Opinion

The lesson from Sanjiv Bhatt’s dismissal: there’s nobody to protect whistle-blowing civil servants

The Gujarat IPS officer was given the highest administrative punishment – of dismissal from service – for taking ‘unauthorised leave’. But the real cause may be his allegations against Modi.

In yet another display of vendetta against prominent critics of the prime minister, Gujarat IPS officer Sanjiv Bhatt was served with orders of dismissal from service on August 13, 2015. This is the highest administrative punishment that an officer can face, provided in the rule book for only the most serious transgressions. The charges cited for Bhatt’s dismissal, however, are only unauthorised leave of absence for a few weeks and indiscipline. His dishonourable discharge from service raises many questions about the independence of public institutions and officials, and points to our failures to protect whistle-blowers within the permanent civil services.

In order to shield upright and independent civil servants in the higher All India Services – the Indian Administrative Service and Indian Police Service – from possible malevolent action by the political leadership under which the officers serve, the major penalty of dismissal requires concurrence by both the central and state governments, as well as the Union Public Services Commission. For Bhatt’s dismissal the agreement of the state government and the union Ministry of Home Affairs is unsurprising – even if unfortunate – given his grave charges against the man who is currently the country’s prime minister.

However, what is extremely worrying in Bhatt’s case is the role of the UPSC, which is a Constitutional body set up under Article 315 of the Constitution. According to Bhatt, the first communication that he received from the UPSC was dated July 21, 2015, and this letter informed him that his removal from service was being contemplated. Bhatt sent his reply to the UPSC on August 1, seeking documents and grounds, and asserting his right to defend himself in person before the Commission against these charges. Making allowance for time for the letter to be delivered, it took the Commission barely five to seven working days to arrive at an ex-parte decision without once hearing the officer before dismissing him. It passed the final orders for his dismissal from service on August 13.

Flimsy grounds for punishment

On the face of it, the main charge made against Bhatt, of unauthorised absence of a few weeks, is astonishingly flimsy as grounds for the highest punishment of dismissal from service. I have known IAS officers who proceeded on unauthorised absence sometimes for years, taking employment overseas or with private companies, but escaped any punishment for years, let alone dismissal. Even if it is accepted that his leave was unauthorised – something that Bhatt contests – a rap on the knuckles with a written warning or letter of displeasure, and leave without pay for the period of absence, would seem a reasonable and proportionate penalty for the alleged misdemeanour.

In reality, the official ire he faces is only because of his audacity to testify against the country’s most powerful man. Sanjiv Bhatt utilised those days of “unauthorised leave” to testify before the Special Investigation Team of the Supreme Court, and Raju Ramachandran, the amicus curiae of the Supreme Court, investigating charges by Zakia Jafri. Zakia Jafri, widow of former MP Ehsan Jafri who was brutally killed along with around 70 others at Gulbarg Apartments in Ahmedabad in 2002, held then Chief Minister Narendra Modi to be the first accused for a “deliberate and intentional failure” to protect life and property and failure to fulfil his constitutional duty.

In Sanjiv Bhatt’s testimony to the SIT (a copy of which he later filed on oath before the Supreme Court), he had charged that late at night on February 27, 2002, after 58 pilgrims had been burned alive in a train compartment in Godhra and the Vishva Hindu Parishad had announced a programme to parade the bodies of those killed, Chief Minister Narendra Modi had called an urgent meeting which Bhatt also attended as an intelligence officer. He charged that Chief Minister Modi “impressed upon the gathering that for too long the Gujarat Police had been following the principle of balancing the actions of Hindus and Muslims while dealing with the communal riots in Gujarat. This time the situation warranted that the Muslims be taught a lesson to ensure that such incidents do not recur again”. He further alleged that Modi “expressed the view that the emotions were running very high amongst the Hindus and it was imperative that they be allowed to vent their anger”.

Failure of institutions

The other officers alleged to be present at the meeting said they had no memory of these instructions by Modi. His driver and a BBC correspondent who was present with him when he left for the alleged meeting however testified that he had indeed proceeded for this meeting. The SIT concluded that Bhatt was not present at the meeting, and that he was an unreliable witness. Raju Ramachandran, the Supreme Court’s amicus curiae, held a different opinion. He questioned how the SIT could rely on the testimony of witnesses who were present at the meeting when the investigation had raised doubts concerning their credibility. He felt that the question of whether Bhatt was present or not in the meeting needed to be tested in court because the evidence available was insufficient to discount Bhatt’s claims. Ramachandran believed that the alleged statements made by Modi, if they were true, were actionable in law and that the veracity of those allegations should also be tested in court.

The official action against Bhatt – of dismissing him from service – stands in stark contrast to the fate of other police officers, charged with infinitely more grave and culpable crimes than unauthorised absence from service. These officers charged with extra-judicial killings, including of a teenaged girl and an older woman, are out of prison, freed on bail with the open or tacit backing of the state or central government. Not a single officer has been punished for failing to perform their duty to control the communal carnage of 2002.

What is pertinent here is not the truth or otherwise of Bhatt’s claims against Narendra Modi. Zakia Jafri’s appeal against the lower court’s order absolving Modi of criminal responsibility for the 2002 massacre is still being heard. What is irrelevant also is Bhatt’s reputation and record as a police officer. What is undisputed is that Bhatt was a whistle-blower, a serving police officer who chose to make extremely serious criminal charges against a man who was then his chief minister, and is now the country’s prime minister. In these circumstances, it was the duty of the country’s constitutional institutions – the UPSC and the higher judiciary – and the senior civil service to protect him from official vengeance. All of these have instead chosen to abjectly fail him, exposing again the enfeeblement and partisanship of our public institutions.

We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BY 

Ten awesome TV shows to get over your post-GoT blues

With those withdrawal symptoms kicking in, all you need is a good rebound show.

Hangovers tend to have a debilitating effect on various human faculties, but a timely cure can ease that hollow feeling generally felt in the pit of the stomach. The Game of Thrones Season 7 finale has left us with that similar empty feeling, worsened by an official statement on the 16-month-long wait to witness The Great War. That indeed is a long time away from our friends Dany, Jon, Queen C and even sweet, sweet Podrick. While nothing can quite replace the frosty thrill of Game of Thrones, here’s a list of awesome shows, several having won multiple Emmy awards, that are sure to vanquish those nasty withdrawal symptoms:

1. Billions

There is no better setting for high stakes white collar crime than the Big Apple. And featuring a suited-up Paul Giamatti going head-to-head with the rich and ruthless Damien Lewis in New York, what’s not to like? Only two seasons young, this ShowTime original series promises a wolf-of-wall-street style showcase of power, corruption and untold riches. Billions is a great high-octane drama option if you want to keep the momentum going post GoT.

Watch Billions Now

2. Westworld

What do you get when the makers of the Dark Knight Trilogy and the studio behind Game of Thrones collaborate to remake a Michael Crichton classic? Westworld brings together two worlds: an imagined future and the old American West, with cowboys, gun slingers - the works. This sci-fi series manages to hold on to a dark secret by wrapping it with the excitement and adventure of the wild west. Once the plot is unwrapped, the secret reveals itself as a genius interpretation of human nature and what it means to be human. Regardless of what headspace you’re in, this Emmy-nominated series will absorb you in its expansive and futuristic world. If you don’t find all of the above compelling enough, you may want to watch Westworld simply because George RR Martin himself recommends it! Westworld will return for season 2 in the spring of 2018.

Watch Westworld Now

3. Big Little Lies

It’s a distinct possibility that your first impressions of this show, whether you form those from the trailer or opening sequence, will make you think this is just another sun-kissed and glossy Californian drama. Until, the dark theme of BLL descends like an eerie mist, that is. With the serious acting chops of Reese Witherspoon and Nicole Kidman as leads, this murder mystery is one of a kind. Adapted from author Liane Moriarty’s book, this female-led show has received accolades for shattering the one-dimensional portrayal of women on TV. Despite the stellar star cast, this Emmy-nominated show wasn’t easy to make. You should watch Big Little Lies if only for Reese Witherspoon’s long struggle to get it off the ground.

Watch Big Little Lies Now

4. The Night of

The Night Of is one of the few crime dramas featuring South Asians without resorting to tired stereotypes. It’s the kind of show that will keep you in its grip with its mysterious plotline, have you rooting for its characters and leave you devastated and furious. While the narrative revolves around a murder and the mystery that surrounds it, its undertones raises questions on racial, class and courtroom politics. If you’re a fan of True Detective or Law & Order and are looking for something serious and thoughtful, look no further than this series of critical acclaim.

Watch The Night Of Now

5. American Horror Story

As the name suggests, AHS is a horror anthology for those who can stomach some gore and more. In its 6 seasons, the show has covered a wide range of horror settings like a murder house, freak shows, asylums etc. and the latest season is set to explore cults. Fans of Sarah Paulson and Jessica Lange are in for a treat, as are Lady Gaga’s fans. If you pride yourself on not being weak of the heart, give American Horror Story a try.

Watch American Horror Story Now

6. Empire

At its heart, Empire is a simple show about a family business. It just so happens that this family business is a bit different from the sort you are probably accustomed to, because this business entails running a record label, managing artistes and when push comes to shove, dealing with rivals in a permanent sort of manner. Empire treads some unique ground as a fairly violent show that also happens to be a musical. Lead actors Taraji P Henson and Terrence Howard certainly make it worth your while to visit this universe, but it’s the constantly evolving interpersonal relations and bevy of cameo appearances that’ll make you stay. If you’re a fan of hip hop, you’ll enjoy a peek into the world that makes it happen. Hey, even if you aren’t one, you might just grow fond of rap and hip hop.

Watch Empire Now

7. Modern Family

When everything else fails, it’s comforting to know that the family will always be there to lift your spirits and keep you chuckling. And by the family we mean the Dunphys, Pritchetts and Tuckers, obviously. Modern Family portrays the hues of familial bonds with an honesty that most family shows would gloss over. Eight seasons in, the show’s characters like Gloria and Phil Dunphy have taken on legendary proportions in their fans’ minds as they navigate their relationships with relentless bumbling humour. If you’re tired of irritating one-liners or shows that try too hard, a Modern Family marathon is in order. This multiple-Emmy-winning sitcom is worth revisiting, especially since the brand new season 9 premiers on 28th September 2017.

Watch Modern Family Now

8. The Deuce

Headlined by James Franco and Maggi Gyllenhaal, The Deuce is not just about the dazzle of the 1970s, with the hippest New York crowd dancing to disco in gloriously flamboyant outfits. What it IS about is the city’s nooks and crannies that contain its underbelly thriving on a drug epidemic. The series portrays the harsh reality of New York city in the 70s following the legalisation of the porn industry intertwined with the turbulence caused by mob violence. You’ll be hooked if you are a fan of The Wire and American Hustle, but keep in mind it’s grimmer and grittier. The Deuce offers a turbulent ride which will leave you wanting more.

Watch The Deuce Now

9. Dexter

In case you’re feeling vengeful, you can always get the spite out of your system vicariously by watching Dexter, our favourite serial killer. This vigilante killer doesn’t hide behind a mask or a costume, but sneaks around like a criminal, targeting the bad guys that have slipped through the justice system. From its premier in 2006 to its series finale in 2013, the Emmy-nominated Michael C Hall, as Dexter, has kept fans in awe of the scientific precision in which he conducts his kills. For those who haven’t seen the show, the opening credits give an accurate glimpse of how captivating the next 45 minutes will be. If it’s been a while since you watched in awe as the opening credits rolled, maybe you should revisit the world’s most loved psychopath for nostalgia’s sake.

Available starting October

10. Rome

If you’re still craving an epic drama with extensive settings and a grandiose plot and sub-plots, Rome, co-produced by HBO and BBC, is where your search stops. Rome is a historical drama that takes you through an overwhelming journey of Ancient Rome’s transition from a republic to an empire. And when it comes to tastes, this series provides the similar full-bodied flavour that you’ve grown to love about Game of Thrones. There’s a lot to take away for those who grew up quoting Julius Caesar, and for those looking for a realistic depiction of the legendary gladiators. If you’re a history buff, give this Emmy-winning show a try.

Watch Rome Now

For your next obsession, Hotstar Premium has you covered with its wide collection of the most watched shows in the world. Apart from the ones we’ve recommended, Indian viewers can now easily watch other universally loved shows such as Silicon Valley and Prison Break, and movies including all titles from the Marvel and Disney universe. So take control of your life again post the Game of Thrones gloom and sign up for the Hotstar Premium membership here.

This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of Hotstar and not by the Scroll editorial team.