The troubles at India’s private lenders are escalating.
Shikha Sharma, managing director and CEO of Axis Bank, has decided to shorten her tenure by more than two years, the lender informed the exchanges on April 9. The decision has come amid reports that the Reserve Bank of India was unhappy with the lender’s performance and had asked the bank to review its decision to extend Sharma’s term.
Last December, the board of Axis Bank, India’s third-largest private lender, had given Sharma her fourth extension. The new three-year term was set to start from June 1, 2018. Now, the RBI’s final approval for the curtailed term is awaited.
Sharma took over the reins of the bank in 2009 after quitting the ICICI Bank group, which incidentally has also found itself under the scanner.
An IIM Ahmedabad graduate, Sharma has been credited with building Axis Bank’s investment banking and the retail businesses. The latter, in particular, helped the lender tide over a period when corporate loans had begun turning sour.
But it wasn’t all smooth sailing.
Bad loans
Over the last few years, Indian banking’s toxic loan pile has increased considerably. While it’s mainly the public sector banks that have suffered, private lenders like Axis Bank, too, have had their share of dud loans.
Under Sharma’s tenure, for instance, the gross non-performing assets of the bank have risen from 0.96% in March 2009 to 5.28% in December 2017.
The bank’s increased exposure to sectors such as infrastructure, power, and mining returned to haunt it when the economy slowed down after 2008. By the time it attempted a course correction, the damage was done.
Credibility crisis
Axis Bank has also been pulled up twice by the central bank for under-reporting bad loans for financial years 2016 and 2017. The divergence – ie the difference between the RBI’s and the lender’s assessments – was around Rs 9,480 crore, nearly one-and-a-half times the amount reported by the bank.
In financial year 2017, the lender once again reported a loan divergence of Rs 5,633 crore, denting its financial credibility in a big way.
Profits plunge
As toxic loans surged, the bank’s earnings came under pressure.
In 2016, it reported a loss for the first time in 46 quarters. Since then, despite recovery, earnings have remained below analysts’ estimates even as recently as in the October-December 2017 quarter.
As a result, its stock has under-performed, too. In the last three years, the Axis Bank scrip has lost over 7% of its value, plummeting from around Rs 570 to Rs 527 at the start of trade on April 10.
It has also under-performed at the banking index for the last three years. The share has fallen 0.1% in this time, compared to a 13.1% rise in the banking Nifty index.
Demonetisation woes
In the aftermath of the November 2016 note ban, Axis Bank once again found itself in a tight spot.
At least 19 of its employees were suspended for flouting norms and for alleged money laundering. The reported malpractices led to a series of raids by income-tax officers at several Axis Bank branches. There were even rumours that the bank could lose its banking licence. The RBI had to step in to contain the damage.
WhatsApp information leaks
In December 2017, the Securities and Exchanges Board of India ordered Axis Bank to probe insider trading allegations against bank officials. The bank came under the market regulator’s lens following reports that the lender’s earnings were already being shared on WhatsApp before it was sent to the exchanges.
This article first appeared on Quartz.
