Jammu and Kashmir has surpassed Kerala as the state with the highest life expectancy in India for all ages, barring life expectancy at birth, according to the latest data released on October 19 by the Registrar General of India custodian of census data.

The Registrar General of India publishes state-level life expectancy – defined as the estimate of the average number of additional years that a person of a given age can expect to live – data for different ages: 0 (at birth), 1, 5, 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60 and 70. Being the state with the highest life expectancy at birth in India, Kerala used to be the leader in almost all these age categories till 2010.

Since then, it has escaped public attention that Jammu and Kashmir has replaced Kerala as the new number one in most of these categories. More specifically, barring life expectancy at birth, the state has a higher life expectancy than Kerala for every age group included in the Registrar General of India's Sample Registration System data analysis released last week, based on surveys done between 2010 and 2014.

Source: Sample Registration System, 2016.

India’s statistical system does not produce life expectancy numbers on 15 “small states” and Union Territories, such as Goa, limiting itself to 21 “bigger” states and UTs.

Kerala still has the highest overall life expectancy at birth, at 74.9 years – 72 for men and 77.8 for women, according to the Sample Registration System. Delhi is second, with an overall life expectancy at birth of 73.2 years, 72 for men and 74.7 for women. In third position is Jammu and Kashmir, which had the second-highest life expectancy at birth – behind only Kerala – even during 2006-10. Delhi was not included in the analysis then, as it became eligible for the “bigger state” status only later.

Why you should be surprised

When I opened the Census of India webpage, which holds the abridged life tables based on the Sample Registration System for 2010-14, I was greeted with a line “Are you surprised?“ on the browser tab. At first, I thought this was a prank by an official, perhaps equally amused by the numbers as I was.

I soon realised the question was the result of a computer virus from the 1990s, called Shankar’s Virus, playing tricks with official documents. In all likelihood, the computer network within the Registrar General of India's office is one of the last places on earth where you will see Shankar’s Virus.

We often assume that more prosperous states, such as Kerala, Himachal Pradesh, Punjab, Haryana, Delhi, Tamil Nadu and Maharashtra, with relatively high human development scores, fare equally well in terms of overall health indicators, such as life expectancy or Infant Mortality Rate.

Why is Jammu and Kashmir number three in terms of overall life expectancy at birth? The answer lies in its Infant Mortality Rate, a measure of the children under one year who die for every 1,000 live births.

Kerala has an Infant Mortality Rate of 12, while Jammu and Kashmir has an Infant Mortality Rate of 34, closer to the national average of 39. If you consider the percentage distribution of deaths by age group, infant deaths (death before age 1) consisted of 11.3% of overall deaths in Jammu and Kashmir, close to the India average of 12.3%. In comparison, Kerala’s infant deaths comprise 2.6% of all deaths.

This also does not mean that children in Jammu and Kashmir are doing particularly badly. The reductions in Infant Mortality Rate as well as Under-5 Mortality Rate have been impressive over the last decade.

Source: Sample Registration System, Census of IndiaIMR: Infant Mortality Rate (Infant deaths per 1,000 live births)U5MR: Under 5 Mortality Rate (Number of children who die by the age of five, per 1,000 live births)

Within the toddler age group (1-4), Jammu and Kashmir has the lowest proportion of deaths in India – 0.1% of all deaths; Kerala has 0.4%. In particular, given the low proportion of children dying in the 1-4 age category, Jammu and Kashmir’s high Infant Mortality Rate needs to be looked at more closely through systematic studies. The soon-to-be-released National Family Health Survey-4 results for Jammu and Kashmir may address this situation.

More data needed

It may look like an anomaly, but in all Indian states with the exception of Kerala, life expectancy at birth is lower than life expectancy at age 1. In other words, a high Infant Mortality Rate drags down overall life expectancy at birth. Jammu and Kashmir is illustrative of this conundrum, as it beats Kerala in terms of life expectancy at every age category other than 0. It still ends up being third overall, behind Kerala, and even Delhi, even when women in J&K have a higher life expectancy at birth (74.9) than women in Delhi (74.7).

The uncelebrated win of Jammu and Kashmir over Kerala says two things about indicators of overall health status, such as life expectancy and Infant Mortality Rate. One, life expectancy at birth does not provide a complete picture of overall health status or mortality of a society. Second, despite being one of the most popular measures of general health status, the Infant Mortality Rate is not always a good indicator of overall health status or mortality.

Does living longer mean living healthier? This is the question which a 2014 study by the Institute for Social and Economic Change – which used mortality data given by Sample Registration System together with morbidity data given by National Sample Survey Office – tried to answer. The findings are not encouraging. The authors found that average healthy years lost due to major groups of diseases is 7.5 for men and 9.2 for women in India.

Diseases cost Kerala men 19.7 healthy years and women 24.6 healthy years, according to the study. A low Infant Mortality Rate and a high life expectancy at birth does not make Kerala a healthy society; the state is fast gaining notoriety as the diabetes and lifestyle-disease capital of India, as IndiaSpend reported in October 2014. Average healthy years lost due to major groups of diseases at birth in Jammu & Kashmir is 9.1 for men and 10.8 for women.

The Jammu and Kashmir-Kerala enigma also says something about public perceptions of human development:

  • Irrespective of strife and political commentary about life in Jammu and Kashmir, the general population there has India’s best life expectancy.
  • Despite having India’s best female life expectancy, both Delhi and Jammu and Kashmir have amongst the lowest sex ratios in the country.
  • Despite naming itself “God’s Own Country” and winning most major local human development competitions in India, Kerala may not be a very healthy place after all.

This article first appeared on IndiaSpend, a data-driven and public-interest journalism non-profit.