Higher Education

Why has the Centre put universities to which it awarded high grades on a list of under-performers?

Is the list of 11 'under-performing' universities politically motivated?

A newspaper report last week that the Union Ministry of Human Resource Development has drawn up a list of 11 so-called “under-performing” universities whose teaching and research functions will be audited has left teachers and students across campuses scratching their heads in bewilderment. According to the report in the Times of India, the 11 universities to be audited include Aligarh Muslim University, Allahabad University, Central University of Rajasthan at Kishangarh, Pondicherry University, and Babasaheb Bhimrao Ambedkar University in Lucknow.

The confusion among teachers and students is understandable. Several of the 11 universities under the scanner according to the report, have been rated quite highly by the government’s National Assessment and Accreditation Council, some as recently as 2015 and 2016. The council is an autonomous institution of the University Grants Commission – which has now been tasked with auditing the alleged non-performers.

“This makes no sense,” said Faizal Hasan, president of the Aligarh Muslim University Students’ Union. “The NAAC [National Assessment and Accreditation Council] rating is the government’s assessment and this list is the government’s too.”

Aligarh Muslim University, Central University of Rajasthan, Pondicherry University and Babasaheb Bhimrao Ambedkar University were all awarded As in the last cycle of the council’s ratings. The institutions are graded from A++ to D with A++ to C being accredited, and D being not accredited.

In 2012, the University Grants Commission made accreditation compulsory for institutions under its purview. These universities and higher education institutes were required to get accreditation certificates from the National Assessment and Accreditation Council with the final aim of linking funding to it. Grades awarded by the council are valid for five years. When this period expires, universities must apply for another round of accreditation. Of the four universities mentioned above, only Pondicherry University’s rating, awarded in 2011, has expired. Allahabad University, also on the list of 11 non-performers, was awarded a B++ in 2004. It has not been graded more recently. Others are yet to be rated.

‘Politically motivated’

The University Grants Commission had not officially informed Aligarh Muslim University that it featured in the under-performers list when this reporter contacted its spokesperson, Omar S Peerzada. But the news nevertheless has caused consternation among the university community.

Hasan said that an American agency had ranked Aligarh Muslim University higher than even Delhi University last year. “This is clearly an attempt to defame our university and students are angry and upset about it,” he said.

With little clue as to where the university has been found wanting, many in the Aligarh Muslim University community wonder if the acrimony between the university and the Union Human Resource Development ministry over the university’s minority status could be a reason. There is an ongoing court battle on the subject, and the ministry had told the Supreme Court in September that it did not support the university’s minority tag.

“What are the criteria for judging?” asked Mohammad Mohibul Haque of the Department of Political Science. “This is the first time this premier institution is being discussed for this reason. The teachers here suspect the decision to include AMU is politically motivated because it claims to be a minority institution.”

However, Aligarh Muslim University has had its share of troubles. In addition to the court case and an investigation regarding financial and administrative impropriety initiated against its vice-chancellor Zameeruddin Shah, two students were killed in campus violence last year, and the university closed for a few days. But Aftab Alam, also a political science teacher at the university, argued that none of this explained the allegation of under-performance.

Aligarh Muslim University vice-chancellor Zameeruddin Shah.
Aligarh Muslim University vice-chancellor Zameeruddin Shah.

“That isolated incident did not affect the impact of the institution,” said Alam. “There is a rush of students every year. The faculty is engaged in research and there are publications in almost all branches of knowledge. There have been substantial cuts in funds and these lists and audits could be a way of justifying that.”

‘What’s the yardstick?’

N Dastagiri Reddy of the Department of Chemistry at Pondicherry University said that he would like to know what yardstick had been used to categorise universities as “under-performing”.

“I joined 12 years ago and have seen tremendous improvement in the quality of research, number of students and the type of placements [at Pondicherry university],” he said. “It is totally unjust to include us.”

Pondicherry University has been participating in the accreditation process from the 1990s, and its ratings have improved in successive cycles.

But there was a spell of trouble at this university too. Protests by the teacher-student community against the previous vice-chancellor in 2013-’14 had even reached Delhi. More recently, there are fewer science projects coming its way and government funds are being squeezed too, said Reddy. “The functions of the university were affected in that period but the impact was not permanent,” he added.

This reporter sought a response to allegations and questions raised by teachers and students from the official responsible for central universities at the Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human Resource Development, and from the University Grants Commission. However, there was no response to text messages, phone calls or emails.

However, an official working in the ministry, who wanted to remain anonymous, confirmed that a list of under-performing universities had indeed been drawn up. “It is true that 11 institutions have been identified as non-performers,” said the official. “The UGC [University Grants Commission] will audit these and based on its reports, further course of action will be decided.”

This report will be updated if and when an official response is received.

‘Centre to blame’

Allahabad University vice-chancellor Rattan Lal Hangloo said that he had not been officially informed about the audit but was told informally that it was in the offing. Though academics outside of that university are puzzled by its inclusion in the under-performers list, Hangloo thinks its inclusion is justified.

“The university is at its lowest ebb right now,” he said.

Hangloo recalled the state of Allahabad University when he joined in 2015: “Financial irregularities… crowding because after [the introduction of the 27% Other Backward Classes quota in 2007] there are over 160 students in some classes…and staff shortage because there has been no recruitment in 30 years.”

He is of the view that the university, which has two institutes and 11 affiliated colleges, needs help, and urgently.

But Hangloo said that the Central government was responsible for letting things slide this far. “Ultimately, accountability rests with the government,” he said. “People complained to the ministry but no one bothered. At the same time, there is interference in matters of recruitment and disciplinary action.”

Hangloo had famously threatened to resign in 2016, alleging interference by the Union Human Resource Development ministry.

‘Part of a plan’

Abha Dev Habib, former executive council member of Delhi University, agreed with Hangloo that the government, now sitting in judgment, first “allowed the rot to set in”. She also echoed Hangloo in saying that the government was answerable first.

“In a public institution, the government is ultimately responsible for infrastructure, appointment of staff, promotions and quality,” she said. “Instead, there is complete inaction in case of misgovernance.”

Delhi University is not on the list of 11 under-performers, but the list has worried its academics too. “What are the implications for these institutions?” asked Habib. “Does the government have a plan for fixing them? If it does, it must make these 11 its priority.” But teachers fear that may not be the final goal.

Habib pointed out that the committee to develop a new education policy headed by former cabinet secretary TSR Subramanian had recommended that the government “weed out institutions that fall below an accepted benchmark of performance”.

“Many of the policies recommended by the committee are being implemented even though the policy has not been finalised,” said Habib. She fears that the ground is being prepared for “weeding out struggling institutions or handing [them] over to the private sector like primary schools in some states were”.

We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content  BY 

Modern home design trends that are radically changing living spaces in India

From structure to finishes, modern homes embody lifestyle.

Homes in India are evolving to become works of art as home owners look to express their taste and lifestyle through design. It’s no surprise that global home design platform Houzz saw over a million visitors every month from India, even before their services were locally available. Architects and homeowners are spending enormous time and effort over structural elements as well as interior features, to create beautiful and comfortable living spaces.

Here’s a look at the top trends that are altering and enhancing home spaces in India.

Cantilevers. A cantilever is a rigid structural element like a beam or slab that protrudes horizontally out of the main structure of a building. The cantilevered structure almost seems to float on air. While small balconies of such type have existed for eons, construction technology has now enabled large cantilevers, that can even become large rooms. A cantilever allows for glass facades on multiple sides, bringing in more sunlight and garden views. It works wonderfully to enhance spectacular views especially in hill or seaside homes. The space below the cantilever can be transformed to a semi-covered garden, porch or a sit-out deck. Cantilevers also help conserve ground space, for lawns or backyards, while enabling more built-up area. Cantilevers need to be designed and constructed carefully else the structure could be unstable and lead to floor vibrations.

Butterfly roofs. Roofs don’t need to be flat - in fact roof design can completely alter the size and feel of the space inside. A butterfly roof is a dramatic roof arrangement shaped, as the name suggests, like a butterfly. It is an inverted version of the typical sloping roof - two roof surfaces slope downwards from opposing edges to join around the middle in the shape of a mild V. This creates more height inside the house and allows for high windows which let in more light. On the inside, the sloping ceiling can be covered in wood, aluminium or metal to make it look stylish. The butterfly roof is less common and is sure to add uniqueness to your home. Leading Indian architecture firms, Sameep Padora’s sP+a and Khosla Associates, have used this style to craft some stunning homes and commercial projects. The Butterfly roof was first used by Le Corbusier, the Swiss-French architect who later designed the city of Chandigarh, in his design of the Maison Errazuriz, a vacation house in Chile in 1930.

Butterfly roof and cantilever (Image credit: Design Milk on Flickr.com)
Butterfly roof and cantilever (Image credit: Design Milk on Flickr.com)

Skylights. Designing a home to allow natural light in is always preferred. However, spaces, surrounding environment and privacy issues don’t always allow for large enough windows. Skylights are essentially windows in the roof, though they can take a variety of forms. A well-positioned skylight can fill a room with natural light and make a huge difference to small rooms as well as large living areas. However, skylights must be intelligently designed to suit the climate and the room. Skylights facing north, if on a sloping roof, will bring in soft light, while a skylight on a flat roof will bring in sharp glare in the afternoons. In the Indian climate, a skylight will definitely reduce the need for artificial lighting but could also increase the need for air-conditioning during the warm months. Apart from this cleaning a skylight requires some effort. Nevertheless, a skylight is a very stylish addition to a home, and one that has huge practical value.

Staircases. Staircases are no longer just functional. In modern houses, staircases are being designed as aesthetic elements in themselves, sometimes even taking the centre-stage. While the form and material depend significantly on practical considerations, there are several trendy options. Floating staircases are hugely popular in modern, minimalist homes and add lightness to a normally heavy structure. Materials like glass, wood, metal and even coloured acrylic are being used in staircases. Additionally, spaces under staircases are being creatively used for storage or home accents.

Floating staircase (Image credit: Design Milk on Flickr.com)
Floating staircase (Image credit: Design Milk on Flickr.com)

Exposed Brick Walls. Brickwork is traditionally covered with plaster and painted. However, ‘exposed’ bricks, that is un-plastered masonry, is becoming popular in homes, restaurants and cafes. It adds a rustic and earthy feel. Exposed brick surfaces can be used in home interiors, on select walls or throughout, as well as exteriors. Exposed bricks need to be treated to be moisture proof. They are also prone to gathering dust and mould, making regular cleaning a must.

Cement work. Don’t underestimate cement and concrete when it comes to design potential. Exposed concrete interiors, like exposed brick, are becoming very popular. The design philosophy is ‘Less is more’ - the structure is simplistic and pops of colour are added through furniture and soft furnishings.

Exposed concrete wall (Image Credit: Getty Images)
Exposed concrete wall (Image Credit: Getty Images)

When building your home, it is important to use strong and durable materials. A value-added premium product with high compressive strength, Birla Gold cement is used to make tough, impermeable concrete that sets quickly, lasts long and minimises cracking. Its durability will ensure that your dream home always looks new and the steel structure inside remains protected. Birla Gold offers variants that are optimised for different needs. The unique hydraulic binding properties of the Birla Gold Premium cement variant prevent seepage, making it resistant to even corrosive water, especially important for houses in coastal cities. The Birla Gold Royal cement variant provides very high strength and is perfect for the foundation. As the video below says, with the different varieties of cement that Birla Gold offers, you can build the home of your dreams.


This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of Birla Gold Premium Cement and not by the Scroll editorial team.