Modi was half-right: World's first plastic surgeon may well have been Indian (but he wasn't Shiva)
Surgeons on the subcontinent had been doing nose jobs millennia before much of the rest of the world caught on.
That wasn't all. Ancient India was also aware of genetic science, Modi said at the inauguration of the Nita Ambani-run Sir H.N. Reliance Foundation Hospital and Research Centre in Mumbai. To back up this assertion, he noted that Karna of the Mahabharata was born outside his mother’s womb.
By citing mythology as factual evidence of scientific progress, Modi seemed to be setting himself for ridicule. Newspapers in India and abroad did not miss the opportunity to take sarcastic digs at the prime minister's statements, and, as was to be expected, social media users joined in too.
Modi could have spared himself the embarrassment if he'd put aside the epics and reached for some real Sanskrit treatises instead. Had he looked at the Sushruta Samhita, for instance, he would have found a description of one the world's first plastic surgeries by Sushruta. In his treatise, Sushruta writes about grafting a piece of skin from the cheek to the nose around 500 CE.
He also lays out instructions for how to reconstruct a nose with a flap of living skin carved from the cheek, treating it with liquorice and sandalwood. Europeans did not perfect rhinoplasty until the 19th century.
Sushruta was not the first physician from the subcontinent to detail his treatments. Shalihotra, perhaps the world’s first recorded veterinarian, wrote a long treatise on the care of horses some thousand years before that. He not only recommended what medicines to give horses when they were ill, but also detailed surgical procedures such as eye operations and bloodletting.
Bloodletting on a horse. Illustration and text, 18th century. From Asvacikitsa. Photo credit: Wellcome Library, London.
Eye operation on a horse. Illustration and text, 18th century. From Salihotra (Hindi): Asvacikitsa of Purusottama [treatise on horses]. Photo credit: Wellcome Library, London.
As is evident, India has a long and thriving history of medical treatment. Traditional medical systems such as unani and ayurveda, which call for holistic healing, are vibrant in India even today. While they are looked upon with some distrust by western medical practitioners, these practices even have a department under the union health ministry to themselves, AYUSH, which deals with ayurveda,yoga, unani, siddha and naturopathy.
Visual evidence of India's long medical history can be found in the collection of The Wellcome Trust, a health-oriented international charity based in London, has been collecting images of medical practices from across the world since the 1890s.
The library has over 2,50,000 paintings, prints and drawings, some of which document the subcontinent's transition from Indian to western medicine, as ear cleaners and surgical veterinarians give way to British-run plague hospitals and informative posters about leprosy. Here is a selection.
Earthenware jar with Urdu inscription containing unani medical preparations, 1801. Photo credit: Wellcome Library, London.
Physician taking pulse. By a Delhi painter. Watercolour, 1825. Published: [Delhi], [ca. 1825]. Photo credit: Wellcome Library, London.
An ear cleaner at work. By an unnamed Delhi painter, commissioned by Colonel James Skinner. Watercolour, 1825. Published: [Delhi], [ca 1825]. Photo credit: Wellcome Library, London.
A child with plague in a hospital bed, a nurse and two men by his side, during the plague epidemic in Mumbai. Photograph attributed to Captain C Moss, 1897. Photo credit: Wellcome Library, London.
Interior of a temporary hospital for plague victims. Mumbai plague epidemic, 1896-1897. Photo credit: Wellcome Library, London.
Leprosy: patients showing symptoms. Colour lithograph, [195-?]. By Hind Kusht Nivaran Sangh. Photo credit: Wellcome Library, London.
Leprosy: patients showing symptoms. Colour lithograph, [195-?] By Hind Kusht Nivaran Sangh. Photo credit: Wellcome Library, London.
Colour photograph showing an anatomical model advertising a pharmacy in Delhi, India. The model is behind glass and surrounded with bottles. The pharmacist's name, Kaviraj A N Roy, BSc, MASFRMP, is written on a label at the top left of the glass case. A man, perhaps the pharmacist, sits reading a book. Photograph, 1993. By Ben Dray. Photo credit: Wellcome Library, London.
Correction: This piece has been edited to reflect that Sushruta wrote his Samhita around 500 CE, not 600 BCE.
