Public Health Watch

Rajasthan is trying to fix staff shortages at health facilities – but that’s creating other problems

The state has privatised the management of some its primary health centres. But the low wages have prompted many qualified staff to quit.

Lalita Malviya is a lady health visitor at a primary health centre or PHC in Ambirama village in Pratapgarh district of Rajasthan. Her job involves supervising three sub-centres, within the area served by her PHC. For the residents of the area, these facilities are their first point of contact with the public health system. A lady health visitor usually has a few years of experience as an auxiliary nurse and midwife, but 25-year-old Malviya had no experience when she started the job last year. Having just completed a diploma degree in nursing, she was hired after the Rajasthan government handed over management of the Ambirama PHC to the non-profit organisation WISH Foundation.

It was one of 41 PHCs that the state government allotted to private organisations early in 2016 in public private partnerships. Rajasthan said that this arrangement was necessary to overcome the staff shortages that had arisen at PHCs across the state because doctors and other medical personnel were unwilling to serve in rural areas, especially in the state’s desert and tribal regions. Private organisations running PHCs have been filling vacancies by hiring less experienced personnel like Malviya.

In addition to being relatively inexperienced, staff at these privately-run PHCs are often paid less than their counterparts in PHCs that are still run by the state government. As a consequence, staff attrition at privately manages PHCs is also high. This month, for instance, six PHCs run by Geetanjali Hospital and Medical College lost 11 employees and PHCs run by the Chitransh Education and Welfare Society lost 13.

“The staff at PHCs run on PPP keeps changing,” said Dr OP Bairwa, chief medical health officer at Pratapgarh. “So there is no continuity of medical services. People do not trust them much then.”

But despite such complaints by block and district level health officials, the state health department recently conducted a partial evaluation of the programme and declared it a success.

An Auxillary Nurse Midwife conducts a health check at a primary health centre in Rajasthan. Photo: Menaka Rao
An Auxillary Nurse Midwife conducts a health check at a primary health centre in Rajasthan. Photo: Menaka Rao

The inexperience and rapid turnover of the staff at many of Rajasthan’s privately-run PHCs have diminished their efficiency. PHCs treat minor health problems and refer more serious illnesses to larger health facilities. But PHCs also play a crucial role in healthcare and promoting good health practices. For this, health workers need to develop trust in the communities they work with, which requires both experience and time.

For instance, said Dr Sanjeev Tank, chief medical officer of Udaipur district where six PHCs are run in public private partnerships, an auxiliary nurse and midwife with significant field experience is more effective in boosting preventive and promotive health services like immunisation programmes.

Little money

The gap between the wages of staff in privately run PHCs and government facilities can be significant. Malviya in Ambirama earns about Rs 10,000 a month, less than a third of what a lady health visitor employed by the government gets.

Kuldeep Joshi, a laboratory technician at the PHC at Achnera village in Pratapgarh run by Chitransh, earns Rs 6,000 a month – even as a government employee doing the same job would earn a little more than Rs 20,000. Ironically, Joshi had to take a salary cut last year. When WISH Foundation ran the PHC, he was paid Rs 10,000 a month.

At most privately-run PHCs, general nurses, pharmacists and lab technicians get paid only Rs 10,000 to Rs 12,000 per month.

Why do private operators pay their staff so little? The operators that the government does not give them enough money to increase salaries. The government pays private organisations between Rs 22 lakh and Rs 35 lakh per PHC per year, depending on how much the operator had bid to get the contract.

In a petition in the Rajasthan High Court, the health network Jan Swasthya Abhiyan asked that the public private partnership arrangement be discontinued. The petition pointed out that this amount is grossly insufficient to run a PHC and its sub-centres, so private operators compromise on delivery of healthcare and underpay their staff. The public private partnership agreements do not specify whether the salaries of staff hired by the private operators should adhere to government standards.

“The government is paying for staff [at the privately-run PHCs] at the fresher level,” said Dr RN Meena, the state’s joint director for hospital administration. “When we continue this for 5-10 years, these people will get promoted and earn more money.”

Anil Mathur who runs Chitransh said that the organisation cannot afford to pay employees at the same levels as government salaries. “Our employees are social workers,” he said. “We pay them honorarium, not salary.”

Kuldeep Joshi works as a laboratory technician in Achnera PHC. Photo: Menaka Rao
Kuldeep Joshi works as a laboratory technician in Achnera PHC. Photo: Menaka Rao

Underpaid medical personnel do not stay long at these privately-run PHCs.

Rajesh Singh, chief operating officer of WISH Foundation, said that the organisation’s PHCs have a staff shortage of about 40%. “We have been paying more salary to doctors in remote areas,” he said. “If we give them below par salaries, they will run away. We try to incentivise their stay by arranging for accommodation sometimes.”

He claimed that the organisation spends nearly 45% more money on running the PHCs than what the government gives them. The additional money comes from donors, he said.

Not all private providers can afford to pay higher salaries to their staff. “We try to manage with as much money as is given to us,” said Anil Mathur of Chitransh, which runs four PHCs in Banswara, Sirohi and Pratapgarh districts.

Tank said that private operators do not seem to have a plan to address the problem of high attrition. This leads to government health officials having to conduct repeatedly train new personnel.

“We train new recruits again and again but the staff [at privately-run PHCs] does not understand our government programmes well,” he added.

However, Omi Singh of Geetanjali Hospital which runs the six PHCs, denied that the government trains staff at these facilities.

In Karnataka, public private partnerships under the Arogya Bandhu scheme allowed non-governmental organisations to run PHCs. Like in Rajasthan, the private operators paid the staff much less than the government. An evaluation done by Indian Institute of Health Management Research in Bengaluru, found that this resulted in recruitment of less qualified staff. “It is very important to maintain the standardisation in the remuneration for the staff, because it is one of the motivational factors to work in the rural areas,” the institute said in its report.

Tough working conditions

Priyanka Lohar left her job as the lady health visitor at Savina PHC on the outskirts of Udaipur city when she got a contractual government job as an auxiliary nurse and midwife. “In the PPP mode, we do not even get travel or mobile expenses,” she said. “In the government job, at least that will be covered.”

Besides, personnel on government contracts may get permanent well-paying government jobs.

Staff in the PHCs under private management are allowed only one day off a week and do not get any other leave. If a doctor misses work for a day, the government cuts Rs 1,500 from the monthly payment to the private operator. The penalty for a paramedic missing a day of work is Rs 500.

Despite the low salary and poor working conditions Singh, who runs the PHCs for Geetanjali Hospital, believe that the PHC employees get a fair deal.

“Government doctor ke nakhre hote hai,” he said. “They throw tantrums. They take leave often. We do not have that problem.”

Anaemic pregnant women get their doses of iron-sucrose intravenously in Dalot PHC, Pratapgarh district. Photo: Menaka Rao
Anaemic pregnant women get their doses of iron-sucrose intravenously in Dalot PHC, Pratapgarh district. Photo: Menaka Rao

Dr T Sundararaman, dean of the School of Health Systems at Mumbai’s Tata Institute of Social Sciences, said the PHC partnership model works on the flawed expectation that the private player will run the PHC on lower costs and higher motivation. “But this motivation is only at the ownership level,” he said.

Unnecessary shortage?

Why is the government unable to get doctors and other staff to work in rural areas in the first place?

Dr Kishore Murthy, a healthcare researcher in Bengaluru, blames the bureaucratic and inefficient system of filling vacancies. “Some government officials feel the PPP model gives them the freedom to fill posts when necessary,” he said.

Sundararaman said the recruitment deficiency in the public health system has existed for a long time but there are simple ways to fix it. “The government should not wait for vacancies to fill posts and should in fact have a surplus of staff to account for employees quitting or going on leave,” he said.

Doctors are dissuaded from working in rural areas by the lower standard of living there, lack of education opportunities for their children and absence of technology, among other things, argued Dr Vikas Bajpai from the Centre for Social Medicine and Community Health, Jawaharlal Nehru University, Delhi. “All these aspects can only be taken care of by the government, not a non-governmental body,” he said.

The Indian Army Medical Corps is proof that the government can fix this problem, Bajpai added. “I am unable to understand how the government with its reach and logistics is not able to provide for doctors,” he said. “What qualities does an NGO have to provide care to people where the government has failed?”

We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BY 

“My body instantly craves chai and samosa”

German expats talk about adapting to India, and the surprising similarities between the two cultures.

The cultural similarities between Germany and India are well known, especially with regards to the language. Linguists believe that Sanskrit and German share the same Indo-Germanic heritage of languages. A quick comparison indeed holds up theory - ratha in Sanskrit (chariot) is rad in German, aksha (axle) in Sanskrit is achse in German and so on. Germans have long held a fascination for Indology and Sanskrit. While Max Müller is still admired for his translation of ancient Indian scriptures, other German intellectuals such as Goethe, Herder and Schlegel were deeply influenced by Kalidasa. His poetry is said to have informed Goethe’s plays, and inspired Schlegel to eventually introduce formal Indology in Germany. Beyond the arts and academia, Indian influences even found their way into German fast food! Indians would recognise the famous German curry powder as a modification of the Indian masala mix. It’s most popular application is the currywurst - fried sausage covered in curried ketchup.

It is no wonder then that German travellers in India find a quite a lot in common between the two cultures, even today. Some, especially those who’ve settled here, even confess to Indian culture growing on them with time. Isabelle, like most travellers, first came to India to explore the country’s rich heritage. She returned the following year as an exchange student, and a couple of years later found herself working for an Indian consultancy firm. When asked what prompted her to stay on, Isabelle said, “I love the market dynamics here, working here is so much fun. Anywhere else would seem boring compared to India.” Having cofounded a company, she eventually realised her entrepreneurial dream here and now resides in Goa with her husband.

Isabelle says there are several aspects of life in India that remind her of home. “How we interact with our everyday life is similar in both Germany and India. Separate house slippers to wear at home, the celebration of food and festivals, the importance of friendship…” She feels Germany and India share the same spirit especially in terms of festivities. “We love food and we love celebrating food. There is an entire countdown to Christmas. Every day there is some dinner or get-together,” much like how Indians excitedly countdown to Navratri or Diwali. Franziska, who was born in India to German parents, adds that both the countries exhibit the same kind of passion for their favourite sport. “In India, they support cricket like anything while in Germany it would be football.”

Having lived in India for almost a decade, Isabelle has also noticed some broad similarities in the way children are brought up in the two countries. “We have a saying in South Germany ‘Schaffe Schaffe Hausle baue’ that loosely translates to ‘work, work, work and build a house’. I found that parents here have a similar outlook…to teach their children to work hard. They feel that they’ve fulfilled their duty only once the children have moved out or gotten married. Also, my mother never let me leave the house without a big breakfast. It’s the same here.” The importance given to the care of the family is one similarity that came up again and again in conversations with all German expats.

While most people wouldn’t draw parallels between German and Indian discipline (or lack thereof), Germans married to Indians have found a way to bridge the gap. Take for example, Ilka, who thinks that the famed differences of discipline between the two cultures actually works to her marital advantage. She sees the difference as Germans being highly planning-oriented; while Indians are more flexible in their approach. Ilka and her husband balance each other out in several ways. She says, like most Germans, she too tends to get stressed when her plans don’t work out, but her husband calms her down.

Consequently, Ilka feels India is “so full of life. The social life here is more happening; people smile at you, bond over food and are much more relaxed.” Isabelle, too, can attest to Indians’ friendliness. When asked about an Indian characteristic that makes her feel most at home, she quickly answers “humour.” “Whether it’s a taxi driver or someone I’m meeting professionally, I’ve learnt that it’s easy to lighten the mood here by just cracking a few jokes. Indians love to laugh,” she adds.

Indeed, these Germans-who-never-left as just diehard Indophiles are more Indian than you’d guess at first, having even developed some classic Indian skills with time. Ilka assures us that her husband can’t bargain as well as she does, and that she can even drape a saree on her own.

Isabelle, meanwhile, feels some amount of Indianness has seeped into her because “whenever its raining, my body instantly craves chai and samosa”.

Like the long-settled German expats in India, the German airline, Lufthansa, too has incorporated some quintessential aspects of Indian culture in its service. Recognising the centuries-old cultural affinity between the two countries, Lufthansa now provides a rich experience of Indian hospitality to all flyers on board its flights to and from India. You can expect a greeting of Namaste by an all-Indian crew, Indian food, and popular Indian in-flight entertainment options. And as the video shows, India’s culture and hospitality have been internalized by Lufthansa to the extent that they are More Indian Than You Think. To experience Lufthansa’s hospitality on your next trip abroad, click here.

Play

This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of Lufthansa as part of their More Indian Than You Think initiative and not by the Scroll editorial team.