Mirwaiz Umar Farooq, the chairman of the Hurriyat Conference, along with six other separatist leaders, including Masarat Alam, whose recent release from detention had been the subject of a heated controversy, were among the invitees.
Alam begged off, citing ill-health, but the Indian external affairs ministry stuck to the script. "The Government of India prefers to speak for itself," rebuked its spokesperson, Syed Akbaruddin. "There should be no scope for misunderstanding or misrepresenting India's position on the role of the so-called Hurriyat... there are only two parties and there is no place for a third party in resolution of India-Pakistan issues."
Despite the rhetoric, all seemed to be well on the Indo-Pak diplomacy front when Prime Minister Narendra Modi tweeted that he had greeted his counterpart Nawaz Sharif for Pakistan’s National Day.
Not only that, none other than the country's second ranked diplomat, the minister of state for external affairs, former army chief General VK Singh, was deputed to represent the Indian government at the reception.
Come the evening, and there was the usual jingoistic bombast on certain television channels, with apoplectic hosts working themselves into a lather.
Debating tonight on @thenewshour: Just call it off! Why the long rope to Pakistan now? #PartyWithEnemy
— TIMES NOW (@TimesNow) March 23, 2015
Fmr Army Chief & MoS MEA, Gen VK Singh attends Pakistan Day celebrations in New Delhi #PartyWithEnemy pic.twitter.com/Lcs5AnjRAw
— TIMES NOW (@TimesNow) March 23, 2015
There were also those who welcomed the seeming diplomatic thaw.
On a day when @PMOIndia reaches out to Pak, what's wrong with kebab diplomacy? Why the outrage with an annual ritual? Need to grow up.
— Rajdeep Sardesai (@sardesairajdeep) March 23, 2015
Others pointed to the irony of the situation, recalling earlier posturing:
Whoever invented screenshots deserves a Bharat Ratna pic.twitter.com/VTLroz3aeE
— Baba Chicago Waley (@BabaGlocal) March 23, 2015
As the hashtag #PartyWithEnemy seemed to pick up, Singh seems to have decided to pitch in with a series of cryptic tweets of his own:
#DUTY A task or action that a person is bound to perform for moral or legal reasons
— Vijay Kumar Singh (@Gen_VKSingh) March 23, 2015
#DUTY The force that binds one morally or legally to one's obligations
— Vijay Kumar Singh (@Gen_VKSingh) March 23, 2015
#DUTY A job or service allocated
— Vijay Kumar Singh (@Gen_VKSingh) March 23, 2015
#DISGUST To sicken or fill with loathing
— Vijay Kumar Singh (@Gen_VKSingh) March 23, 2015
#DISGUST To offend the moral sense, principles, or taste of
— Vijay Kumar Singh (@Gen_VKSingh) March 23, 2015
While most were left puzzled and intrigued by Singh’s tweets, they seem to have provided just the grist that the gossip mills needed, leading to speculation that he was “unhappy about representing the government at the Pakistan Day function after his followers on Twitter criticised him for attending the event.”
Gen VK Singh's twitter comments rebellious, embarrassment to government: sources
— NDTV (@ndtv) March 23, 2015
Singh, who has a history with such indiscreet tweeting and had once infamously tweeted “Presstitute” to describe certain news journalists, responded with yet another salvo before retreating for the night:
#'Disgust'ed to see how certain sections of the media are twisting this issue
— Vijay Kumar Singh (@Gen_VKSingh) March 23, 2015
Meanwhile, it had become a free for all on Twitter, as people tried to make sense of what exactly was going on, with speculation, sarcasm and satire.
Dinner. Duty. Disgust.
— Shiv Aroor (@ShivAroor) March 23, 2015
Duty. Disgust. Duty. Disgust. Duty. Disgust. Drink. Drunk. Drink. Drunk. Drink. Drunk.
— Seema Goswami (@seemagoswami) March 23, 2015
LOL. General VK Singh is tweeting the dictionary. Should check what DATE OF BIRTH means.
— TheComicProject (@thecomicproject) March 23, 2015
Gen VK Singh should consider taking this Govt to Court for orders he doesn't like.
— Ankur Bhardwaj (@Bhayankur) March 23, 2015
Lol he even wore green jacket “@dna: Pakistan Day: VK Singh attends reception; later tweets of 'Disgust' and 'Duty' pic.twitter.com/VknNjyOc3e”
— TheComicProject (@thecomicproject) March 23, 2015
#Confusion: When you are not sure of your birth date.
— Amreekan Desi (@amreekandesi) March 23, 2015
*badaumdish* RT @Joydas General VK Singh should have two Twitter Accounts. One Official, another Unofficial. Like his Date-of-Birth
— Kabir Taneja (@KabirTaneja) March 23, 2015
Moral of the story: NEVER tweet after bellyful of biryani.
— xxxheadlinetocomexxx (@sidin) March 23, 2015
Also, as MOS External Affairs, he *has* to attend such events. Why in the world is it such a big deal? What have I not understood?
— Sachin Kalbag (@SachinKalbag) March 23, 2015
General VK Singh disgusted that unpatriotic media unable to appreciate his noble sacrifice of truth
— RushdieExplainsIndia (@RushdieExplains) March 23, 2015
V K Singh's twitter feed now is like the stream of consciousness of a man shopping with wife and in-laws.
— Arnab Ray (@greatbong) March 23, 2015
Did VK Singh have a conversation with Shahid Afridi about birth certificates? #PartywithEnemy #runs
— Arnab Ray (@greatbong) March 23, 2015
Why does an Indian Minister ( Gen. V.K. Singh ) attend a function organized by a fake, artificial entity called Pakistan ?
— Markandey Katju (@mkatju) March 23, 2015
Heh. He might be disgusted but he remembered to put on a green jacket! pic.twitter.com/CrV6barU4R #outrage
— Rohit Pradhan (@Retributions) March 23, 2015
Hmm. Somehow think the government may want to blame this round on a "non state actor" ;-)
— barkha dutt (@BDUTT) March 23, 2015
On Tuesday, as the day dawned, one would have thought that Singh would at least be a little chastened by the all-round roasting he had received the night before, but he seemed oblivious to it all, as he launched his morning operations with yet another Tweet:
@Gen_VKSingh https://t.co/F8LXh0OoXO. Indian Express proves that P Word fits them like a glove.
— Vijay Kumar Singh (@Gen_VKSingh) March 24, 2015
Singh may have been alluding to something other than his own unforgettable coinage, "presstitute", but enquiring minds were left wondering.
Very very keen to know from the General what the 'P' word here means. Only from the man himself. https://t.co/odagpYVxFV
— Smita Prakash (@smitaprakash) March 24, 2015
Perhaps the last word is best reserved for a man whose own tweeting while in government had resulted in unintended consequences:
Why @Gen_VKSingh is a good man doing a bad job: my column http://t.co/GdkQP6LQBy
— Shashi Tharoor (@ShashiTharoor) March 24, 2015
And the last words from the column:
There's an old line about diplomacy that says: "If he says yes, he means maybe; if he says maybe, he means no; if he says no, he's no diplomat." Gen VK Singh, whom I genuinely like as a person, is no diplomat.
If the Prime Minister is serious about his diplomatic opening to Pakistan, he needs to harness General Singh's considerable professional qualities for something more appropriately up his street - a job in which he can say "No". Give him the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan or the bullet train project, and let his office in South Block be occupied by someone who understands the difference " between calling someone a liar and pointing out gently that he may have inadvertently been guilty of terminological inexactitude.