Paying the price

Will the drug pricing authority regulate the price of knee implants?

After capping the prices of cardiac stents, the drug authority turns its attention to knee implants, even though they aren’t on the essential medicines list.

The National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority has released data that shows the average trade margin on orthopaedic knee implants is 313%. In a statement on August 4, the drug price regulatory body said the data has been sourced from the manufacturers and importers of these medical devices.

The minimum cost of a knee implant for the patient, as per the data, is Rs 59,091 and the maximum is Rs 413,059. The average trade margin includes the margins of importers and distributors. The highest margins were taken by the distributors and hospitals that perform knee replacement surgeries, according to the analysis.

Landed cost is the cost at the time of manufacture or import.
Landed cost is the cost at the time of manufacture or import.

The data release comes five months after the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority capped the price of cardiac stents at Rs 29,600. A similar price analysis was done before the price of stents was regulated. This has sparked speculation that the prices of knee implants could come under price regulation soon. In its statement, the drug pricing authority said it was releasing the data “to bring in transparency”. Its tweet said the government and the authority are “committed to transparency and affordable healthcare”.

Bhupendra Singh, the chairman of the authority, however, refused to comment on the question of price regulation.

As per the process laid down in the Drug Price Control Order, the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority can regulate the price of a drug or device only after it has been included in the National List of Essential Medicines. Even after the inclusion, the Department of Pharmaceuticals needs to issue an order asking the authority to regulate the price.

In case of coronary stents, the authority had analysed the prices of stents after the Department of Pharmaceuticals had issued an order in December. However, in case of knee implants, the price has been analysed before any order has been issued.

Some members of the Indian Orthopedic Association, an association of orthopedic surgeons which was represented in the authority’s meeting last month, welcomed price control as beneficial for patients. Others cautioned against it. Industry representatives said price regulation would adversely affect the availability of knee implants, the bulk of which are imported.

A four-part system

Knee replacement surgery is a procedure in which an artificial joint or prosthesis replaces the damaged knee joint. The most common reason for knee damage that requires replacement is osteoarthritis (wearing of knee joints) or the rheumatoid arthritis (an autoimmune disease that attacks joint cells).

Four parts are used in the knee replacement system - femoral, tibial plate, insert and patella. Orthopedic surgeons said that usually the entire set, consisting of these four parts, is required for the surgery. The data released by NPPA showed the prices and trade margins for each of the four parts. Altogether, the maximum price came to Rs 4,13,059.

Many doctors expressed surprise at the prices. “The maximum cost of more than Rs four lakhs is unacceptable,” said Dr Pradeep Bhonsale, joint replacement surgeon at Nanavati Hospital, Mumbai.

But the members of Indian Orthopedic Association were split on the question of price control of knee implants. “If the price goes down, the volume of surgeries will go up,” said Dr Ram Prabhoo, president of the association. Prabhoo explained that many people eligible to go through the surgery do not opt for the surgery because implants are expensive.

But Dr HS Chhabra, a member of the Indian Orthopedic Association, took a more cautious view. “We are all for the benefit of the patients but there are a number of factors determining pricing,” he said.

The current practice, he explained, involves the distributor getting an inventory of various sizes of the knee implants before the surgery, of which one is chosen for the patient. The size of the knee implant is not determined before the surgery, but during the surgery. The maintaining of the inventory and transporting it from surgeon to surgeon increases cost, he said. The distributor also provided instruments that are essential for the surgery.

“These costs should also be taken into consideration,” said Chhabra, who also represents the Association of Healthcare Providers of India. “There are other factors such as design, innovation, finish, quality that need to be considered.”

Industry concerns

The Indian orthopaedic devices market is worth Rs 2,400 crore, according to a 2016 report prepared by consulting firm Sathguru Management Consultants. Knee implants account for nearly half the market and 80% of knee implants are imported. Rajiv Chhabra, who handles the orthopedic implant division of Association of Indian Medical Device Industry, said that there are only four companies in India which manufacture knee implants.

Probir Das, chairman of the Medical Devices Forum of the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce, said price caps could bring down the profitability of the industry and reduce further investments.

But Himanshu Baid of the Medical Devices Division of the Confederation of Indian Industry said that price control will not have a major impact on the industry, but more on the hospitals. “The distributors at most take 15-20 percent margin,” he said. “The biggest impact will be on the hospital. They take the biggest margin.”

The NPPA’s reporting format sought information on the price at which distributors supplied knee implants to hospitals, as well as the price at which hospitals made the implants available to patients. But the final statement does not spell out the difference in the margins of distributors and hospitals. When the NPPA analysed the prices of cardiac stents, it was found that the hospitals had the highest margin.

The regulatory build-up

A few years ago, the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority sought the help of National Health Systems Resource Centre to study the clinical effectiveness of hip and knee implants. The Centre provides technical assistance to the health ministry. In its 2015 report, the technical body also suggested that the “valid” cost of the knee implant should not exceed Rs 97,000.

In 2011, the Maharashtra Food and Drug Administration conducted an investigation on the pricing of various medical devices including orthopedic implants and concluded that the margins were unacceptably high. The state body wrote to the Central Drug Standard Control Organisation asking for a cap on the profits of implant manufacturers and distributors.

The Central Drug Standard Control Organisation recently last month asked the Health ministry to consider the inclusion of heart valves, orthopaedic implants and eye lenses in the National List of Essential Medicines, a report in The Indian Express said.

On May 12, the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority sought information relating to the prices of 19 medical devices, including knee implants, to “monitor the price”. Some companies did not submit the data by the deadline of May 31. The authority issued a warning that they would inspect the premises of these companies to get the data. The companies then submitted the data.

Government powers

Malini Aisola of the All India Drug Action Network, which works towards increasing access to essential medicines, said: “The official data shows what was already known about the excessive margins and price gouging in medical devices.”

Aisola pointed out that the government could regulate the price of knee implants even before they are included in the National List of Essential Medicines. Paragraph 19 of the Drug Price Control Order gives the government the power to fix a ceiling price of any drug in such extraordinary circumstances and in case of public interest “as it deems fit”.

This clause was used to fix the price of cardiac stents too. The National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority said that the formula prescribed under the Drug Price Control Order – based on average price of the stents to the retailer – was resulting in unethical mark-ups and exorbitant prices.

Like it did in the case of cardiac stents, the authority should make use of Paragraph 19 to regulate the prices of knee implants in a systematic manner, said Aisola. She insisted that the NPPA should publish the data related to other devices and regulate their prices using the public interest provisions.

But industry representatives said the use of Paragraph 19 would be arbitrary. “It would be unfortunate,” said Das. “There would be no scientific evaluation of the product before capping the price.”

We welcome your comments at
Sponsored Content BY 

When did we start parenting our parents?

As our parents grow older, our ‘adulting’ skills are tested like never before.

From answering every homework question to killing every monster under the bed, from soothing every wound with care to crushing anxiety by just the sound of their voice - parents understandably seemed like invincible, know-it-all superheroes all our childhood. It’s no wonder then that reality hits all of a sudden, the first time a parent falls and suffers a slip disc, or wears a thick pair of spectacles to read a restaurant menu - our parents are growing old, and older. It’s a slow process as our parents turn from superheroes to...human.

And just as slow to evolve are the dynamics of our relationship with them. Once upon a time, a peck on the cheek was a frequent ritual. As were handmade birthday cards every year from the artistically inclined, or declaring parents as ‘My Hero’ in school essays. Every parent-child duo could boast of an affectionate ritual - movie nights, cooking Sundays, reading favourite books together etc. The changed dynamic is indeed the most visible in the way we express our affection.

The affection is now expressed in more mature, more subtle ways - ways that mimics that of our own parents’ a lot. When did we start parenting our parents? Was it the first time we offered to foot the electricity bill, or drove them to the doctor, or dragged them along on a much-needed morning walk? Little did we know those innocent acts were but a start of a gradual role reversal.

In adulthood, children’s affection for their parents takes on a sense of responsibility. It includes everything from teaching them how to use smartphones effectively and contributing to family finances to tracking doctor’s appointments and ensuring medicine compliance. Worry and concern, though evidence of love, tend to largely replace old-fashioned patterns of affection between parents and children as the latter grow up.

It’s something that can be easily rectified, though. Start at the simplest - the old-fashioned peck on the cheek. When was the last time you gave your mom or dad a peck on the cheek like a spontaneous five-year-old - for no reason at all? Young parents can take their own children’s behaviour available as inspiration.

As young parents come to understand the responsibilities associated with caring for their parents, they also come to realise that they wouldn’t want their children to go through the same challenges. Creating a safe and secure environment for your family can help you strike a balance between the loving child in you and the caring, responsible adult that you are. A good life insurance plan can help families deal with unforeseen health crises by providing protection against financial loss. Having assurance of a measure of financial security for family can help ease financial tensions considerably, leaving you to focus on being a caring, affectionate child. Moreover,you can eliminate some of the worry for your children when they grow up – as the video below shows.


To learn more about life insurance plans available for your family, see here.

This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of SBI Life and not by the Scroll editorial team.