Medical ethics

Tainted former Medical Council of India chief installed as chief of the World Medical Association

The CBI had arrested Desai and three others in 2010 for allegedly accepting a bribe of Rs 2 crore to grant recognition to a medical college in Punjab.

On Friday, former Medical Council of India chief Dr Ketan Desai, who had been arrested six years ago on charges of corruption, was installed as the president of the World Medical Association for 2016-’17 at a meeting in Taiwan.

The Central Bureau of Investigation had arrested Desai and three others in 2010 for allegedly accepting a bribe of Rs 2 crore to grant recognition to a medical college in Punjab. The Supreme Court stayed the proceedings in this case. The CBI also booked Desai in another corruption case in Lucknow, but a special CBI court dropped charges of cheating and criminal conspiracy against him after it failed to obtain mandatory sanction from the government to prosecute him.

Desai had been elected to the post of president of the World Medical Association in 2009 , but his inauguration was suspended after his 2010 arrest. In 2013, after the Indian Medical Association defended Desai's credibility, the global body decided to lift the suspension of his appointment.

The World Medical Association represents millions of physicians worldwide and was created to “ensure the independence of physicians” and “to work for the highest possible standards of ethical behavior and care by physicians”, according to its website. Its members include medical associations from 112 countries.

The association’s spokesperson, Nigel Duncan, told Reuters that the association had nothing to say about the charges of corruption against Desai.

Scroll.in sent Desai an email seeking his response, which is awaited. This article will be updated once he responds.

Strong IMA support

The Indian Medical Association website has published a congratulatory message at Desai’s taking charge at the global body.

“The court case has nothing to do with this appointment,” said Indian Medical Association chief, Dr KK Aggarwal.

He added: “There is only one case left and that is stayed before the Supreme Court. He has never been convicted.”

In January, the Indian Medical Association issued a “white paper” on Desai, which explains the various allegations against him.

Authored by Aggarwal, the white paper says:

“IMA [Indian Medical Association] is clearly of the view/stand that unless any doctor member is convicted of any offence, he cannot be made to suffer any adversity or prejudice because of any charge sheet.”

Aggarwal said, “I am proud that IMA now has a world representative.”

In his inaugural speech as president of the global body, Desai said that professional honesty and integrity is at stake in many countries, and added that the medical profession needed transparency. “All referrals and prescriptions should be transparent,” he said.

Activists outraged

Health rights activists who had attempted to block Desai from taking over as head of the global body blamed the Indian Medical Association for fraudulently representing the urologist.

“It was very difficult for us,” said Dr Abhay Shukla of the National Alliance for Ethical Practices. “This lobbying was done at a global level.”

Dr Kunal Saha, who lives in the US and heads the non-profit, People for Better Treatment, has been fighting against Desai’s appointment to the global body since 2010.

His latest letter, dated October 16, was to the outgoing president of the World Medical Association, Professor Micheal Marmot. In the email, Saha asked Marmot to ensure that Desai did not assume the position of president of the organisation as it would send a “wrong signal to the people and undermine the fundamental dignity of the medical community at large”.

The appointment "is nothing less than a sheer atrocity that will send a strong demoralizing message to the ordinary people and hapless patients of India”, Saha said in the email.

Support our journalism by subscribing to Scroll+ here. We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BY 

Snippets of wisdom on the health care industry by Dr. Kevin Lofton

His sessions stressed on the importance of patient centric healthcare.

At the Hospital Leadership Summit 2017, Dr Kevin Lofton, CEO Catholic Health Initiatives, spoke on the need to focus on patient experience, the role of the leader and shared some ideas from the practices of his own hospital chain. Here are some snippets from Dr Lofton’s presentation that will provide some food for thought. The Bringing Health to Life content hub contains his and many other insights and best practices for healthcare delivery.

The two kinds of willing patients

During the summit, a consensus emerged that the health care industry needs to learn customer centricity from other industries. However, the health care industry is unique in several ways and one of the fundamental differences is the nature of its customer. Dr Lofton spoke about how the customer i.e. the patient in the health care industry is different by way of motivation. He reminded the gathering that nobody willingly seeks out a doctor.

Play

The paradigm shift needed in health care

Dr Lofton emphasised that patient centricity needs to become a part of the very philosophy of a health care facility, a philosophy that drives every action and motivates every employee in the organisation. He described this revaluation of purpose as a paradigm shift. Dr Lofton spoke about how patient centricity starts much before the patient walks into the hospital, that the patient’s tryst with the health care system starts before a visit to the doctor is warranted. In this clip, Dr Lofton provides an example of one such paradigm shift for health care providers.

Play

At the 2017 Hospital Leadership Summit, Dr Lofton shared several such insights from his experience in the US health care system. He emphasised especially on the need of empathy alongside clinical skill among health care providers.

For more insights and best practices for healthcare delivery, visit Abbott’s Bringing Health to Life portal.

This article was produced on behalf of Abbott by the Scroll.in marketing team and not by the Scroll.in editorial staff.