Australia captain Tim Paine started a debate on social media when he said that England’s Jos Buttler is the best white-ball wicketkeeper batsman in the world, ahead of even MS Dhoni.
Paine was referring to the Buttler’s superb 110 not out that sealed a thrilling one-wicket win and completed their first 5-0 series sweep of Australia in any format. Set just 206 to win, England slumped to 195/9, but Buttler took the team home in the dying moments, in a manner reminiscent to ‘Captain Cool’ Dhoni in chases.
“He’s good, he’s very good,” Paine, a keeper-batsman himself, said of Buttler. “Right now, at the moment, he’d have to be the best white-ball wicket-keeper batsman in the world. I don’t think there’s too many guys to challenge him. MS Dhoni is pretty good, but right at this moment, Jos is at the absolute peak of his powers. He understands his one-day game so well and knows his strengths inside out and just doesn’t go away from him.
In fact, Butter himself credited Dhoni with helping him maintain calm. “When you’re out there at least you can do something about it. I was just trying to soak up the pressure and imagine what MS Dhoni would do.”
🗣@josbuttler: “It’s right up there with my best performances. I was calm, I was imagining what MS Dhoni would do”
— England Cricket (@englandcricket) June 25, 2018
➡️ https://t.co/tPo4Eaf3hp#ENGvAUS pic.twitter.com/jXHQySJxh9
However, Paine’s remarks were not so well received on social media. Many Indians on Twitter didn’t take very kindly to Paine’s words, and sought to remind him of his own place in the keeper-batsman’s hierarchy
Best keeper batsman in ODIs is debatable. Worst keeper batsman in ODIs should be simple. https://t.co/4YTdc7FcUL
— cricBC (@cricBC) June 25, 2018
I guess Paine really never watch cricket matches except when he plays cricket. https://t.co/UOmyPjvAn7
— Tabrez (@its_tabrez_) June 25, 2018
Even @josbuttler knows @msdhoni Is best in the World 😏
— Shalom Beryl (@shalom_beryl) June 25, 2018
Jos buttler himself said that he was imagining to play with MSD's attitude. Now you can say who is better.?
— Vicky (@vky17msd) June 25, 2018
Prime example of Recency Bias https://t.co/7wjSfWZikM
— Arjun Mody 🇮🇳 (@arjunmody01) June 25, 2018
Comparisons btwn #Dhoni and #Buttler r amusing. Dhoni is towards end of his glorious career & Buttler is yet to reach his prime. Don't even understand the point of comparing the two & claim one is better than other! 🤦
— Nishant Mehta (@nish_90) June 25, 2018
On what basis was Tim Paine made the captain of the Australian team? Because he's a wicketkeeper?
— Jeet V. (@Jeetv27) June 24, 2018
Not everyone can be M.S. Dhoni!#ENGvAUS
But there was some who defended him as well.
Don't think anything Paine said is wrong here
— Abhay🇧🇷 (@ImAbhay3) June 25, 2018
“Right now, at the moment, he’d have to be the best white-ball wicket-keeper batsman in the world. I don’t think there’s too many guys to challenge him. MS Dhoni is pretty good, but right at this moment, Jos is at the absolute peak" https://t.co/cm8us8xzFN
And a timely reminder
And Taylor’s best? https://t.co/2JoOCJ9zLW
— Women's CricZone (@WomensCricZone) June 25, 2018
In conclusion...
Tim Paine : MS Dhoni is pretty good, but right at this moment, Jos is at the absolute peak of his powers.@josbuttler: It’s right up there with my best performances. I was calm, I was imagining what MS Dhoni would do #Dhoni - Wicket Keeper - Batsman of the era.
— Stanley Stephen (@stanley_twts) June 25, 2018