Protests or peace in Srinagar? Videos from the BBC and from Prasar Bharti show conflicting footage
Contrary to the government’s videos, BBC footage shows massive protests, bordering on violence, after evening prayers on Friday in Soura, Srinagar.
शुक्रवार को नमाज़ के बाद कश्मीर के सौरा में बड़ी संख्या में प्रदर्शनकारी सड़कों पर उतरे और सुरक्षाबलों से उनकी झड़प भी हुई. हालाँकि भारत सरकार किसी भी बड़े प्रदर्शन से इनकार कर रही है. देखिए BBC की EXCLUSIVE फ़ुटेज. #Kashmir #KashmirProtest #Article370 #BBCExclusive #Srinagar pic.twitter.com/oUu9mTkHIp
— BBC News Hindi (@BBCHindi) August 10, 2019
Exclusive footage from the BBC showing scenes of protest, bordering on violence, in Jammu and Kashmir’s Srinagar has come in direct contradiction to the Central government’s claims that all is well in there.
Curfew was relaxed after five days on Friday in the lead up to Eid. While Reuters reported, “Indian police used tear gas and pellets to fight back at least 10,000 people protesting Delhi’s withdrawal of special rights for Muslim-majority Jammu and Kashmir state in its main city of Srinagar on Friday, a police official and two witnesses said.”
However, the government has insisted – tweeting a rejoinder at noon on Saturday, August 10 – that only small squabbles took place, with less than twenty people involved in each.
A news report originally published in Reuters and appeared in Dawn claims there was a protest involving 10000 people in Srinagar.
— Spokesperson, Ministry of Home Affairs (@PIBHomeAffairs) August 10, 2019
This is completely fabricated & incorrect. There have been a few stray protests in Srinagar/Baramulla and none involved a crowd of more than 20 ppl.
Now, the BBC has released exclusive footage of what it claims were Friday’s protests in Soura, Srinagar. BBC’s footage shows a gathering of hundreds of protesters on the streets and at a meeting. According to BBC correspondent Amir Pirzada, the initially peaceful protest turned violent after clashes with security forces. Going by the video, tear gas, pellets and live rounds were also fired.
शुक्रवार को श्रीनगर के सौरा में अनुच्छेद 370 को कमजोर करने के ख़िलाफ़ कश्मीरियों ने किया प्रदर्शन, भीड़ को तितर-बितर करने के लिए सुरक्षाबलों ने किया बल प्रयोग, भारत सरकार कर रही है किसी भी बड़े प्रदर्शन से इनकार, देखिए BBC की EXCLUSIVE फ़ुटेज.#Srinagar #Article370 #Kashmir pic.twitter.com/Y69mRDqrW6
— BBC News Hindi (@BBCHindi) August 10, 2019
State-run media channels as well as news agency ANI have released rounds of videos attempting to bolster the claim of uniform peace. Prasar Bharti and DD News released footage showing prayers, people lining up to use ATMs, and scenes of everyday activity.
People offering Friday prayers at a mosque in Srinagar yesterday. pic.twitter.com/1Y7uqXPd8u
— Prasar Bharati News Services (@PBNS_India) August 10, 2019
Situation remains calm and peaceful across Jammu & Kashmir...Read More: https://t.co/Rf3JAycH6S pic.twitter.com/QadOymfwUE
— Doordarshan News (@DDNewsLive) August 10, 2019
Dismissing the news of protests as fake, Prasar Bharti tweeted, “It’s business as usual in Srinagar.” Urdu and English dailies had resumed publication, it added.
Contrary to some fake news reports, it's business as usual in Srinagar. pic.twitter.com/IAsRIRwNcG
— Prasar Bharati News Services (@PBNS_India) August 10, 2019
Reports of newspapers not being published in Kashmir are wrong. English dailies like Greater Kashmir, Rising Kashmir, Kashmir Images and 4 Urdu dailies are being published from Kashmir. pic.twitter.com/IQRkZC3pja
— Prasar Bharati News Services (@PBNS_India) August 10, 2019
ANI, meanwhile, posted a video of tranquil scenes from Srinagar.
#WATCH SRINAGAR: Latest visuals from near Dal Lake in the city. #JammuandKashmir pic.twitter.com/O2tAYkciMa
— ANI (@ANI) August 10, 2019
BBC’s Pirzada said the situation remained tense in Srinagar. The BBC said its team attempted to visit Soura on Saturday morning but found the roads blocked – some by angry demonstrators, and others by Central Reserve Police Force Personnel. According to local media, five people were injured in Friday’s clashes, but the BBC could not confirm this information with authorities.
“Kashmir is under siege at the moment,” a lawyer living in Pulwama told the BBC. “The moment it’s lifted, trouble will start. Once the political and separatist leaders are freed from detention or house arrest, there will be calls for protests and people will come out.”