Mile Jedinak scored his second penalty of the World Cup in Denmark’s match against Australia but rather than the scorer, it was the manner in which the spot-kick was awarded that became the topic of debate.
Yusuf Poulsen was penalised and booked as replays showed that the ball had hit the Danish attacker’s outstretched hand. The ball however, ricocheted off an Australian player’s head and changed course at the last moment hitting Poulsen’s hand. Did he have any chance to avoid the ball hitting his hand? That was the sticking point.
Referee Antonio Mateu then asked for a Video Assistant Referee review and gave the decision to Australia as the Danish players protested.
VAR: Penalty Review
— FIFA World Cup 🏆 (@FIFAWorldCup) June 21, 2018
Penalty confirmed by VAR.
Reason: There was a foul.
Mile Jedinak scores his second penalty of the #WorldCup to bring @Socceroos level!#DENAUS 1-1 pic.twitter.com/wYe2NThUPn
Interestingly, Australia were at the receiving end of the historic first penalty to be avoided by VAR review in their first match against France, when Antoine Griezmann was adjudged to have been brought down in the box after video replays.
VAR giveth, VAR taketh away, it would seem as Australia finished the game 1-1, earning their first World Cup points in Russia.
The decision against Denmark though, stirred plenty of debate, mostly because handball is the most subjective of footballing decisions and even in the non-VAR days, it was arguably the cause for most heated debates.
Here’s a selection of the reaction to that decision:
Harsh by the ref. No one jumps with their hands by their side we all raise them to add spring n momentum to the jump. Then to add more he books him too? #DENAUS #WorldCup18
— Paul Malignaggi (@PaulMalignaggi) June 21, 2018
Will be interesting to see if/when a referee doesn't give a penalty after reviewing it with VAR. #DENAUS
— zion.litty (@vkeipoprat) June 21, 2018
Pre-tournament: VAR is a good idea but way off being ready to be used in meaningful football.
— Raj Bains (@BainsXIII) June 21, 2018
Start of the tournament: Maybe I was wrong about VAR after all, these referees seem to know what they’re doing.
Now: Hate VAR more than ever. Disrupts the very fabric of the game. Shite.
Criticism of the decision fell mainly on the fact that while the arm was in an ‘unnatural’ position according to the rules of the game, the interpretation was off due to the replay slowing down the actual pace at which the game was played and subsequently, the deliberateness of Poulsen stretching his hand to meet a ball which had switched paths.
Yesterday I actually thought VAR was kind of a cool thing, but today... Hmmmm 🤔 #WorldCup pic.twitter.com/mEWo0TCLbO
— Peter Schmeichel (@Pschmeichel1) June 21, 2018
That penalty decision is, for me, the fault of VAR. Watching football in slow motion changes the nature of the action. It 'looks' worse than it was. Creates a false impression of the sport.
— Daniel Storey (@danielstorey85) June 21, 2018
I think we love VAR now #DENAUS
— Charlie Pickering (@charliepick) June 21, 2018
VAR has been Australia's best player this World Cup.#WorldCup #DEN #AUS #DENAUS
— 🇩🇰 vs 🇦🇺 Football Tweet (@Football__Tweet) June 21, 2018
Yay technology! #DENAUS
— Titus O'Reily (@TitusOReily) June 21, 2018
Can understand why they’ve given a penalty for that but it is preposterous to suggest it is ‘deliberate’. Few handballs are ‘deliberate’ but doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be given. The rule’s definition needs to change. #DENAUS #WorldCup
— Samuel Luckhurst (@samuelluckhurst) June 21, 2018
So, when is it ok to discuss how ridiculous that penalty was? #DENAUS
— Sam McClure (@sam_mcclure) June 21, 2018
guys this tactic of forcing our opponents to use their hands is paying huge dividends #DENAUS
— jess wheeler (@wheelswordsmith) June 21, 2018
Denmark 🇩🇰 1
— Seema Jaswal (@meseemajaswal) June 21, 2018
Australia 🇦🇺 1 Penalty #Jedinak
VAR 1 ....Game on!#DENAUS #WorldCup @itvfootball
"Australian best player is VAR!"#DENAUS pic.twitter.com/Unwfgr1kgK
— Jemet (@Lespiedsoujveut) June 21, 2018
VAR is a bit of a joke! Not deliberate handball and not clear and obvious. Always been a fan of technology but it seems we are getting as many bad decisions by VAR as good. Too much subjectivity around decisions in football for VAR to work. #DENAUS
— Andrew Wilesmith (@WilesmithNunez) June 21, 2018
#DEN v #AUS Halftime Thoughts:
— Jimmy Conrad (@JimmyConrad) June 21, 2018
- Christian Eriksen is too good for Spurs.
- That was a harsh penalty and, for me, unnecessary for VAR to get involved. If the ball didn’t hit his hand, it’s not scoring. Denmark had a man on the post to go along with their man mountain in goal.
YOUR HAND IS IN AN UNNATURAL POSITION AND YOU LIEEEEEEEED #DENAUS
— Van Badham (@vanbadham) June 21, 2018
Man If VAR gets added in the Champions League, Barcelona & Real Madrid would never cross the round of 16
— Major A. (@king_adze) June 21, 2018
Led a chant of
— Daniel Brettig (@danbrettig) June 21, 2018
V A R
V A R
V A R
at the pub. No particular reason.#DENAUS #WorldCup
The debate, it would seem, continues.