Australian batsman Matthew Wade received a life during the third T20 International against India on Tuesday after Virat Kohli’s attempt to review an LBW appeal was deemed “null and void” by the third umpire.
After winning the series on Sunday, India lost the third match as Australia avoided a clean sweep.
The incident happened in the 11th over of the Australian innings when a delivery from left-arm seamer T Natarajan struck Wade on the front pad. The on-field umpire said not-out and that’s when the confusion ensued.
Kohli, who was fielding at long-on, first took the advice of wicketkeeper KL Rahul while deciding to go for DRS. The India captain then turned to go back to his position but quickly decided to take the review after all. It seemed he saw the replay of the delivery and made his decision.
Rahul then gestured at the on-field umpire that India had opted for the review which didn’t go down well with Wade. “They referred it off the big screen,” he was heard telling the square-leg umpire.
However, just as the replays of the delivery started to show for DRS, third umpire Paul Wilson deemed the appeal “null and void” because it has been taken after the replay was shown on the big screen.
“We can’t go through this review anymore,” Wilson was heard saying. “There are replays on the big screen. “This is a null and void review.”
Kohli and the rest of the Indian players were understandably displeased with the turn of events. The replay showed that Wade would have indeed been out as the ball had struck in line and was going on to hit the stumps.
A captain is supposed to take DRS within 15 seconds but Kohli, according to cricket.com.au, had taken 17 seconds before making his decision.
Wade, who is the vice-captain of the Australian team, made a key contribution of 80 runs off 53 balls. Down 0-2 in the three-match series, Australia batted first at the Sydney Cricket Ground on Tuesday and posted a total of 186/5 in their 20 overs. The hosts won the match by 12 runs.
Here’s the full video of the incident:
UPDATE: Speaking about the incident after the match, Kohli said: “That LBW was a strange one, we were still discussing that if ball was going down leg side within the 15-second timeframe, they showed the replay on screen and decided to go for the review but Rod [Tucker] said nothing can be done.”
Kohli added that the mistake was from the television crew.
“[We felt] that these mistakes cannot be done at the highest level. In a very important game, this could be very costly. It was a little bit of a miss from the TV guys upstairs and I’m sure that it’s probably not going to be repeated. No one wants to be in a situation where you lose out on a very important moment in the game,” Kohli said.
Watch his comments from the 9-minute mark here:
#TeamIndia skipper @imVkohli reflects on the the LBW review that was disallowed by the on-field umpires in the final T20I against Australia. #AUSvIND pic.twitter.com/QlVVHloJEY
— BCCI (@BCCI) December 9, 2020
Twitter, though, was divided over the incident with many not sure if the right decision was taken.
Here are some reactions:
Right decision made. Can’t have the review after the replays are on the big screen. But was it up earlier than it should have been??? Or was it played only after 15 seconds had lapsed?? #Wade #Natarajan #AusvInd
— Aakash Chopra (@cricketaakash) December 8, 2020
The standard protocol is that you do not show the replay till the time for referral is past. There was no timer so we don't know if India were late. https://t.co/WOsfNSrs9w
— Harsha Bhogle (@bhogleharsha) December 8, 2020
The referral against Wade raises an interesting question. If the big screen shows the replay within the time allotted for the referral, can you disallow the referral? In this case we need to see the timer but the question is valid
— Harsha Bhogle (@bhogleharsha) December 8, 2020
#DRS was introduced to cut down on errors. #wade should have been walking back by now... it will hurt #virat, every run that comes now from #wade’s bat. #AUSAvIND
— Pragyan Ojha (@pragyanojha) December 8, 2020
How good! Batter misses a leg stump half volley. Bowler doesn’t appeal. Keeper turns down the review. Big screen dude plays the replay too early. Umpire accepts the review until the batter complains.
— Jimmy Neesham (@JimmyNeesh) December 8, 2020
That’s gotta be the most mistakes made in a 20 second window in all cricket 😂
India giving a masterclass on how to not use DRS. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻#AUSvIND
— Omkar Mankame (@Oam_16) December 8, 2020
India need to really review their review process. #DRS
— Nikhil 🏏 (@CricCrazyNIKS) December 8, 2020
India went about reviewing that decision with ineptitude that would make the Trump election challenging legal team look like paragons of competence.
— Tareque Laskar (@tarequelaskar) December 8, 2020
Umpires getting a lot right tonight. As spectators we are very quick to crucify, including me, but they have made some tight decisions & can’t disagree with any of them #AUSvIND
— Lisa Sthalekar (@sthalekar93) December 8, 2020