The Daily Fix

The Daily Fix: In the Kathua quest for justice, neither BJP nor Congress are credible voices

Everything you need to know for the day (and a little more).

The Big Story: The Kathua test

Three months after an eight-year-old child was kidnapped, drugged, raped and killed in Jammu’s Kathua district, according to the police chargesheet, the national media has woken up to it and so have political parties. Inevitably, the political grandstanding has begun. Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti announced on Thursday that the state government, led by the People’s Democratic Party, will enact a law that ensures the death penalty for the rape of minors. The Congress’s Rahul Gandhi went on a midnight vigil at India Gate to protest against the Kathua case as well as the rape of a teenager in Unnao, Uttar Pradesh, and the death of her father in police custody. The Bharatiya Janata Party, a coalition partner in Jammu and Kashmir, swings between sympathy for the accused and muted sympathy for the brutalised child, while the top leadership maintains a deafening silence.

Of the three, the People’s Democratic Party has been under pressure for months as the Kathua incident gave rise to protests in both Jammu and the Kashmir Valley. While a newly formed organisation, the Hindu Ekta Manch, agitated for the case to be shifted to the Central Bureau of Investigation, groups representing the Gujjar-Bakarwal communities in Jammu and various other organisations in Kashmir broke out in protest against the crime. Even as Mufti held out against pressure to transfer the investigation, there was growing anger against her party for its alliance with the BJP, which is widely believed to be shielding the accused.

As a consequence, the People’s Democratic Party proposes to take the route that the United Progressive Alliance did after the Delhi gang rape of December 2012: to frame a big-ticket law with stringent punishments to give the appearance of action and quell public anger. As the last five years have shown, the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act of 2013, which allowed capital punishment for rape, has not been a deterrent. While other states have tried to introduce the death penalty for the rape of minors, studies show that low conviction rates and other flaws in the judicial system will continue to blunt such laws. The death penalty law is no better than a promise of blood for blood.

Meanwhile, the Congress has not covered itself with glory. While the party high command showed admirable agility in organising a spontaneous vigil on Thursday, it may want to look within first. In Jammu, its local party leaders openly supported the Hindu Ekta Manch. Moreover, the Jammu Bar Association, which enforced a shutdown to push for the transfer of the case and supported lawyers who tried to prevent the chargesheet from being filed, is reportedly led by an old Congress hand. The party high command may now point fingers at the politics of hate but there is little difference between the Congress and BJP in Jammu. For too long, both parties have thrived on a poisonous Hindutva that fed on the polarisation between Hindu-majority Jammu and Muslim-majority Kashmir. So long as this continues, the Congress cannot expect to be a credible voice in the campaign for justice.

Most troubling, perhaps, is the BJP top leadership’s studied silence – it is, after all, the party in government at the Centre and in the state. Moreover, the party has its fingerprints all over the vicious mobilisations that followed the crime and tried to shield the accused. The Hindu Ekta Manch is headed by the former Kathua district president of the BJP. Two BJP ministers in the state government attended the meetings of the manch, which called for a boycott of the Muslim Gujjar-Bakarwal community to which the child belonged. A Union minister of state also chimed in sympathy with the manch, echoing its demand for a Central Bureau of Investigation probe. While Union Minister of State for External Affairs VK Singh and a few other legislators have made soothing noises, it is not enough. The party’s top leadership, including the prime minister, needs to speak above the din and make its position clear. In an ideal world, this would mean the BJP stating clearly that it does not stand for hate crimes, that it will crack down on any attempt by party members to bully and alter the course of law.

The Big Scroll

Rayan Naqash reports on how the Kathua rape and murder stirred the Valley into a new debate. He also travelled to Kathua to find villages divided along deepening communal faultlines, explored how the Forest Rights Act may safeguard the rights of Gujjar-Bakarwals and reported on a charge sheet which gave harrowing details of the eight-year-old’s ordeal.

Punditry

  1. In the Indian Express, Pratap Bhanu Mehta argues that with Kathua and Unnao, blaming politicians is just a way of exonerating ourselves.
  2. In the Hindu, Sadiq Rangwala makes a case for science.
  3. In the Economic Times, Atisha Kumar writes that India will not be able to sustain economic growth without focusing on all states and regions.

Giggles

Don’t miss...

Naresh Fernandes traces how a party song from Bandra travelled around the globe:

  “In 1969, the recording company HMV asked Kava and the Music Makers to write a song about the city in which he lived. Kava had already made a few records for the company by then (and had changed his name at the insistence of HMV’s publicists), but his tunes hadn’t quite captured the imagination of the public. Like all the songs he made in English, the lyrics had been written by his formidable wife Naju and carried a whiff of Edwardian innocence about them. In 1966, they’d made their debut with an ode to their home state, which had been born only six years earlier. It was called Evening in Gay Maharashtra.” 

Support our journalism by subscribing to Scroll+ here. We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BY 

A musical remix, a delectable dish and a taxi makeover

What do these three works of art have in common?

What connects Raghav Sachar, Ranveer Brar and Taxi Fabric? On the surface, nothing at all. Sachar is known for his genius musical abilities, Brar a chef loved for demystifying food while the essence of Taxi Fabric goes way beyond its name. All three operate, and thrive, in unconnected domains. Upon looking closer, though, a common thread emerges between their work so far - an unmistakable streak of creativity.

Raghav Sachar is a singer, composer and film scorer who was featured in a National Geographic series, My Brilliant Brain, for his prodigious musical abilities - he can effortlessly switch between male and female vocals and play over 30 musical instruments! His adaptations of old Bollywood songs, shot in a multi-screen format, have been especially well received on the Internet.

Ranveer Brar is a well-known chef who is working to expand the idea of food. He has appeared in culinary shows as diverse as Masterchef India, Great Indian Rasoi, Thank God It’s Fryday and Food Tripping. Brar’s work in food media isn’t merely instructional, he seeks to deep dive into food - to the very science of it and its endless aesthetic possibilities. Brar is also a phenomenal food stylist who approaches food presentation as no less than an art, and himself as no less than a food artiste.

Taxi Fabric is a startup that turns taxi seat covers into canvases for artists. Through Taxi Fabric, artists have found a medium to unleash their creativity and activism onto Mumbai’s roads – the iconic kaali peelis. If you get lucky on a Mumbai street, you may hop into a world of Mumbai’s chawls, surrealist Persian architecture, Chandni Chowk and more in your short taxi ride.

The latest projects from these three creatives have a connection too - the same muse, presented by Flipkart. The muse inspired Raghav Sachar to recreate one of his own songs ‘Baahon Mein Tu Aaja’. Watch his new version of the song below.

Chef Ranveer Brar, meanwhile, dipped into his food styling instinct to create a beautiful dish. You can watch his piece of culinary art below.

Taxi Fabric brought on board Arun Chanchal, a graphic designer who describes his aesthetic as geometric surrealism. Watch the stunning result of their collaboration below.

Flipkart revealed the #ExtraordinaryBeauty that launched a musical remix, a delectable dish and a taxi makeover on 20th July. Watch the reveal below.

Honor 9N is the latest in Honor’s range of beautiful, yet highly functional, phones. There’s a lot that makes Honor 9N a worthy muse - it boasts 2.5D curved glass design with 12-layer nano coating process. It, moreover, offers full-screen display thanks to its notch design. Honor 9N will be launched in India as a Flipkart exclusive on 24th July, 2018. To know more about the phone, click here. Stay tuned for the launch, here.

This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of Flipkart and not by the Scroll editorial team.