Manmohan Singh’s family say they objected to being photographed during health minister’s AIIMS visit
The former prime minister’s daughter said that her mother’s objections to a photographer being present in the hospital room were ignored.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/18438/18438bc8ee5dbc3eec9321c0bfea8d3cf1f6cb53" alt="Manmohan Singh’s family say they objected to being photographed during health minister’s AIIMS visit"
The family of former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on Friday said they had objected to a photographer being present when Union Health Minister Mansukh Mandaviya visited him at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences in Delhi, The Hindu reported.
In a statement, Singh’s daughter Daman Singh said that her mother’s objections were ignored when Mandaviya called upon the former prime minister on Thursday. Daman Singh said that her mother was “very upset” about the matter.
Singh was admitted to the cardio-neuro section of the hospital in Delhi on Wednesday evening after he complained of fever and weakness. After meeting him on Thursday, Mandaviya reportedly posted a few photos with Singh on his Twitter handle. However, he removed them after facing criticism on social media, The Hindu reported.
In her statement on Friday, Daman Singh said the family had restricted visitors due to risk of infection. In April, the 89-year-old was hospitalised after he tested positive for the coronavirus disease.
“My father is being treated for dengue at AIIMS,” Daman Singh said. “His condition is stable but his immunity is low. It was nice of the health minister to visit and express his concern. However, my parents were in no state to be photographed at the time.”
The Congress leader’s daughter also told The Print that her parents are “not animals in a zoo” to be photographed in such a situation.
Earlier, several social media users and Congress leaders had pointed out that Singh was not in a state to be photographed and that the health minister had violated his right to privacy.
It’s a serious breach of privacy, why Union Health Minister @mansukhmandviya walk with cameras in to the Hosipital and publish it ? When former PM Vajpayee was in hospital whether we got pictures from AIIMS? It’s crime @crpfindia must answer ? AIIMS must answer? #ManmohanSinghji pic.twitter.com/7uMiBFfFah
— Manickam Tagore .B🇮🇳✋மாணிக்கம் தாகூர்.ப (@manickamtagore) October 15, 2021
I know you all are concerned about the health of former PM Manmohan Singh but kindly do stop sharing photos of him from his hospital bed. It's invasion of his & his family's privacy & not good conduct in any way.
— Abhishek Singhvi (@DrAMSinghvi) October 15, 2021
It’s shameful that #AIIMS admin has allowed what’s medically unethical- giving permission to a random photographer to take pictures of former Prime Minister #Manmohansingh while he is getting treated in the hospital. Would the health minister be treated the same way? Stop it!!
— sanjay kapoor (@sanjaykpr) October 14, 2021
Wishing former PM Dr. Manmohan Singh a speedy recovery. Appalled that the Health Minister would take a photographer in to his hospital room without care for infections, apart from the violation of a patient's privacy.
— Suhasini Haidar (@suhasinih) October 15, 2021
Had no idea that this stunt was pulled off by Health minister Manush Mandaviya who brought in a photographer into Manmohan Singh's AIIMS hospital room. When it comes to this govt and party, be it prime minister or senior leaders or cadre, there are just no depths too low. https://t.co/vLXspSgh5R
— Sofia | சோபியா (@Red_Pastures) October 15, 2021
Delhi: Union Health Minister Mansukh Mandaviya arrives to meet former Prime Minister & Congress leader Dr Manmohan Singh at All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Delhi
— ANI (@ANI) October 14, 2021
Singh was admitted to AIIMS Delhi, yesterday pic.twitter.com/cjVhJvMQm4