Letters to the editor

Readers’ comments: If demands for azadi in Kashmir are free speech, so are demands for Hindu Rashtra

A selection of readers’ opinions.

Hindu Rashtra demand

This meeting was not a one-off. It reflects the underlying programme of the RSS (“‘Establish a Hindu Rashtra by 2023’: What 132 Right-Wing Hindu organisations demanded in Goa”). This will certainly create a dichotomy between what the government projects and what the RSS and those who demand a Hindu Rashtra say. How Modi solves this problem will determine the future of this government? – SN Iyer


We are marching towards authoritarian fanaticism. – Paramjit S Basi


A more appropriate headline for this piece would have been: RSS stays away from the All-India Hindu Convention”. But then it wouldn’t fit Scroll.in’s narrative, would it?

About 132 Hindu groups gathered at this meet, of which I’m sure only a handful are even known. By no stretch of imagination can claim to speak for a majority of the Hindu community. Also, if sloganeering by leftists in JNU and other institutions demanding azadi for Kashmir and Bastar is justified in the name of freedom of expression, so should the various so-called demands made at the meet? – P Raghavendra

Forgotten poet

I am very touched by the plight of Asrar Jamayee (“An 80-year-old Urdu poet declared dead by the Delhi government is struggling to survive”). Not only has a great injustice been done to him, his situation is demeaning to all poets and writers. Could we help him to get his pension, and start a small fund to assist him and other artists? – Sujatha Mathai


It is sad to hear about the fate of poet Asrar Jamayee and the government’s indifference. The videos show his spirit. How can he be helped? – Hena Hassan


The government must help this poet, who believed in the system. Declaring a person dead and depriving him of his rights is the worst possible way to treat any citizen and even more so an eminent poet. The government should recompense him for his losses and pay him each and every penny due to him for all this years. – Aashish


It is truly heartbreaking how our artists have to struggle and suffer and I would love to help Asrar Jamayee in any way possible. –Tarannum

Caste clout

It is the prime duty of the state government to maintain harmony (“Dalits in this Kerala village are refusing to bury the dead of upper caste Hindus”). A new society should be developed uner the banner of Dr Ambedkar, one where all social and economic needs are served within the society. The caste system is deep-rooted in Indian society. The only solution to it is to claim our Constitutional rights in a democratic way through adequate government representation of Dalits. – Bipin Gajbhiye

Beef politics

The person who made such a hate speech should be hanged first (“Hang those who eat beef, preacher Sadhvi Saraswati urges Narendra Modi government”). What she said goes against our Constitution as it is against the spirit of secularism. Sadhvi Saraswati is against the North East because all of us here depend on cows. She should first keep in mind that the North East was never a part of India originally, so how will the BJP make us follow the Hindutva ideology here? Are we all Hindu? We are not Indians to follow the Hindutva ideology. – Nehemiah Urailang Narzary

Peace appeal

I am sorry to see so much hatred for the BJP. It’s only because of organisations like that and the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh that we can continue to exist as Hindus (“Why Gandhi’s favourite bhajan ‘Vaishnav Jan To’ is so important in Modi’s hate-filled India”). Please understand that this is not an anti-other religions but a pro-Hindu way of life. You must be very narrow-minded to blame the BJP or the RSS for every incident caused by the fringe elements. A better understanding of the RSS’s philosophy is required. – Dilip Badami


This was a very well-written piece. Narsinh Mehta’s composition represents the essence of the syncretic and inclusive bhakti tradition, which started in the deep South of this sub-continent in the 6th and 7th century CE, with the Alwars and Nayanmars who wrote in Tamil, and swept through the rest of the country through the Dasara Padas of the Dasa tradition, the Abhangs of Sant Gyaneswar and Sant Tukaram, Mehta’s song, the dohas of Kabir and Rahim, the poems of Surdas and Tulsidas, and the songs of Namdev and Ramananda.

Mahatma Gandhi took this one step further. He was perhaps the first true Indian transcendentalist, whose religion went beyond the boundaries of this sub continent. He spoke of a dharma that transcended all religions and incorporated elements of various religions in his daily morning prayers. It is no coincidence that Vaishnav Jan To was his favourite. He had often gone on record to say that the upliftment of lower castes was of far greater importance to him than independence from the British.

Since TM Krishna is heir to the Vaishnava tradition of the South (not merely by birth but because of his convictions) it was apt that he chose to sing this composition as his concluding piece. It was perhaps also apt that he started the composition in what is quintessentially a Carnatic raga - Suruti before segueing through other ragas to arrive at the Khamaj, the original raga in which Vaishnav Jan To is set. By doing this, was TM Krishna trying to trace the history of the Bhakti movement and thereby communicate an alternative an inclusive view of religion that Gandhi had propounded, and which leaders of the present ruling dispensation will never understand? – S Bhashyam

Animal cruelty

This cruelty against animals has got to stop (“This video of a lactating elephant forced to haul logs in Assam sparks outrage, and an investigation”). The poor elephant was suffering and yet pulling that log. The explanation about not being able to get any vehicle into the forest is ridiculous. They use the elephants because it’s cheap labour and do not care about how much the animal has to suffer. Something must be done to stop this cruelty. – June Carmichael

Big battle

It’s not that the present Pakistan team played an outstanding game (“Why Indian cricket supporters must remember to applaud Pakistan in the final”). We appreciate their spirit to fight and come from behind. However, their victory against England was aided by the fact that the opposing team dropped two simple catches. Anyway, cricket is a game of uncertainty. Bravo to the Pakistan team if they play an honest game.But the odds are in favour of India. – Madhu

Media watch

Strings are being pulled from all directions to strangle the media on the name of nationalism and patriotism (“45 years of Watergate: Why the journalism of the Washington Post-NYT holds lessons for today’s media”). – Paramjit S Basi

Ramdev’s remarks

Ramdev has just echoed what was in many of our hearts (“Ramdev faces arrest for threatening to behead those who refuse to say ‘Bharat mata ki jai’”). The arrest warrant should be nullified. There is no question of breach of peace. India is a secular country and people from different religions and castes are staying here with proper documentation. Those who are anti-India who criticise the country and refuse to say “Bharat mata ki jai” should be beheaded by law – this has nothing to do with religion. – Tuhin Das

Pushing Aadhaar

The Aadhaar programme is meant for those who are getting subsidised LPG, ration and provisions from fare price shops (“If Supreme Court made PAN-Aadhaar partly optional, how can a bank-Aadhaar link be mandatory?”). If the government wants to make it mandatory for other things, it should be passed by both houses of Parliament. Enforcing systems through executive orders, bypassing the Parliament, is undemocratic. – BSN

Autism awareness

You are an amazing mother, Tulika, and my heart fills with positivity when I read your articles (“How to navigate a children’s party when your child has autism”). I too faced similar problems at parties till about six months ago, and would like to share what helped my son. Apart from the things this artilce mentioned, we also made visualised the event for our son, by drawing a picture of the party. That to give him a visual image of what to expect over the next few hours. We would draw children, cake, balloons, lots of mothers and fathers, birthday presents and the like. We found that this drastically changed his response towards parties as he was more prepared and less stressed out.

Also, we always tried to get to the parties early, when there were just a few people so that my son is not overloaded with sensory or auditory stimuli. And as the crowd would built up, he would slowly get adapted to it with some help from us. – Meenakshi Pawar

We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BY 

Bringing the glamour back to flying while keeping it affordable

The pleasure of air travel is back, courtesy of an airline in India.

Before dinner, fashionable women would retire to the powder room and suited-up men would indulge in hors d’oeuvres, surrounded by plush upholstery. A gourmet meal would soon follow, served in fine tableware. Flying, back in the day, was like an upscale party 35,000 feet up in the air.

The glamour of flying has been chronicled in Keith Lovegrove’s book titled ‘Airline: Style at 30,000 feet’. In his book, Lovegrove talks about how the mid-50s and 60s were a “fabulously glamorous time to fly in commercial airlines”. Back then, flying was reserved for the privileged and the luxuries played an important role in making travelling by air an exclusive experience.

Fast forward to the present day, where flying has become just another mode of transportation. In Mumbai, every 65 seconds an aircraft lands or takes off at the airport. The condition of today’s air travel is a cumulative result of the growth in the volume of fliers, the accessibility of buying an air ticket and the number of airlines in the industry/market.

Having relegated the romance of flying to the past, air travel today is close to hectic and borderline chaotic thanks to busy airports, packed flights with no leg room and unsatisfactory meals. With the skies dominated by frequent fliers and the experience having turned merely transactional and mundane, is it time to bid goodbye to whatever’s enjoyable in air travel?

With increased resources and better technology, one airline is proving that flying in today’s scenario can be a refreshing, enjoyable and affordable experience at the same time. Vistara offers India’s first and only experience of a three-cabin configuration. At a nominal premium, Vistara’s Premium Economy is also redefining the experience of flying with a host of features such as an exclusive cabin, 20% extra legroom, 4.5-inch recline, dedicated check-in counter and baggage delivery on priority. The best in class inflight dining offers a range of regional dishes, while also incorporating global culinary trends. Other industry-first features include Starbucks coffee on board and special assistance to solo women travellers, including preferred seating.

Vistara’s attempts to reduce the gap between affordability and luxury can also be experienced in the economy class with an above average seat pitch, complimentary selection of food and beverages and a choice of leading newspapers and publications along with an inflight magazine. Hospitality aboard Vistara is, moreover, reminiscent of Singapore Airlines’ famed service with a seal of Tata’s trust, thanks to its cabin crew trained to similarly high standards.

The era of style aboard a ‘flying boat’ seems long gone. However, airlines like Vistara are bringing back the allure of air travel. Continuing their campaign with Deepika Padukone as brand ambassador, the new video delivers a bolder and a more confident version of the same message - making flying feel new again. Watch the new Vistara video below. For your next trip, rekindle the joy of flying and book your tickets here.


This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of Vistara and not by the Scroll editorial team.