Media Matters

TimesNow’s Tejpal tapes programme reflects many legal and ethical concerns about reporting rape

On Monday, the channel aired CCTV footage that it claimed was evidence from the ongoing trial in which journalist Tarun Tejpal is accused of sexual assault.

Several concerns arise in relation to the reportage of sexual violence. Every once in a while, these concerns take centerstage when content deemed particularly egregious is published. TimesNow’s show on Monday, in which the television channel aired CCTV tapes that it claimed were evidence from the ongoing trial in which writer Tarun Tejpal is accused of rape, seems to have fit the bill.

In its primetime show, the channel aired CCTV footage of Tejpal and the woman who accused him of rape entering and exiting the lifts where the alleged crime took place in 2013. As the tapes were played on the channel, what appeared to be presented as the woman’s detailed testimony was read out. Throughout the show, TimesNow editor Rahul Shivshankar claimed to be questioning what Tejpal apparently believes is evidence of his innocence. But he did so while seeming to make no mention of the trial being ‘in camera’, meaning reportage of details is generally restricted by law without court consent. The channel went on to break down the tapes, in excruciating detail, with a panel of reporters and analysts.

Such reportage quite rightly raises concerns. Questionable reportage is, however, not at all unusual when it comes to reporting sexual violence, and it is certainly not the monopoly of TimesNow. There are both legal and ethical issues involved, and the tale isn’t necessarily a story about the malicious against the well-intentioned. The law may well be breached not just by those who are ignorant of it or who maliciously choose not to respect it but also by those who believe that it is structurally toxic.

Protecting identities

One of the first precepts of the law is to protect the identities of women and children who have allegedly been raped or subjected to various other forms of sexual violence which it contemplates as requiring identity protection. The law provides such protection this through the Indian Penal Code as well as statutes which deal with sexual harassment at work and child sexual abuse. There are legal mechanisms through which victim identities may be publicly revealed but the law leans towards non-disclosure. Given that Indian society often treats victims of sexual violence extremely harshly, there are sound practical reasons to keep victim identities secret.

Nonetheless, what is inescapable is that early laws that protected victim identities found their basis in the supposed shame of having been raped. Considering their rationale, it is all too easy to decide to thwart patriarchy by revealing identity and refusing to associate having been raped with shame. However, when one unilaterally acts on that decision in relation to another person, one is almost certain to have broken both law and one’s ethical obligations. It doesn’t matter if one intends not to harm the person raped but to dent patriarchal fetters instead. The law does not contain a “feminism-at-work” exception even if it were possible to convincingly argue that such an act is inherently feminist; it isn’t. After all, unilaterally disclosing the identity of a person who has been raped is a violation of their agency.

The law doesn’t always help matters. It is sometimes unclear about what it intends to keep confidential. When it comes to sexual harassment at the work-place, for example, confidentiality is not a monolith. It could relate to the identities of witnesses, alleged victims, alleged perpetrators, allegations, proceedings, or findings. Although there’s no doubt that victim and witness identities are to be kept confidential at all stages, the 2013 statute that deals with the subject contains an intriguing exception which allows the dissemination of information “regarding the justice secured to any victim of sexual harassment” under the statute.

It isn’t clear what exactly the statute contemplates when it speaks of justice secured to any victim. To further complicate the issue, there is also a provision in the Indian Penal Code that deals with sexual harassment but which does not contain comparable confidentiality requirements in its main body. There are therefore questions about how the two provisions would interact if both of them were involved in a matter. The lack of clarity in this area of law has been used to attempt to veil findings of sexual harassment and to protect the identities of abusers even after they have been found to have committed harassment. This, presumably, is not the intention of the law although one can’t be sure.

As such, even where there is law, there is uncertainty. And, where law is scant, the uncertainty only rises. The most glaring example of this is probably demonstrated by the intrusive and explicit reportage of sexual violence that is sometimes ostensibly used to raise awareness about violence. Although the publication of obscene content is legally prohibited and privacy is a constitutional right, reportage could easily be gratuitously intrusive without reaching the level of incontrovertible illegality. There is no reason to believe that such reportage is justifiable particularly since it does not appear to help ensure that perpetrators are held accountable at law. Still, it continues.

Caste and class privileges

In addition, there are significant differences in how rape reportage is conducted depending on the caste and class of those involved. Women who are upper caste or upper class are generally not portrayed in disarray. Those who are not privileged are wont to have images of their corpses hanging from trees or sinking in mud be disseminated without a second thought and without so much as having their identities blurred. When it comes to alleged perpetrators too, one is far more likely to see in-depth profiles of lower caste and lower class men men accused of sexual violence than of privileged men.

There is reason to suggest that the identities of all alleged perpetrators should be protected until the first formal finding of their guilt. Doing so would protect those who are accused without any basis. However, what cannot be gainsaid is that experience indicates that disclosing the identities of alleged perpetrators may well convince others whom they’ve abused to come forward with public (and, possibly, formal) allegations.

Some common problems with rape reportage are easily corrected. The oft-repeated claim that “medical reports (dis)prove rape” is a canard in relation to competent adult women, for example, simply because rape hinges on consent which a medical report cannot speak to. As such, medical reports are nothing but corroborative evidence that cannot either prove or disprove rape by themselves. Addressing the issue would take nothing more than purging the phrase “medical reports (dis)prove rape” from the vocabulary of rape reportage.

In most cases, however, clear-cut answers to questions about how to report sexual violence are often hard to come by. The law could be considered to prescribe minimum standards which attempt to protect those who have been subjected to sexual violence. The law alone, however, isn’t enough. Framing reportage in a manner which does not retraumatise victims, and which holds perpetrators to account requires one to go above and beyond the letter of the law.

Support our journalism by subscribing to Scroll+ here. We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BY 

Following a mountaineer as he reaches the summit of Mount Everest

Accounts from Vikas Dimri’s second attempt reveal the immense fortitude and strength needed to summit the Everest.

Vikas Dimri made a huge attempt last year to climb the Mount Everest. Fate had other plans. Thwarted by unfavourable weather at the last minute, he came so close and yet not close enough to say he was at the top. But that did not deter him. Vikas is back on the Everest trail now, and this time he’s sharing his experiences at every leg of the journey.

The Everest journey began from the Lukla airport, known for its dicey landing conditions. It reminded him of the failed expedition, but he still moved on to Namche Bazaar - the staging point for Everest expeditions - with a positive mind. Vikas let the wisdom of the mountains guide him as he battled doubt and memories of the previous expedition. In his words, the Everest taught him that, “To conquer our personal Everest, we need to drop all our unnecessary baggage, be it physical or mental or even emotional”.

Vikas used a ‘descent for ascent’ approach to acclimatise. In this approach, mountaineers gain altitude during the day, but descend to catch some sleep. Acclimatising to such high altitudes is crucial as the lack of adequate oxygen can cause dizziness, nausea, headache and even muscle death. As Vikas prepared to scale the riskiest part of the climb - the unstable and continuously melting Khumbhu ice fall - he pondered over his journey so far.

His brother’s diagnosis of a heart condition in his youth was a wakeup call for the rather sedentary Vikas, and that is when he started focusing on his health more. For the first time in his life, he began to appreciate the power of nutrition and experimented with different diets and supplements for their health benefits. His quest for better health also motivated him to take up hiking, marathon running, squash and, eventually, a summit of the Everest.

Back in the Himalayas, after a string of sleepless nights, Vikas and his team ascended to Camp 2 (6,500m) as planned, and then descended to Base Camp for the basic luxuries - hot shower, hot lunch and essential supplements. Back up at Camp 2, the weather played spoiler again as a jet stream - a fast-flowing, narrow air current - moved right over the mountain. Wisdom from the mountains helped Vikas maintain perspective as they were required to descend 15km to Pheriche Valley. He accepted that “strength lies not merely in chasing the big dream, but also in...accepting that things could go wrong.”

At Camp 4 (8,000m), famously known as the death zone, Vikas caught a clear glimpse of the summit – his dream standing rather tall in front of him.

It was the 18th of May 2018 and Vikas finally reached the top. The top of his Everest…the top of Mount Everest!

Watch the video below to see actual moments from Vikas’ climb.

Play

Vikas credits his strength to dedication, exercise and a healthy diet. He credits dietary supplements for helping him sustain himself in the inhuman conditions on Mount Everest. On heights like these where the oxygen supply drops to 1/3rd the levels on the ground, the body requires 3 times the regular blood volume to pump the requisite amount of oxygen. He, thus, doesn’t embark on an expedition without double checking his supplements and uses Livogen as an aid to maintain adequate amounts of iron in his blood.

Livogen is proud to have supported Vikas Dimri on his ambitious quest and salutes his spirit. To read more about the benefits of iron, see here. To read Vikas Dimri’s account of his expedition, click here.

This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of Livogen and not by the Scroll editorial team.