fire alarm

After blaze in Mumbai’s Kamala Mills claims 14, experts push for regular fire safety audits

Mumbai municipality belatedly swings into action, says it will inspect all 35 or so restaurants in the complex.

Hours after a devastating fire at a rooftop restaurant at Kamala Mills in Mumbai claimed 14 lives, the city’s official machinery swung into belated action.

The Mumbai police filed a case against the restaurant’s promoters for culpable homicide for not ensuring the safety of the premises, while the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation said that it would inspect all 35 or so restaurants in the complex located in the Lower Parel area to ensure that they comply with fire safety norms.

Citizens, however, are asking why they did not do this before the tragedy.

Lower Parel has grown into a food and entertainment hub over the last 15 years, but without the infrastructure necessary to support up. But in addition to the narrow roads and inadequate transport systems, the area also needs to pay more attention to matters that often escape attention. Fire safety, experts say, should be a priority area.

With Mumbai’s entertainment scene expanding rapidly, the city’s fire department must conduct more regular fire safety audits, especially in older buildings, said Pankaj Joshi of the Urban Development and Research Institute based in Mumbai.

A growing problem in Mumbai, particularly in restaurant hubs like Lower Parel, where there are old mill buildings, and in the heritage buildings of the southern Fort area, is that these old structures are being retrofitted to meet modern requirements. The most common reason for fires in these buildings is not from kitchen accidents but because of short circuits in lighting or air conditioning systems. When old meters get overloaded with higher demand, the system can heat up and cause a fire, Joshi said.

“There needs to be a thorough audit of most buildings that have been retrofitted,” he said.

Although several of the buildings in Lower Parel are new, in Kamala Mills at least, the oldest building dates to the late 1990s, Joshi said. Restaurants only began to open in the compound less than five years ago. These may not follow newer building safety rules that mandate refuge areas and in-built sprinkler systems to douse the fires, he said.

“There are clear regulations for new buildings with respect to fire safety, though it takes ten to 15 years for them to actually be implemented,” said Samir D’Monte, a Mumbai-based architect. “But there’s no clear regulatory framework for old buildings.”

Where does the buck stop?

The police have filed charges against the owners of the restaurant. But D’Monte contends that role of the owners of the buildings in Kamala Mills should also be considered.

“The landlord is supposed to provide a safe premise to his tenant and the restaurant has to provide a safe premise to its guests,” D’Monte said. “But there is a bit of a grey area in who should be responsible for fire safety.”

With tenants changing every few years and unable to make large structural changes without permission, D’Monte contends that landlords should also be held responsible. While most new buildings come with fire escapes and fire padding in the stairwells and refuge areas, old buildings do not comply with these requirements.

The management of 1Above, where the fire broke out, has released a statement claiming that it had followed all fire safety regulations and had its licences in place. It also said that it conducts quarterly fire safety and crisis management training.

“This was also conducted recently for this quarter as per our vigilant practice for all our staff and managers,” the statement said. “There are over 10 fire extinguishers and adequate fire safety signatures in the premises as is required by the authorities. As part of the same fire safety protocol, the fire exit dedicated to 1Above was maintained well as per rules and regulations – a reason why we were able to evacuate persons speedily.”

The statement adds that its staff stayed on to help evacuate guests from the neighbouring Mojo’s Bistro as well.

Regular audits necessary

None of this exonerates the municipal corporation or the fire department.

In 2013, the Supreme Court asked the fire department to conduct annual fire safety audits of the city’s structures. Yet in 2016, the divisional fire officer moved the Bombay High Court to claim that it was the duty of the owner of a building to ensure fire prevention measures, not of the fire department.

“Periodic inspections are extremely critical,” Joshi said. Even if a sprinkler system or a fire extinguisher is working when the municipality grants a restaurant its licence, there is no guarantee that it will not stop working in six months. “The onus is on the authority to see systems are in place. If they are not in place, shut down the restaurant for that period and get everything working. You cannot be frivolous about these things.”

As Joshi pointed out, it is not as if fire departments in cities abroad offer these services for free. If Mumbai’s fire department were to charge for a cursory annual inspection and a more thorough one every five years, the city would be safer.

Said Joshi, “Auditing has to be regular and honest. It should not become a means for extortion. In fire management, damage to property has to be minimised, but casualties have to be zero. Other cities have been doing this for the last 100 years. It is high time we set up systems to do this too.”

Support our journalism by subscribing to Scroll+ here. We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BY 

A special shade of blue inspired these musicians to create a musical piece

Thanks to an interesting neurological condition called synesthesia.

On certain forums on the Internet, heated discussions revolve around the colour of number 9 or the sound of strawberry cupcake. And most forum members mount a passionate defence of their points of view on these topics. These posts provide insight into a lesser known, but well-documented, sensory condition called synesthesia - simply described as the cross wiring of the senses.

Synesthetes can ‘see’ music, ‘taste’ paintings, ‘hear’ emotions...and experience other sensory combinations based on their type. If this seems confusing, just pay some attention to our everyday language. It’s riddled with synesthesia-like metaphors - ‘to go green with envy’, ‘to leave a bad taste in one’s mouth’, ‘loud colours’, ‘sweet smells’ and so on.

Synesthesia is a deeply individual experience for those who have it and differs from person to person. About 80 different types of synesthesia have been discovered so far. Some synesthetes even have multiple types, making their inner experience far richer than most can imagine.

Most synesthetes vehemently maintain that they don’t consider their synesthesia to be problem that needs to be fixed. Indeed, synesthesia isn’t classified as a disorder, but only a neurological condition - one that scientists say may even confer cognitive benefits, chief among them being a heightened sense of creativity.

Pop culture has celebrated synesthetic minds for centuries. Synesthetic musicians, writers, artists and even scientists have produced a body of work that still inspires. Indeed, synesthetes often gravitate towards the arts. Eduardo is a Canadian violinist who has synesthesia. He’s, in fact, so obsessed with it that he even went on to do a doctoral thesis on the subject. Eduardo has also authored a children’s book meant to encourage latent creativity, and synesthesia, in children.

Litsa, a British violinist, sees splashes of paint when she hears music. For her, the note G is green; she can’t separate the two. She considers synesthesia to be a fundamental part of her vocation. Samara echoes the sentiment. A talented cellist from London, Samara can’t quite quantify the effect of synesthesia on her music, for she has never known a life without it. Like most synesthetes, the discovery of synesthesia for Samara was really the realisation that other people didn’t experience the world the way she did.

Eduardo, Litsa and Samara got together to make music guided by their synesthesia. They were invited by Maruti NEXA to interpret their new automotive colour - NEXA Blue. The signature shade represents the brand’s spirit of innovation and draws on the legacy of blue as the colour that has inspired innovation and creativity in art, science and culture for centuries.

Each musician, like a true synesthete, came up with a different note to represent the colour. NEXA roped in Indraneel, a composer, to tie these notes together into a harmonious composition. The video below shows how Sound of NEXA Blue was conceived.

Play

You can watch Eduardo, Litsa and Samara play the entire Sound of NEXA Blue composition in the video below.

Play

To know more about NEXA Blue and how the brand constantly strives to bring something exclusive and innovative to its customers, click here.

This article was produced by the Scroll marketing team on behalf of NEXA and not by the Scroll editorial team.