A Bharatiya Janata Party MLA from Telangana has released a song remarkably similar to a patriotic anthem produced by the Pakistani military’s media wing, prompting reactions from social media users on both sides of the border.
Raja Singh in a tweet on Friday announced that he would release a new song on April 14 on the occasion of Ram Navmi as a tribute to the Indian army.
My new song which will be released on 14th April at 11:45 AM on the occasion of #SriRamNavami is dedicated to our #IndianArmy forces. pic.twitter.com/Es391cE2PT
— Chowkidar Raja Singh (@TigerRajaSingh) April 12, 2019
However, the tune and lyrics of Singh’s track were almost identical to that of the Inter-Services Public Relations song released ahead of Pakistan Day in March and sung by Sahir Ali Bagga. However, Singh altered the lyrics from “Pakistan Zindabad” to “Hindustan Zindabad”.
Commenting on Singh’s video on Twitter from his personal account, Major General Asif Ghafoor, the director general of Pakistan’s ISPR, on Sunday said: “Glad that you copied. But copy to speak the truth as well.”
The “speak the truth” is a reference to Pakistan’s rejection of the Indian claim that the Indian Air Force had downed a Pakistani F-16 fighter jet during a dogfight in February. Islamabad says that its account of the escalation has been supported by international media reports, with US-based Foreign Policy magazine citing unidentified US defence officials to contradict the Indian claim.
Glad that you copied. But copy to speak the truth as well. #PakistanZindabad https://t.co/lVPgRbcynQ
— Asif Ghafoor (@peaceforchange) April 14, 2019
Pakistani journalist Hamid Mir said the BJP lawmaker’s song was “not [a] copy but theft” and described Singh’s rendition as “unimpressive”.
I am not glad because this is not copy but theft very unimpressive voice humiliation to those who are dedicated https://t.co/W8ZgBhr0iT
— Hamid Mir (@HamidMirPAK) April 14, 2019
Others on social media couldn’t help taking a dig at Singh either.
In India ##ChokidaarChorHai becomes top trend after its ruling party #BJP leader #MLA Chowkidar Raja Singh @TigerRajaSingh copies #PakistanArmy #ISPR song #PakistanZindaBad released on Pakistan Day #Pakistan #India #Pakistan #Radio #copy
— Mian Khateeb Adil (@KhateebAdil1) April 14, 2019
pic.twitter.com/9cTcbxxBaw
Beautiful original composition.
— Different Angle (@AchayDinAaingay) April 14, 2019
Now some haters will say that it's copied from Pakistan. NO...actually it was Pak ISPR which stole the actual tune from mind of Raja Singh through #ISI when it was only conceived.
Jai Hind !!!
This is a slightly edited version of an article that first appeared on Dawn.com.