A wave of outrage spread through Twitter on Sunday as cricket fans responded to the news that popular Indian cricket commentator Harsha Bhogle would not be commentating on the ongoing season of the Indian Premier League. The Board of Control for Cricket in India terminated its commentary contract with Bhogle without providing an explanation. The veteran commentator confirmed the development on Saturday.
Would have been nice to be part of @IPL again. Was in fact looking forward to it. Favourite tournament. Hope #IPL9 is a blockbuster.
— Harsha Bhogle (@bhogleharsha) April 9, 2016
The news of Bhogle's ouster followed reports of the BCCI contemplating ending its commentary association with former great Sunil Gavaskar as well, supposedly over reports of him being too expensive and "out of line".
That the Indian cricket body employed former players like Ravi Shastri and Sunil Gavaskar as commentators on its payroll was seen with suspicion by most fans. Many questioned whether the BCCI was trying to control what cricket commentators could say on air. Even the Justice Lodha panel, constituted by the Supreme Court to clean up Indian cricket, came down heavily on the BCCI, slamming the lack of objective commentary.
Bhogle, however, is one of the few Indian voices in cricket that enjoys near universal acclaim and is recognised as one of the world's leading commentators. Consequently, the news that the BCCI did not want to utilise his service for their biggest tournament, angered many. In the Indian Express, anonymous board officials claimed the decision was taken after receiving inputs from social media and players.
Other officials pointed to a recent heated exchange Bhogle had with a Vidarbha Cricket Association official during a game in Nagpur. Bhogle, for his part, clarified that that the exchange was due to the bilingual commentators having to rush around and climb flights of stairs after completing every stint due to the door of the VIP box being shut. He then added, "Even if it was the Nagpur incident, no one heard my part of the story."
Cricket fans on Twitter were an angry lot.
Commentary Without Harsha Bhogle Is Like Team India Without Virat Kohli. #BringBackHarsha #IPL
— Sir Ravindra Jadeja (@SirJadeja) April 10, 2016
I was a nervous wreck while hosting IPL3, it was @bhogleharsha who dragged me to the commentary box to observe &learn. Miss u on the mic sir
— Ayushmann Khurrana (@ayushmannk) April 10, 2016
Entirely agree with you. @bhogleharsha is simply top class & is definitely our finest cricket commentator. https://t.co/1UgH8Bsip7
— Amitabh Kant (@amitabhk87) April 10, 2016
Harsha Bhogle must be feeling like that police officer, who got suspended because he did his duty honestly.
— Sunil- The Cricketer (@1sInto2s) April 10, 2016
IPL should get back Harsha Bhogle into the commentary box & drop Sidhu instead.
— Ramesh Srivats (@rameshsrivats) April 10, 2016
Value will go up, and more importantly, volume will go down.
Last month, Indian cinema legend Amitabh Bachchan criticised Indian commentators for not talking more about Indian players after India won a close encounter against Bangladesh at the World Twenty20 tournament. It was widely speculated that he was specifically referring to Bhogle.
T 2184 - With all due respects, it would be really worthy of an Indian commentator to speak more about our players than others all the time.
— Amitabh Bachchan (@SrBachchan) March 23, 2016
Indian captain Mahendra Singh Dhoni seemed to suggest that he agreed with Bachchan's tweet after he retweeted it with the following observation:
Nothing to add https://t.co/8rBel3vw4o
— Mahendra Singh Dhoni (@msdhoni) March 23, 2016
Both of them also came in for criticism from the Indian Twitterati who assumed that it was Bachchan's missive that had led to Bhogle's ouster from the IPL.
Poor Harsha Bhogle is paying d price 4 being a moderate voice of sanity in d age of tri-colour waving pseudo-patriots lyk Amitabh Bachchan.
— Fekendra Modi (@FekuModi) April 10, 2016
Amitabh Bachchan evaded tax & no body batted an eye.
— Rā's al Ghūl (@TodgyF) April 10, 2016
Sly tweets about Harsha Bhogle and Harsha loses his livelihood.
Wah re Bharat Mata.
Dropping a commentator on technical grounds is BCCI's prerogative. Dropping him on someone's whimsical recommendation is malicious.
— Roflindian Angel (@Roflindian) April 10, 2016
Whether it is Big B or MSD's tweet.
— Sorabh Pant (@hankypanty) April 10, 2016
Or, some officious official.
Harsha Bhogle is an ace commentator and a good man.
His ouster is pure EGO.
On Monday, Bhogle responded to the issue with an emotional post on Facebook, thanking those who had stood by him but reiterating that he remained the "teller of the story, not the story itself."