On Sunday, the intense toxic haze building up in North India over the past week reached apocalyptic levels. Ten monitoring stations in the National Capital Region recorded pollution levels in the “severe plus emergency” category.
#DelhiAirEmergency was the top Twitter trend, followed by #DelhiPollution and #DelhiBachao – literally, save Delhi.
Despite living in Delhi, however, top ministers in the Prime Minister Narenda Modi government seemed to be on another planet.
Environment minister Prakash Javadekar tweeted in the morning to ask Indians to start their day with music.
Start your day with music. Below is the link to a scintillating thematic composition "Swagatam" by Veena exponent Emani Sankara Sastry.https://t.co/9e4mtx6I64
— Prakash Javadekar (@PrakashJavdekar) November 3, 2019
For more such compositions click onhttps://t.co/yMIlz7rrA9 #IndianMusic https://t.co/9e4mtx6I64
His tweet came after a day of squabbling between the Central government and the Delhi government. On Saturday, Javadekar accused Delhi chief minister Kejriwal of “politicising” air pollution and claimed the Centre had organised interstate meetings between officials and ministers of North Indian states about the problem.
But a government document surfaced on Sunday showing that Javadekar had cancelled the previous three meetings of state environment ministers scheduled in September and October.
3 meetings of NCR env ministers under d chairmanship of Union Env min @PrakashJavdekar for ' prevention, control and mitigation of air pollution' were scheduled and postponed thrice betn Sept and Oct 2019
— Rupashree Nanda (@rupashreenanda) November 2, 2019
Dy CM @msisodia asks Union Env Min to spare some time #airpollution pic.twitter.com/cBjRyQD0is
India’s health minister Harshvardhan also tweeted some advice in the morning: Eat carrots for “help against pollution-related harm”.
#EatRightIndia_34
— Dr Harsh Vardhan (@drharshvardhan) November 3, 2019
Eating carrots helps the body get Vitamin A, potassium, & antioxidants which protect against night blindness common in India. Carrots also help against other pollution-related harm to health.#EatRightIndia @PMOIndia @MoHFW_INDIA @fssaiindia pic.twitter.com/VPjVfiMpR8
This prompted much carrot-munching on Twitter.
#DelhiAirEmergency https://t.co/l4gQjSGpzz pic.twitter.com/MIc0NZoXpR
— Padma Priya D (@priyakamal) November 3, 2019
Uttar Pradesh minister Sunil Bharala, meanwhile, noted that farmers have always practiced stubble burning, a major cause of atmospheric pollution as smoke from neighbouring states gathers over the capital. “It’s a natural system,” said Bharatala, reported ANI. “Repeated criticism of it is unfortunate.”
He offered a solution: “Governments should hold yagnas [Hindu rituals held in front of a sacred fire] to please Lord Indra [the God of rain] as done traditionally. He will set things right.”
#WATCH Uttar Pradesh minister Sunil Bharala: Farmers have always practiced stubble burning, it's a natural system. Repeated criticism of it is unfortunate. Govts should hold 'Yagya' to please Lord Indra (God of rain), as done traditionally. He (Lord Indra) will set things right. pic.twitter.com/EcImGAbVrl
— ANI UP (@ANINewsUP) November 3, 2019
Perhaps working with the knowledge that rituals and carrots alone cannot help, the bureaucrat heading Indian government’s policy think tank, the Niti Aayog, declared that he planned to move away from Delhi after he retired.
Away from the hustle, bustle of Delhi in God’s Own Country where I have lived, worked and served the people of the State. This is where I will settle down in life. #Kerala #pollutionkills pic.twitter.com/TuJDptEDJo
— Amitabh Kant (@amitabhk87) November 3, 2019
The mandate of the Niti Aayog is to help India “achieve sustainable development goals with cooperative federalism” – exactly what is needed for tackling the pollution emergency in North India. No single state government can tackle the crisis. What is needed is collaborative action. That is where the Centre must take the lead. But there are no signs of that happening.
A journalist with the New York Times put it quite simply.
Air pollution off the charts in Delhi today. A thick, nasty haze with levels of PM 2.5 reaching 30-40 times the global safe limit. And yet, silence from @narendramodi @AmitShah @drharshvardhan
— Kai Schultz (@Kai_Schultz) November 3, 2019
Actually, Prime Minister Narendra Modi did say something – not on the pollution, though.
"Best time to be in India" pic.twitter.com/2F7IyWzUkO
— Mihir Chhablani (@MihirChhablani) November 3, 2019
With no decisive leadership in sight, former Election Commission SY Quraishi offered up a dose of gallows humour.
A byproduct of Delhi’s pollution is several jokes! pic.twitter.com/wAgN2kCG9e
— Dr. S.Y. Quraishi (@DrSYQuraishi) November 2, 2019