’s many contributions to modern Indian society.
A Thread on the 1940's & 1950's Newspaper cartoons on Hindu Code Bill.
— Advaid (@Advaidism) April 9, 2018
1) Cartoon published on March 18, 1949 in The Tribune during the Hindu Code Bill debates in Indian Parliament, drawn by cartoonist B Verma.
Dr. Ambedkar saving Hindu women from the grip of Orthodox Brahmins. pic.twitter.com/UMUb9JVFkX
2) Cartoon published in Shankar’s Weekly on 20th February, 1949 showing a Brahmin dancing on woman while Dr Ambedkar with Hindu code bill in his hand and women who supported him question this.
— Advaid (@Advaidism) April 9, 2018
Drawn by Cartoonist Shankar pic.twitter.com/EWqE151Ffr
3) Dr Ambedkar coming to cure the disease of the patient 'Hindu Society' through the medicine Hindu code bill, but the patient shows fists to Dr Ambedkar.
— Advaid (@Advaidism) April 9, 2018
Cartoon published in National Herald on 26th February, 1949, drawn by cartoonist Bireshwar. pic.twitter.com/7NyvLqqE6F
4) Cartoon published in Shankar’s Weekly in December 1949.
— Advaid (@Advaidism) April 9, 2018
Dr Ambedkar holding the hand of a little girl named Hindu code bill and leading her towards the Parliament and a Brahmin holding an axe in hand hiding behind a wall, while women from the terrace try to save the girl. pic.twitter.com/CBWgsosITP
5) A Brahmin frightened seeing Dr Ambedkar and a woman marching with a banner equal rights for women.
— Advaid (@Advaidism) April 9, 2018
Drawn by Cartoonist Shankar during the Hindu code bill debate, from Shankar’s weekly, Jan 1950. pic.twitter.com/pc2iWn7P6G
6) A cartoon published in National Herald on September 8, 1948, showing the reaction of women demanding their share and rights supporting the Hindu code bill, while Dr. Ambedkar , the then Law Minister watching this sitting on a branch.
— Advaid (@Advaidism) April 9, 2018
This cartoon is drawn by Bireshwar. pic.twitter.com/JqngKIeTwQ
7) A cartoon by RK Laxman, Feb 1950
— Advaid (@Advaidism) April 9, 2018
Nehru urges a Hindu Monk (anti Hindu code Bill protester) to accept the Hindu Code Bill, while the small Child (New India) cries. pic.twitter.com/wJBvyz13ft
8) Cartoon showing Dr. Ambedkar tied to a chair with a thick rope by a group of angry Brahmins holding sticks in their hands.
— Advaid (@Advaidism) April 9, 2018
Cartoon published on September 30, 1951 in 'The Leader news paper, drawn by Oommen. Cartoon shows the defeat of the Hindu Code Bill in the Parliament. pic.twitter.com/u0MHeFXuwc
9) Cartoon showing Dr Ambedkar's decision to resign from Law Ministry over the failure to implement the Hindu Code Bill.
— Advaid (@Advaidism) April 9, 2018
Cartoon from Shankar's Weekly, October 7, 1951. pic.twitter.com/06dMxFdGTo
When the bill was finally passed in 1956 as four separate parts, Dr Ambedkar was present in Rajya Sabha.
— Advaid (@Advaidism) April 9, 2018
There was common penal code drafted in the 1830s by Thomas B Macaulay but the British did not interfere with the personals laws of the different religions and cultures. pic.twitter.com/AQyOX1exYr